I'm wondering, how many people would have a problem dating someone like this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter user299792458
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around a survey about dating preferences, particularly regarding individuals with disabilities, exemplified by a woman with a prosthetic leg. Participants express varied opinions on dating amputees, with many emphasizing that personality and inner qualities are more important than physical attributes. Some participants share personal anecdotes about dating experiences and perceptions of attractiveness, while others discuss societal judgments and safety in the workplace, referencing legal obligations for employers to ensure safe working conditions. The conversation shifts to the implications of a specific incident involving a woman who lost her leg in a workplace accident, with participants debating her intelligence and awareness of safety risks. Overall, the thread highlights differing attitudes towards physical disabilities in dating and the complexities of personal attraction versus societal expectations.

Would you have a problem with this?

  • You wouldn't date her because of THAT

    Votes: 4 5.4%
  • You wouldn't care about THAT

    Votes: 66 89.2%
  • You PREFER people like that

    Votes: 4 5.4%

  • Total voters
    74
user299792458
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
This is basically just a survey, I'm not trying to make fun of anyone here. I've done these surveys on some other forums, and I'm wondering whether the results will be about the same here. If this is considered an innappropriate question here, please forgive me.

http://www.imagecraze.com/uploads/40653_.jpg
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Why did you choose 2's and 9's? They seem so far apart, did you use both hands? Wouldn't 2323111223 be easier?

And no I would not, anyone who still uses a cassette player is obviously not technologically advanced enough for my tastes.
 
Definitely but then we have COSHH and HASAW acts. So this is pretty much what we have to do by law.

COSHH


http://www.hse.gov.uk/coshh/

HASAW

http://www.dmccormick.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/coursecontent/02/2_03.htm

Employers have a responsibility to their employees to provide them with a safe, healthy place for them to work in, and safe systems of work to enable them to do their jobs safely. This includes the provision of information and training. Employees in turn must:

* Take reasonable care to preserve the health and safety of themselves and others who may be affected by anything that they do or fail to do whilst at work
* Co-operate with their employer in the operation of any safety systems and equipment put in place to comply with legislation
* Report immediately to a responsible person any hazardous situation they may come across
* Not remove or interfere with any safety equipment or device put in place to comply with legislation

This applies equally to employees in their own workplace and to visiting and temporary workers.

:smile: and she's fit anyway:biggrin: :-p
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Whats that movie about the guy who is dating the girl whose prosthetic leg is constantly falling off? lol

btw I voted that I wouldn't mind, of course. :P, the prosthetic leg wouldn't matter at all. Although I probably would have to buy her an ipod.
 
Last edited:
I would hot have a problem dating Candace or any other woman amputee, on the basis of being an amputee. It is irrelevant.

What counts is the inner person.
 
Astronuc said:
What counts is the inner person.
:approve:

But in my opinion, this person is good looking as well :smile:
Her good-lookingness is a bias to your test :wink:
 
humanino said:
But in my opinion, this person is good looking as well :smile:
Her good-lookingness is a bias to your test :wink:
Candace is certainly an attractive woman.

However, I've known a lot of attractive women, but I wouldn't date them.

But for me, it's an academic exercise. I've been married to the same woman for nearly 25 yrs, or 26 years if one counts the year we lived together as time and opportunity would permit.
 
humanino said:
:approve:

But in my opinion, this person is good looking as well :smile:
Her good-lookingness is a bias to your test :wink:

Agreed but if she gave me the nod I wouldn't be one to turn her down for a date, call me shallow or call me human? your choice :smile:

Dating and relationships are not the same thing, a date is a reconnaissance mission.
 
Last edited:
Schrodinger's Dog said:
Dating and relationships are not the same thing, a date is a reconnaissance mission.
This subtelty is way above my head, I don't understand ! :redface: Can you be more explicit please ?
 
  • #10
A date is a brief encounter in which one has the opportunity to learn about the other person. One can engage in successive dates with the same person and can develop into a relationship. A relationship is an evolutionary process.
 
