Misc. Making a 3D topo map of my town - looking for techniques

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaveC426913
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
Creating a 3D relief model of a town involves challenges in scaling and material selection, particularly in achieving a vertical exaggeration to represent flat terrain effectively. Initial attempts using foam core and balsa sheets resulted in poor cutting quality and excessive material costs. Suggestions include using rigid urethane foam for smoother contours, outsourcing the cutting to a professional topo shop, or utilizing a commercial laser cutter for precision. