Magnetic Field formula Question

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the work done by a magnetic field on a proton beam moving in a circular path. It is clarified that the work done is zero because the magnetic force acts perpendicular to the direction of motion, resulting in no displacement in the direction of the force. The Lorentz force equation is highlighted as essential for understanding the relationship between the magnetic field, the charge, and the velocity of the protons. Additionally, the centripetal force required for circular motion must equal the magnetic force acting on the protons, leading to a formula for calculating the speed of the protons. Overall, the key takeaway is that magnetic forces do not do work on charged particles moving in circular paths due to their perpendicular nature.
WrathofHan
Messages
6
Reaction score
1
I'm not sure why the answer to the following question would be zero, so far, I'm thinking because work is force times distance and in a circle, there is no distance after a complete orbit. But I have a strange doubt that it might be something else.

A magnetic field of .1T forces a proton beam of 1.5 mA to move in a circle of radius .1 m. The plane of the circle is perpendicular to the magnetic field. Of the following which is the best estimate of the work done by the magnetic field on the protons during one complete orbit of the circle?

What I have a real problem with is how to solve the second part:

Of the following, which is the best estimate of the speed of a proton in the beam as it moves in the circle?

Could someone at least give me a formula or something to start with?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
WrathofHan said:
I'm not sure why the answer to the following question would be zero, so far, I'm thinking because work is force times distance and in a circle, there is no distance after a complete orbit. But I have a strange doubt that it might be something else.

A magnetic field of .1T forces a proton beam of 1.5 mA to move in a circle of radius .1 m. The plane of the circle is perpendicular to the magnetic field. Of the following which is the best estimate of the work done by the magnetic field on the protons during one complete orbit of the circle?

What I have a real problem with is how to solve the second part:

Of the following, which is the best estimate of the speed of a proton in the beam as it moves in the circle?

Could someone at least give me a formula or something to start with?
What is the cause of the magnetic field of the proton beam? What is the magnitude of the force if the protons move in a circle?

What is the direction of the force relative to the direction of motion of hte protons if the protons are moving in a circle? Does such a force do any work? Use \vec{F} \cdot \vec{ds} = d\vec{W}

AM
 
Andrew Mason said:
What is the cause of the magnetic field of the proton beam? What is the magnitude of the force if the protons move in a circle?

What is the direction of the force relative to the direction of motion of hte protons if the protons are moving in a circle? Does such a force do any work? Use \vec{F} \cdot \vec{ds} = d\vec{W}

AM

The question doesn't have the cause of the magnetic field of the proton or the magnitude of the force... Unless those questions were supposed to help me grasp a concept in which I still can't see...

For the second part, I'm still clueless...
 
WrathofHan said:
The question doesn't have the cause of the magnetic field of the proton or the magnitude of the force... Unless those questions were supposed to help me grasp a concept in which I still can't see...

For the second part, I'm still clueless...
This is a Lorentz force problem. The moving proton charge is seen as having a magnetic field which interacts with the static magnetic field according to the Lorentz force equation:

\vec{F} = q\vec{v}\times \vec{B}

If it is moving in a circle, the centripetal force must equal the magnetic force on the proton. Work out the expression for v.

Does v depend on the current? What is the direction of the force compared to the direction of the proton (hint: think 'cross product')

AM
 
Andrew Mason said:
This is a Lorentz force problem. The moving proton charge is seen as having a magnetic field which interacts with the static magnetic field according to the Lorentz force equation:

\vec{F} = q\vec{v}\times \vec{B}

If it is moving in a circle, the centripetal force must equal the magnetic force on the proton. Work out the expression for v.

Does v depend on the current? What is the direction of the force compared to the direction of the proton (hint: think 'cross product')

AM

Ok, for the first part:
(-mv^2)/.1 = .1*.0015 * v
v = -( .00015 * .1 )/m
mass of proton is about 1.67*10^(-27)(I'll use 1.5*10^-27 because I can't use a calculator here)
v = 10 * 10 ^ 22

I think I did something wrong here...
 
\frac{mv^2}{r} = Bqv
so ...
v = \frac{Bqr}{m}
Now put the numbers in. If the answer is greater than c, then mass correction is probably your problem.
 
The F is a centripetal force, and the d is tangent to the circle. Because the F perpendicular to the d, Then W = Fd cos Θ is equal to zero.
 
Back
Top