  • #11
Schrodinger's Dog said:
Dating and relationships are not the same thing, a date is a reconnaissance mission.

I now have new advice for my friends :biggrin:Back to the OP. I would have no problem in dating someone like her.
 
  • #12
humanino said:
This subtelty is way above my head, I don't understand ! :redface: Can you be more explicit please ?

A relationship is something more than a reconnaissance mission IMHO.
 
  • #13
Astronuc said:
A date is a brief encounter in which one has the opportunity to learn about the other person. One can engage in successive dates with the same person and can develop into a relationship. A relationship is an evolutionary process.
Thank you Astronuc. :smile:
Schrodinger's Dog said:
A relationship is something more than a reconnaissance mission IMHO.
The part I really did not get is exactly the "reconnaissance mission" thing. But after browsing google, I realize that my problem only came from a similar wording in french. Sorry for my stupidity :redface:
 
  • #14
Nope, couldn't do it...I don't date women. And I'm not really into people who are really crazy about things like sports either, and she looks like she's one of those people who's really into sports, too.
 
  • #15
A prosthetic leg is pretty uncontroversial. A much more telling question would be to ask who would date a girl who had her breasts amputated. (I wouldn't mind, personality is where it's at, well to a point, if she looked like a gremlin I'd probably not.)
 
  • #16
verty said:
A prosthetic leg is pretty uncontroversial. A much more telling question would be to ask who would date a girl who had her breasts amputated. (I wouldn't mind, personality is where it's at, well to a point, if she looked like a gremlin I'd probably not.)

Chicks can get their breasts amputated
 
  • #18
I've heard of at-risk women having the procedure in the interest of future health. I don't know how prevalent it is though, nor do I know whether or to what degree it is effective.
 
  • #19
From Astronuc's article:

Another reason for performing a mastectomy is when a breast contains widespread ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS). DCIS is a pre-cancerous condition, and has the potential to become invasive cancer if left in place. It is typically discovered when a suspicious mammogram alerts your doctor to perform a biopsy.
 
  • #20
No problem here. She's hot enough to turn my head, though that says nothing about who she is as a person.

(BTW, I would bet money that her attractiveness factored into her getting the spot. i.e. we're reacting exactly as expected.)
 
  • #21
I'd feel pretty privelaged to have a person like this date me. By the way, what the hell is the point in this?
 
  • #22
dontdisturbmycircles said:
Whats that movie about the guy who is dating the girl whose prosthetic leg is constantly falling off? lol

btw I voted that I wouldn't mind, of course. :P, the prosthetic leg wouldn't matter at all. Although I probably would have to buy her an ipod.

I don't know about a movie, but there's a story about a woman with a wooden leg: Good Country People.
 
  • #23
Kurdt said:
I'd feel pretty privelaged to have a person like this date me. By the way, what the hell is the point in this?

The OP says its for a survey.
 
  • #24
A complete mastectomy is now only routinely performed in adanced cases of breast cancer. In early stages, a lumpectomy is becoming an increasingly popular option. Also, in the case of mastectomy, a flap of skin and the nipple is often left so that reconstructive surgery may be performed at a later date. The nipple is grafted onto the lower abdomen. In some cases a new nipple is created and the areola is "tatooed" on. Plastic surgery is amazing.

As for the OP, I would not have a problem with an amputee or someone confined to a wheelchair. My first boyfriend had been crippled in a motorcycle accident a year before I met him although he was able to move about in moderation, it wasn't until a few years later that his condition deteriorated to the point that he could no longer walk. He had such a great personality that he always had women chasing after him.
 
Last edited:
  • #25
Moonbear said:
Nope, couldn't do it...I don't date women. And I'm not really into people who are really crazy about things like sports either, and she looks like she's one of those people who's really into sports, too.
:smile:

...[/color]
 
  • #26
The big question is: Maybe some of you HAVE been on a date with someone who had an artificial leg and they just didn't tell you?
 
