I Ideal working gas for a Stirling engine

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the ideal working gas for Stirling engines, highlighting hydrogen and helium due to their high thermal conductivities. There is debate over whether a gas with high or low thermal capacity is preferable, with the argument that a lower thermal capacity would allow for quicker heating and cooling, thus enhancing efficiency. It is suggested that the optimal gas should maximize the ratio of thermal conductivity to heat capacity. While hydrogen has superior thermal properties, it poses challenges due to its permeability through metals, whereas helium is inert and easier to contain. Ultimately, both gases can achieve similar efficiencies in Stirling engines, but their system designs would differ significantly.
cmb
Messages
1,128
Reaction score
128
I was reading around Stirling engines and there's something I am not sure about, can't see a logical explanation.

So the ideal gases discussed are hydrogen and helium on account of their higher thermal conductivities.

But I am unclear on what motivation there would be to use hydrogen which has a significantly higher thermal capacity than other gases.

Is it better to have a gas with a high or a low thermal capacity in a heat engine?

I'd have assumed you'd want a gas with the lowest possible thermal heat capacity, because that would require the least amount of energy transfer to heat it up and cool it down (i.e., would be quicker) yet still deliver the same mean effective pressure as the working volumes change. (Ideal gas laws law still applies, irrespective of heat capacity.)

I mean, if hydrogen and helium have the same thermal conductivity but hydrogen has 3 times (ish) the heat capacity, then it'd take 3 times as long to heat up and cool down the hydrogen than helium.

So in fact, the best gas for a Stirling engine is one where the ratio of thermal conductivity to heat capacity is the highest, not one that has a high value for both characteristics.

Is that right?
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
There are a large number of variables, of which you identified two. I suggest getting one or two books on the subject, and enjoy some good reading. Two good resources, both of which are currently available from Amazon, are:

Stirling Engine Design and Feasibility for Automotive Use, edited by M.J. Collie, 1979.
Air Engines The History, Science, and Reality of the Perfect Engine, by T. Finkelstein and A.J. Organ, 2009.

From the Collie book: "Hydrogen is the best because it has the highest thermal conductivity, the lowest viscosity, and a low heat capacity ... However, hydrogen permeates through metals ... On the other hand, helium is inert and can be permanently contained in metal. It has an even lower volumetric heat capacity than hydrogen and almost as good a thermal conductivity, but the viscosity is twice that of hydrogen. Michels [76e] showed that a Stirling engine can be designed to use either hydrogen, helium, or nitrogen all with the same efficiency for the same temperature. However, the heater, cooler, and regenerator of each engine would be designed quite differently."

Would it surprise you to know that once upon a time, I also was interested in Stirling engines? Enough to buy books on the subject, but not enough to actually try to build one.
 
I need to calculate the amount of water condensed from a DX cooling coil per hour given the size of the expansion coil (the total condensing surface area), the incoming air temperature, the amount of air flow from the fan, the BTU capacity of the compressor and the incoming air humidity. There are lots of condenser calculators around but they all need the air flow and incoming and outgoing humidity and then give a total volume of condensed water but I need more than that. The size of the...
Thread 'Why work is PdV and not (P+dP)dV in an isothermal process?'
Let's say we have a cylinder of volume V1 with a frictionless movable piston and some gas trapped inside with pressure P1 and temperature T1. On top of the piston lay some small pebbles that add weight and essentially create the pressure P1. Also the system is inside a reservoir of water that keeps its temperature constant at T1. The system is in equilibrium at V1, P1, T1. Now let's say i put another very small pebble on top of the piston (0,00001kg) and after some seconds the system...
Back
Top