Just requiring understanding of thermodynamics solution

  • Thread starter Thread starter matthewsyq1995
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Thermodynamics
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a thermodynamics problem involving the mixing of nitrogen and argon gases in an insulated vessel after removing a partition. The key point is the determination of the final temperature (Tf) after mixing, which is calculated by equating the total change in internal energy to zero, using the formula U=nCv(deltaT). There is confusion regarding the applicability of this method, as the participant believes it should only apply to isothermal systems rather than adiabatic ones. However, the explanation clarifies that in a rigid and insulated vessel, no work is done and no heat is transferred, leading to a zero change in internal energy for the entire system. The participant seeks further clarification on this approach to understanding the entropy change during the mixing process.
matthewsyq1995
Messages
7
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A vessel divided into 2 parts by a partition, contains 4 mol of nitrogen gas at 348.15K and 30 bar on one side and 2.5mol of argon gas at 130C and 20bar on the other. If the partition is removedand the gases mixes adiabatically, and comletely, what is the change in entropy?

Homework Equations


Assuming Nitrogen is an ideal gas with Cv = (5R/2)
Assuming argon is an ideal gas with Cv = (3R/2)

The Attempt at a Solution


Ok basically i have the solution but i can't seem to understand the starting part where he got the final temperature. the professor told us to 1st bring the individual stream to mixture T and P. But i don't understand how he got the final temperature Tf.

How he did it was by equating
U(N2) + U(Ar) = 0
Then,
4 x (5R/2) x (Tf - 348.15) = 2.5 x (3R/2) x (403.15 - Tf)
Tf = 363.15K

It is my understanding that this method is basically equating the total change in internal energy of the system to be 0. Then using U=nCv(deltaT), he finds Tf.

However, I believe that the change in internal energy to be 0 should only apply for isothermal systems instead of adiabatic.

I understand the rest of his solution to find the entrpy except for this part. Do help me pls :)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
If you take as your system the contents of the entire vessel (i.e., both gases in both compartments), then, since the vessel is rigid, no work is done on the contents. And, since the vessel is insulated, no heat is transferred to the contents. So, since ##\Delta U=Q-W##, the change in internal energy of the total contents of the vessel is zero.
 
Back
Top