  • #27
Her prosthetic leg doesn't put me off. It's her slightly large chin that'd count against her if she asked me out.

If she was a lil cutie with a prosthetic leg then I'd be all for it.
 
  • #28
sure. assuming she wasn't a jerk. I value the inside(possibly because I am "ugly"(by the typical societal definition, meaning if you don't have a 6 pack and a tan and clear skin then your ugly)
 
  • #29
rock4christ said:
(by the typical societal definition, meaning if you don't have a 6 pack and a tan and clear skin then your ugly)

Gee, there sure are a lot of "ugly" people around then. :rolleyes:
 
  • #30
I certainly think the carbon fibre is less repellent than an earlier type prosthetic. Will anyone see a problem whatsoever, if technology comes up with superhuman robotic prosthetics? Actually it may even be more desirable than flesh and blood limbs, yeah?
 
Last edited:
  • #31
cyrusabdollahi said:
That clip had jerry springer written all over it.
I don't own a TV, and I never have. I recalled reading something about the contest, and figured it might be germaine, since people were discussing the woman in the photo's overall attractiveness.

I think reading about Stern's antics is probably more amusing than actually watching them. Looking for a clean text-only link, I found references to other gags. Example: the concept of a Robospanker is amusing, but I imagine it'd be rather banal to watch. The cognitive dissonance on that one is good for perhaps five seconds of humor.
 
  • #32
twisting_edge said:
I think reading about Stern's antics is probably more amusing than actually watching them. Looking for a clean text-only link, I found references to other gags. Example: the concept of a Robospanker is amusing, but I imagine it'd be rather banal to watch. The cognitive dissonance on that one is good for perhaps five seconds of humor.
I must admit, I don't find Stern amusing. A friend watches the program at home and listens to the radio on the way to work. I caught some it when we road together. It bewilders me that people find Stern's program entertaining.
 
  • #33
rock4christ said:
sure. assuming she wasn't a jerk. I value the inside(possibly because I am "ugly"(by the typical societal definition, meaning if you don't have a 6 pack and a tan and clear skin then your ugly)
After watching MTV, I thought those things made you "Jersey" - which I took to mean a form of insult handed out by New Yorkers :biggrin: :-p
 
  • #34
The prosthetic used in the picture was on purpose to shock young people to think about safety. Many prosthetics look like the real thing but some do not.
However, this is a most beautiful woman, with or without her leg, and with or without a realist looking prosthetic. From elsewhere, it obvious she is also very intelligent. If compatible and if I met everything she was seeking in man, I would be delighted to have the privilege of dating and marrying her.
 
  • #35
Gentleman said:
The prosthetic used in the picture was on purpose to shock young people to think about safety. Many prosthetics look like the real thing but some do not.
However, this is a most beautiful woman, with or without her leg, and with or without a realist looking prosthetic. From elsewhere, it obvious she is also very intelligent. If compatible and if I met everything she was seeking in man, I would be delighted to have the privilege of dating and marrying her.

Actually a modern fully functional prosthesis looks exactly like the one in the picture. A prosthesis that is manufactured for cosmetic purposes is mostly passive and will not function any better than a peg leg. Regardless she is truly a beautiful young woman.
 
Last edited:
  • #36
Id date her.. she is gorgeous.. assuming she wasnt a psycho.
 
  • #37
I wouldn't date her because of her deficiency elsewhere.
That wasn't an option in the poll.
 
  • #38
arildno said:
I wouldn't date her because of her deficiency elsewhere.
That wasn't an option in the poll.

Could you explain this? What is her deficiency elsewhere and do you mean big t*ts or a fine old ass :smile: etc.

I'd give her a roll in the hay, but then I'm less discriminatory these days.
 
  • #39
I would have no qualms about it. W might thrash me around a bit if I tried, though. :rolleyes:
For her own sense of well-being, however, she would have to hide my toolbox.
 
