fluidistic
Gold Member
- 3,928
- 272
I wonder if Heisenberg principle (both \Delta p \Delta x \geq \frac{\hbar }{2} and \Delta E \Delta t \geq \frac{\hbar }{2}) can be applied to photons.
Say I have a laser emitting a flash. I know very well the wavelength of the photon, therefore its momentum. Also, I know well where it might be: it travels at c and must lie somewhere inside the cross section area of the laser beam situated at a distance ct from the laser, if I consider a time t after emission. Which seems to contradict that if I know well the momentum of the laser, I shouldn't know well where it is.
The same doubt arises with the relation between \Delta E and \Delta t. I know very well the energy of a laser photon since I know very well its wavelength. And I do so at any time...
Unless E\neq \frac{hc}{\lambda}...
So I don't understand if I'm missing something or if Heisenberg's principle cannot be applied to photons.
Say I have a laser emitting a flash. I know very well the wavelength of the photon, therefore its momentum. Also, I know well where it might be: it travels at c and must lie somewhere inside the cross section area of the laser beam situated at a distance ct from the laser, if I consider a time t after emission. Which seems to contradict that if I know well the momentum of the laser, I shouldn't know well where it is.
The same doubt arises with the relation between \Delta E and \Delta t. I know very well the energy of a laser photon since I know very well its wavelength. And I do so at any time...
Unless E\neq \frac{hc}{\lambda}...
So I don't understand if I'm missing something or if Heisenberg's principle cannot be applied to photons.