How to Approach an Op-Amp Homework Problem with Earthed Terminals?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on solving an op-amp homework problem involving earthed terminals. Key points include the understanding that no current flows into the input terminals of an ideal op-amp and that in a negative feedback configuration, both input terminals must have the same voltage. Participants clarify that if one terminal is at a fixed voltage, the other must match it to maintain zero voltage difference. A participant successfully derives the output voltage using the correct equations, confirming their understanding of the circuit dynamics. The conversation emphasizes the importance of feedback in maintaining voltage equality at the op-amp inputs.
thereddevils
Messages
436
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



See attachment.

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



I am not familiar with questions like this. The usual op-amp i see have either of the terminals earthed so i need some hints to get started. Thanks.
 

Attachments

  • electronics.jpg
    electronics.jpg
    19.3 KB · Views: 406
Physics news on Phys.org


Hint: The important things to remember about the (ideal) op-amp is that
1. No current flows into or out of the input terminals.
2. In a negative feedback situation, both input terminals will always be at the same voltage (no voltage difference).

That being the case, what can you say about the voltage at the (-) input?
How about the current in the resistors?
 


gneill said:
Hint: The important things to remember about the (ideal) op-amp is that
1. No current flows into or out of the input terminals.
2. In a negative feedback situation, both input terminals will always be at the same voltage (no voltage difference).

That being the case, what can you say about the voltage at the (-) input?
How about the current in the resistors?

Thanks Gneill for your reply.

Ok, since the input impedance of the op-amp is very high, the current flowing through the 20 k ohm resistor is the same as the one through the 100 k ohm resistor.

I am not sure about point 2. Why are the voltage of the input terminals the same? How do i set up the equations? V- = 8V and V+ = 4V ??
 


thereddevils said:
Thanks Gneill for your reply.

Ok, since the input impedance of the op-amp is very high, the current flowing through the 20 k ohm resistor is the same as the one through the 100 k ohm resistor.

Good.

I am not sure about point 2. Why are the voltage of the input terminals the same? How do i set up the equations? V- = 8V and V+ = 4V ??

8V is not the same as 4V.

Because the op-amp has very high gain (infinite for the ideal op-amp), any difference in voltage between the V- and V+ input terminals would be magnified infinitely at the output terminal. In practical terms, the output would swing towards one of the power supply rails.

This doesn't happen in a properly configured amplifier circuit with feedback, because the feedback path acts to keep the differential voltage at zero. Thus V- = V+. In your circuit, one of the inputs is tied to a fixed voltage supply. What should you conclude?
 


gneill said:
8V is not the same as 4V.

Because the op-amp has very high gain (infinite for the ideal op-amp), any difference in voltage between the V- and V+ input terminals would be magnified infinitely at the output terminal. In practical terms, the output would swing towards one of the power supply rails.

I understand this.

This doesn't happen in a properly configured amplifier circuit with feedback, because the feedback path acts to keep the differential voltage at zero. Thus V- = V+. In your circuit, one of the inputs is tied to a fixed voltage supply. What should you conclude?

The difference between V+ and V- is zero if connected with a negative feedback resistor? Is V- = 8V and V+ = 4V? I am still confused with the potential difference across the positive and negative input terminals.
 


thereddevils said:
The difference between V+ and V- is zero if connected with a negative feedback resistor? Is V- = 8V and V+ = 4V? I am still confused with the potential difference across the positive and negative input terminals.

What's to be confused about? For an ideal op-amp in a circuit with negative feedback, the difference is zero. 8V and 4V is not a difference of zero volts, it's a difference of 4 volts.

Set the difference between the inputs to zero. One of the inputs is tied to +4v by a fixed supply voltage. What must the voltage at the other input terminal be?
 


gneill said:
What's to be confused about? For an ideal op-amp in a circuit with negative feedback, the difference is zero. 8V and 4V is not a difference of zero volts, it's a difference of 4 volts.

Set the difference between the inputs to zero. One of the inputs is tied to +4v by a fixed supply voltage. What must the voltage at the other input terminal be?

What a miss!

Obviously, the voltage of the upper input terminal is 4V and having the same current flow,

(8-4)/20k = (4-Vo)/100k

Vo=-16V

Am i right?
 


Bravo!
 


gneill said:
Bravo!

Thanks for all the help! Cheers.
 
Back
Top