Identifying Points of Discontinuity in a Continuous Function

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on identifying points of discontinuity in the given piecewise function. Participants agree that x = 4 and x = -4 are points of discontinuity, with x = 4 being a removable discontinuity due to the limit not existing at that point. The confusion arises around the interpretation of the function's domain, particularly regarding the values of x. Clarifications emphasize that for continuity, three conditions must be met, and both identified points fail to meet these criteria. Overall, the consensus is that the function has two points of discontinuity at x = 4 and x = -4.
courtrigrad
Messages
1,236
Reaction score
2
If you are given:

f(x) = \left\{\begin{array}{cc} (3x)/ (x+4),&\mbox{ if } x\leq 4 , x != -4 & \sqrt{x-3}, &\mbox{ if } x > 4 (3x is numerator and x+4 is denominator)

find the points of discontinuity of the function. Identify each type. Since x != 4(not equal to 4, don't know how to put not equal sign) , then this is a point of discontinuity. Hence is this a removavble discontinuity (the only discontinuity?) because you get find an extended function?

Thanks a lot

PS: Is there any good LaTex tutorial. As you can see I need to work on it!
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
I think it has 2 points of discontinuity.First is '-4',obviously.

Find the second.

Daniel.

BTW,i think you meant x\neq -4
 
x = 3 the other one because of domain restrictions?
 
Okay,are u guessing?U have to be sure of your answer...Why is the function not continuous in "3"??

Daniel.
 
You say "Since x!= 4 (not equal to 4, don't know how to put not equal sign) , then this is a point of discontinuity." but the formula does NOT say x can't be 4, it says x can't be -4. You may be confusing 4 and -4.
 
3 things must exist for a function to be continuous at a point

(a) lim f(x) exists
x--> a

(b) lim f(x) = f(a)
x-->a

(c) f(a) is defined

So

lim f(x) does not exist. Hence 4 is a point discontinuity
x--> 4

lim f(x) does not exist. Hence -3 is a point discontinuity.
x--> -4

Is this right?

Thanks
 
Last edited:
any help is appreciated

thanks
 
courtrigrad said:
3 things must exist for a function to be continuous at a point

(a) lim f(x) exists
x--> a

(b) lim f(x) = f(a)
x-->a

(c) f(a) is defined

So

lim f(x) does not exist. Hence 4 is a point discontinuity
x--> 4

lim f(x) does not exist. Hence -3 is a point discontinuity.
x--> -4

Is this right?

Thanks

You're correct that 4 is a point of discontinuity since limx->4 does not exist.

For the second part, I think you meant, hence -4 is a point of discontinuity? You're right that the limx->-4 does not exist, but also f(-4) is undefined. So either reason gives you that there's a discontinuity at x=-4.

Yes, I find according to the question that there are 2 points of discontinuity, 4 and -4.
 
Hey,points o discontinuity are in general "x" values.Tell me why the "x=-3" is a point of discontinuity...

You've already been answered to the problem...

Daniel.
 
Back
Top