How to Distribute Gas Atoms in Two Boxes?

villiami
Messages
27
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


N atoms are in two boxes, box A: volume=V, and box B: volume=3V. (Assume a atoms make up a low density perfect gas).

1) How many ways can n be chosen, where n=(number of atoms in box A)?

2) Each atom if allocated a spatial state. Assuming that the number of available states within a volume V is proportional to that volume, write down an expression for the total number of microstates (Ω) present in the macrostate specified by n.

3) By optimising Ω determine the most likely number of gas atoms present in A and B. What are these values when N = 100?

4) Find the probability of the most likely distribution.


The attempt at a solution
1) 2^N right? (N binary choices)
2) ??
3) Clearly 25 in A, 75 in B. But need to answer 2) to derive it their way.
4) ??

Thanks,
Villiami
 
Physics news on Phys.org
First of all, #1: yes there are 2^N ways of dividing the N atoms up between the two boxes. But how many of those ways put n of the atoms in box A? (Hint: it's not all of them)
 
diazona said:
First of all, #1: yes there are 2^N ways of dividing the N atoms up between the two boxes. But how many of those ways put n of the atoms in box A? (Hint: it's not all of them)

So #microstates(A) = N! / n!(N-n)! [Putting n in A]
but isn't num(B) = N! / (N-n)!n! as well? [putting N-n into B]

I still don't see how to weight them according to volumes..
(thanks for the help so far!)
 
villiami said:
So #microstates(A) = N! / n!(N-n)! [Putting n in A]
but isn't num(B) = N! / (N-n)!n! as well? [putting N-n into B]
Yep, that's exactly right... these numbers are not weighted by volume. Once you pick a particular set of particles to put in box A, all the rest have to go in box B - you don't have any choice left. So each way of putting n particles in box A corresponds to exactly one way of putting N-n particles in box B. Now do you see why you'd expect those two results to be the same?

For part 2, it says each atom is allocated a spatial state. In practice, these would be quantum states, but if you like you can imagine that the volume V is divided into little "miniboxes" of a constant size, say U (or whatever you want to call it), and that each atom goes into a minibox. The total number of miniboxes in box A is V/U - you can give this number a label, say C (again, call it whatever you want). Now, you have n atoms in box A which have to be distributed into the C miniboxes. Each way of distributing them is one microstate of box A. So how many microstates are there for box A alone? What about for box B alone? And once you've found those two numbers, what's the total number of microstates for the entire system (A+B)?
 
To solve this, I first used the units to work out that a= m* a/m, i.e. t=z/λ. This would allow you to determine the time duration within an interval section by section and then add this to the previous ones to obtain the age of the respective layer. However, this would require a constant thickness per year for each interval. However, since this is most likely not the case, my next consideration was that the age must be the integral of a 1/λ(z) function, which I cannot model.
Back
Top