Is Potassium Detectable with a Chemical Test?

  • Thread starter Thread starter cantbemessedwit
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Coffee
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the detectability of potassium in coffee using chemical tests. Participants explore various methods for testing potassium ions, the challenges associated with detection, and the implications of potassium's presence in coffee.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Experimental/applied

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants clarify that potassium ions, rather than potassium metal, are of interest in the discussion about detection methods.
  • It is suggested that a flame test for potassium ions typically results in a violet/lilac flame, but this can be masked by sodium's yellow flame, leading to potential misinterpretation.
  • Concerns are raised about the difficulty of detecting potassium ions in coffee due to low concentrations and the presence of impurities that could interfere with tests.
  • A participant mentions that sophisticated instruments, such as HPLC-AAS or ICP-AES, would be more effective for detecting potassium in coffee, as they can measure low concentrations accurately.
  • Some participants express skepticism about the feasibility of a positive chemical test for potassium in coffee, citing low concentrations and the potential for interference from other elements.
  • There are references to specific chemical reactions and methods for detecting potassium, including the formation of potassium chloroplatinate and the use of perchloric acid.
  • One participant humorously comments on potassium being a "weak emitter," suggesting that its detection is inherently challenging.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the effectiveness of chemical tests for potassium in coffee. Multiple competing views exist regarding the methods and challenges of detection, with some expressing doubt about the possibility of a positive test result.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include the dependence on the concentration of potassium in coffee, the potential masking effects of sodium, and the need for sophisticated equipment for accurate measurement.

cantbemessedwit
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
[SOLVED] Is there potassium in coffee

can the presence of potassium be determined with a chemical test? if so how? If potassium is heated in a bunsen burner flame , would the flame be yellow?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I assume you mean Potassium ions, not Potassium metal (I would avoid heating that in a flame).
If you perform a flame test with the K+ ion, the flame, ideally, should be violet/lilac, not yellow (yellow indicates Sodium).
However, just because you get a yellow, Sodium, flame, does not necessarily indicate that there are no Potassium ions in solution. Potassium gives a very weak flame test and is easily overpowered by the colors given off by impurities, especially Sodium.

Is there Potassium in coffee? Is there anything to indicate that there is as listed on the nutrition facts?
 
the presence of potassium ions

what would be a reason that potassium ions could not be detected when doing a chemical test with coffee? 4 day old coffee where potassium doesn't decompose
 
It is difficult to detect the presence of potassium ions without sophisticated chemical instruments. As mrjeffy321 states, a chemical flame test will not work because sodium's yellow flame will overpower the lilac flame color of potassium.

Here is a section from an old chemistry book I have that may help you out:

Tests for Potassium Compounds-The potassium flame is violet, but is easily masked by the intense yellow of the sodium flame. It is well to view the flame through a thick blue glass which cuts off the yellow light.

The potassium ion unites with the chloroplatinate ion to form insoluble potassium chloroplatinate, K2PtCl6. The precipitate is composed of yellow octahedra. The solution of potassium salt must be rather concentrated and precipitation is aided by addition of a little alcohol. This reaction is the basis of a standard method of determining potassium quantitatively. Due to the great expense of the chloroplatinic acid the perchlorate method is coming into use. perchloric acid is added to a solution of a potassium salt. While potassium perchlorate, KClO4, is precipitated, particularly in the presence of alcohol.

I guess you could try the blue glass trick the book suggests as it is rather difficult/expensive to make/buy perchloric/chloroplatinic acid.
 
I very much doubt a chemical test for potassium in coffee would ever be positive, the concentrations would be extremely low with many impurities. Personally i would use a hyphenated analytical technique like HPLC-AAS and compare to a set of standards as you'd be able to detect ppm concentrations easily.
 
cantbemessedwit said:
can the presence of potassium be determined with a chemical test? if so how? If potassium is heated in a bunsen burner flame , would the flame be yellow?
https://www.physicsforums.com/images/smilies/laughing.gif
:smile:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You know what, i think i have seen this in coffe in a mini store, it said it in the label, so i think there is such a thing.

---------
http://hghlook.com"
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Coffee is relatively high in potassium. It's one of the things that you have to cut out if you have defective kidneys, as having double the normal amount of potassium in your bloodstream is likely to make your heart stop. You can find more information than you are ever likely to want about the composition of foods at http://www.nal.usda.gov/fnic/foodcomp/Data/SR18/reports/sr18page.htm
 
Last edited by a moderator:
potassium in coffe

I just want to understand the prove of potassium in coffe where
K2Na[Co(NO2)6] is the precipitate obtained
 
  • #10
I just want to understand the prove of potassium in coffe where
K2Na[Co(NO2)6] is the precipitate obtained
 
  • #11
Viterbo said:
I very much doubt a chemical test for potassium in coffee would ever be positive, the concentrations would be extremely low with many impurities. Personally i would use a hyphenated analytical technique like HPLC-AAS and compare to a set of standards as you'd be able to detect ppm concentrations easily.


It's easier than that.

I am an environmental chemist. I spent years running an ICP-AES, an Inductively-Coupled Plasma---Atomic Emission Spectrometer. Basically, you fire up an argon plasma at 5000C or so, (not sure), squirt the solution into it and measure the light given off the metallic elements.

ICP's are pretty tough. You could run the coffee straight into it if you wanted, although you'd probably have to clean it afterward. More than likely you'd dilute the coffee by a factor of around 1000 and run that because the potassium signal would be so high.

Minimum Detection Limit for potassium by ICP is around 0.5 ppm. Which is about the highest MDL for routine elements by ICP. Potassium is a WEAK emitter.

Jeff Corkern
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consider the following as a statement of logic and rank it as "True" or "False."

"If people possesses immortal souls, it should be possible to deduce this by logical analysis of their behavior."

www.theninepointfivetheses.blogspot.com

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
  • #12
Viterbo's response is almost a year old... (11-10-2006) and SHAME on you for dissing potassium!
Potassium is a WEAK emitter.
Perhaps you could say that potassium is a 'special' emitter or that our 'crude' detectors fail to accurately show its sublime but beautiful brilliance?
 
  • #13
chemisttree said:
Viterbo's response is almost a year old... (11-10-2006) and SHAME on you for dissing potassium!

Perhaps you could say that potassium is a 'special' emitter or that our 'crude' detectors fail to accurately show its sublime but beautiful brilliance?

Didn't notice the dates.

Hey! Can I help it if potassium is a wuss element?

Jeff Corkern
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Consider the following as a statement of logic and rank it as "True" or "False."

"If people possesses immortal souls, it should be possible to deduce this by logical analysis of their behavior."

www.theninepointfivetheses.blogspot.com

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
22K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
11K
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K