I'm trying to understand compressive strength and Euler stress for columns

6 replies · 2K views · last reply
lee123456789
Messages
90
Reaction score
5
A cloumn has a compressive strength of 220MPa, but its Euler yeild stress is 350MPa. its compressive strength is less than its euler stress.
what does this mean?
 
Last edited:
That the column will fail due to compression before it can buckle.
 
FEAnalyst said:
That the column will fail due to compression before it can buckle.
The compression strength is the downward forces applied resistances.

so it will fail dowards before it will fail sideways basically?
 
lee123456789 said:
The compression strength is the downward forces applied resistances.

so it will fail dowards before it will fail sideways basically?
https://dailycivil.com/types-column-failure/

Two photos of concrete columns after compression failure: the left column bulges outward with horizontal cracking and spalling, the right column has its surface broken and crumbling, captioned Compression Failure.


Diagram of a slender column under load: left, a straight column between plates; right, the same column bowed sideways with a downward arrow. Two photos show buckled, deformed columns.
 
berkeman said:
Thanks
i was getting comfused because both had stress in them so thought it was the same
compressive strength = downward stregth resistance
Euler Stress = sideways to buckling

so by looking at the strength (220) and euler stress (350), it buckles higher than it does when compressing the column.
220 - 350 = 130MPa
is that normal for column?
 
in the reading material it uses compressive strength as the same value they use for critial stress for the column.
 
lee123456789 said:
Thanks
i was getting comfused because both had stress in them so thought it was the same
compressive strength = downward stregth resistance
Euler Stress = sideways to buckling
Force aligned with or perpendicular to the main axis of the column could be more accurate terms, since we not always have a vertical column that is supporting a load on top of it.