# Imaginary roots

## Homework Statement

If both roots of the equation ax^2 + x + c - a = 0 are imaginary and c > -1, then:

Ans: 3a < 2+4c

## Homework Equations

Discriminant < 0 for img roots
Vieta

## The Attempt at a Solution

1-4(a)(c-a)<0
4ac > 4a^2 + 1
Minimum value of 4a^2 + 1 is 1 so
4ac>1

I can't think of anything beyond this and I have no idea how to incorporate c>-1 into my equations.

HallsofIvy
Homework Helper
You mean "both roots are complex" not "imaginary", don't you? It is impossible for that equation to have imaginary roots.

PeroK
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2020 Award

## The Attempt at a Solution

1-4(a)(c-a)<0
4ac > 4a^2 + 1

Okay, so far. What sort of inequality is that in relation to a?

... although, I don't see how you get that answer and c > 1 would make more sense. Are you sure you've got the question right?

Last edited:
Both roots are complex is the same as both roots are imaginary, I think.

Okay, so far. What sort of inequality is that in relation to a?

... although, I don't see how you get that answer and c > 1 would make more sense. Are you sure you've got the question right?

The question is correct, at least should be since it's a question from a test I took yesterday.
I don't have any idea what sort of inequality that is in relation to a.

PeroK
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2020 Award
Both roots are complex is the same as both roots are imaginary, I think.

The question is correct, at least should be since it's a question from a test I took yesterday.
I don't have any idea what sort of inequality that is in relation to a.

A complex number has real and imaginary parts. If both roots were imaginary, they would be ##\pm bi## with no real part.

Here's how I would prove the question is wrong:

Let c = 0 (which is > -1), so we have:

##ax^2 + x - a = 0##

The discriminant is ##4a^2+1## which is +ve, so this equation never has complex roots. And the condition 3a < 2 (=2 + 4c) is not relevant.

Ergo the question is wrong.

Wait, why is the condition 3a<2 not relevant?

PeroK
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2020 Award
Wait, why is the condition 3a<2 not relevant?

The answer says that the equation has complex roots when 3a < 2 + 4c. In this case, when 3a < 2 (as c = 0).

But, with c = 0 the equation never has complex roots. Whether 3a < 2 or not has nothing to do with it.

As an exercise, try c = 1. You should be able to work out when the equation has complex roots and show that it not when 3a < 6

• erisedk
The equation always has complex roots for c=1.
That was neat. Thank you!