Understanding Energy Transfer: From Atoms to Photons and Beyond

  • Thread starter Thread starter JoshWolff7
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Energy
AI Thread Summary
Energy transfer occurs through conduction, convection, and radiation, with conduction involving the direct transfer of energy between molecules, convection involving the movement of air or fluids, and radiation involving the emission of photons that energize molecules. The discussion touches on the nature of light energy as photons and questions the existence of particles in quantum mechanics, asserting that particles may not be real in the traditional sense. A hypothesis is presented regarding multiple dimensions and vibrating space, prompting a reminder to focus on established questions before proposing new theories. Clarifications are made about the definitions of convection and conduction, emphasizing that convection specifically involves the movement of hot air or fluids. The thread concludes with an acknowledgment of the complexities of energy transfer and the importance of understanding foundational concepts.
JoshWolff7
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
I understand that convection, conduction, and radiation are the modes of transferring energy, but - molecularly - how does this work? Is it transferred from one atom to another? If so, why do physicists say that light energy is made of photons - particles? Referring to quantum mechanics, is it not true that there are no real such things as particles? If I was to hypothesize with the tool of parsimony, then I would say that there are many dimensions, and that the space itself can vibrate, its vibrations within itself vary in frequency and these variations make up everything...Anything wrong with that? Please prove me wrong and explain! I'm going to end this thread before I add another topic...
Thanks,
Josh
 
Physics news on Phys.org
JoshWolff7 said:
I understand that convection, conduction, and radiation are the modes of transferring energy, but - molecularly - how does this work?
Conduction: the molecules on the hot body are bouncing around more quickly than the molecules in the cold body. Bring them together, and the fast-moving molecules will hit the slow-moving ones, speeding them up while the fast-movers slow down.

Convection: just like conduction, except that it's the molecules of air around the hot body that receive the energy from the fast-moving molecules. Then the air rises and its now-faster-moving molecules heat something else up.

Radiation: light energy strikes the molecules of an object, causing them to bounce around more quickly. You could think of that as bombarding the object with photons.

Referring to quantum mechanics, is it not true that there are no real such things as particles?
No, not true.

If I was to hypothesize with the tool of parsimony, then I would say that there are many dimensions, and that the space itself can vibrate, its vibrations within itself vary in frequency and these variations make up everything...Anything wrong with that? Please prove me wrong and explain! I'm going to end this thread before I add another topic...

You're getting ahead of yourself here... Don't go hypothesizing new answers to questions until you know which questions already have answers.
 
Nugatory said:
You're getting ahead of yourself here... Don't go hypothesizing new answers to questions until you know which questions already have answers.

That notice should be nailed at the top of every thread!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Just to precise a bit Nugatory's answer:
Nugatory said:
Convection: just like conduction, except that it's the molecules of air around the hot body that receive the energy from the fast-moving molecules. Then the air rises and its now-faster-moving molecules heat something else up.
Actually, only the part where "air rises" is convection. The body-to-air and air-to-air parts are still conduction. Convection appears whenever energy moves with the object (e.g. hot liquid moving up due to pressure difference... and that's the extend of my knowledge for natural cases of convection)

Nugatory said:
Radiation: light energy strikes the molecules of an object, causing them to bounce around more quickly. You could think of that as bombarding the object with photons.
Another part of radiation is the light (mostly infrared at usual temperatures) emitted by an object, which uses up some fraction of the molecules' energy. So any warm object without conduction or incoming radiation will eventually cool down.
 
Thank you everyone!
 
So I know that electrons are fundamental, there's no 'material' that makes them up, it's like talking about a colour itself rather than a car or a flower. Now protons and neutrons and quarks and whatever other stuff is there fundamentally, I want someone to kind of teach me these, I have a lot of questions that books might not give the answer in the way I understand. Thanks
Back
Top