  • #40
Gentleman said:
The prosthetic used in the picture was on purpose to shock young people to think about safety. Many prosthetics look like the real thing but some do not.
Yes, the prosthetic used in the photo is an athletic prosthetic, probably not something most people would wear all the time. She also has a very realistic looking prosthetic which she wears.
Gentleman said:
From elsewhere, it obvious she is also very intelligent.
From WHERE? Is this supposed to be a joke or something? Since when is thinking that it's completely safe to walk over a moving conveyor belt just because everyone else is doing it considered intelligent?
 
  • #41
user299792458 said:
Yes, the prosthetic used in the photo is an athletic prosthetic, probably not something most people would wear all the time. She also has a very realistic looking prosthetic which she wears.

From WHERE? Is this supposed to be a joke or something? Since when is thinking that it's completely safe to walk over a moving conveyor belt just because everyone else is doing it considered intelligent?
Intelligence does not necessarily guarantee common sense. How the accident happened is not described. Perhaps she took a risk and lost.

Of course, from the evidence presented, we cannot know intelligent the woman is.
 
  • #42
Astronuc said:
Intelligence does not necessarily guarantee common sense. How the accident happened is not described. Perhaps she took a risk and lost.

Of course, from the evidence presented, we cannot know intelligent the woman is.

Here are some of the things that she either said (I'm paraphrasing, since I don't remember the exact wording, but the meaning remains exactly the same) or that were written about her (emphasis mine):

Candace had NO IDEA she could get hurt at her summer job (she was working at a damn FACTORY for crying out loud, I knew factories aren't exactly safe since I was a little kid).

There were adults working at the mill, I thought they were looking after me (people go to war at 18, she was already 21).

I just trusted the company and thought that if there was any possible danger in using the shortcut, it would've been pointed out.

Everyone used the shortcut and no one said anything about it, so I assumed it was completely safe.

"(Trainees) were made to believe that the workplace was safer than it really was. The trainer just played the video, left the room, came back when it was finished, rewound the tape and left -- no discussion! So we thought safety wasn't important -- that the training was a waste of time!"

"anyone and everyone walked over top of this conveyor belt. I can't even count how many times a day without even looking down to see if it was moving or on or what was going on and one day I was walking through there and I went to cross over and put my foot down at exactly the wrong place at exactly the wrong time."
 
  • #43
Your point is well made! Oops!

I guess this supports that there are some young adults who do not know how to work and how to work safely. What young people really need to know may have never been taught them.
 
  • #44
Gentleman said:
Your point is well made! Oops!

I guess this supports that there are some young adults who do not know how to work and how to work safely. What young people really need to know may have never been taught them.
Yeah... I find her statements to be pretty shocking actually. I just can't wrap my mind around the fact that a (presumably non-retarded) 21-year-old would say such things. I remember when I was 12 I already knew very well that I had to look out for myself, I didn't even trust close relatives to look out for me, even when they were nearby. But this girl expected adults who worked at the factory to look after her. Excuse me, but wasn't she an adult herself? And the stuff she said about not knowing that she could get hurt at a f*cking factory, really, it just boggles my mind... I can understand that a person might KNOWINGLY take a risk and lose. BUT, she DID NOT even know that she was taking a risk! It's kind of sad actually. She even admitted that she was being payed big bucks while flirting with the guys and hanging out in the break room longer than she should. Here's something else she said, "I didn’t have any other worries than thinking about my back-to-school outfit, the cute guy at work and getting out of Mirimichi and back to Fredericton where there were more cute guys,” Another arcticle said that one of the first questions she later asked her doctor, was, "Will boys still like me?" Jeez...

The factory closed off that shortcut over the belt, of course, and obviously they had to repair that conveyor. I think they also stopped hiring students for the summer, and they were fined $10,000, all because of this clown, who had no idea she could get hurt. Come to think of it, maybe she deserved this harsh lesson she'll never forget. It could have been MUCH worse.


Anyway, what did you mean when you said that "From elsewhere, it obvious she is also very intelligent"?
 
Last edited:
  • #45
Here's something else she said, "I didn’t have any other worries than thinking about my back-to-school outfit, the cute guy at work and getting out of Mirimichi and back to Fredericton where there were more cute guys,” Another article said that one of the first questions she later asked her doctor, was, "Will boys still like me?" Jeez...
:rolleyes: Not someone I'd be interested in dating.

I have worked with people who did not understand the danger of industrial or construction areas. I have seen people nearly get killed.
 
  • #46
Astronuc said:
:rolleyes: Not someone I'd be interested in dating.
LOL! As I read her story, I noticed that she mentioned her parents, her friends, her co-workers, but she never ever mentioned how her boyfriend reacted to the accident! At first, I thought maybe she had a girlfriend instead of a boyfriend, but then I read another article about her, which said that she asked her doctor if boys will still like her. And later, I saw that other article which mentioned how she thought about boys and her back-to-school outfit. Oh, here's something I forgot to mention (emphasis added):

"One of the first questions Candace Carnahan asked her doctor after her left leg was amputated below the knee was: "Will boys still like me?"

The university student laughs today when you ask her for the answer to that question.

Yes, she says modestly, although she's too busy criss-crossing the country, talking to young people about safety in the workplace, to have much time for serious romance." (Ok, really, how busy can she be? Does that mean airline pilots don't have girlfriends or wives? they're busy traveling the world too, aren't they?)


Psss... I think she's a whore... Maybe she should go out with another conveyor belt, the first one had a big crush on her, didn't it?



Here's another exert from that article:


Carnahan recounted how her foot got caught in a small opening in the conveyor belt, how she screamed and how a man pressed the stop button on the machine.

She may have been in shock, but Carnahan said, "I remember every second being caught there." She felt a burning pain in her foot, but refused to look down to see how badly injured she was.

Instead, she focused on the faces of the co-workers who looked on as she remained trapped there for 25 minutes.

Many of them were men, many of them crying and throwing up, their faces white and pale.

People frantically asked where her parents were because both work for the paper mill. Fortunately, said Carnahan, her mother was off and was shopping because she wouldn't have been able to bear the sight of her injured daughter. Her father was brought to the mill and passed out when he saw her.

Carnahan was taken to Miramichi Hospital and, when she awoke the next day, her foot was bandaged and she didn't feel any pain.

It wasn't a good sign.
 
Last edited:
  • #47
user299792458 said:
Psss... I think she's a whore...

I think that's quite enough. Really, let's stop with the judgment.
 
  • #48
But check this out:

The plant she worked at hired the children of its employees for summer jobs that paid $24 an hour and students were excited to be working there.

Can you imagine getting paid $24 an hour for pushing paper around with a broom (which is what she did, according to another article)?

It was Aug. 11, 1999, and it started out like any other day, said Carnahan. Her father made her pancakes for breakfast...

Well, that's sweet, guess she had a loving father. Why wasn't she making pancakes for him though?
 
Last edited:
  • #49
user299792458 said:
But check this out:



Can you imagine getting paid $24 an hour for pushing paper around with a broom (which is what she did, according to another article)?



Well, that's sweet, guess she had a loving father. Why wasn't she making pancakes for him though?

What's your problem? I certainly wouldn't like to date someone as judgemental and apparently disrespectful as you.
 
  • #50
user299792458 said:
Can you imagine getting paid $24 an hour for pushing paper around with a broom (which is what she did, according to another article)?

That happens everywhere you. The whole purpose is to give some money to students, but get them to work for it a little. More like a scholarship program if anything just not titled as so.

Get over yourself.
 

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
28
Views
11K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
25
Views
10K
Replies
13
Views
9K
Replies
65
Views
13K
Replies
56
Views
7K
Back
Top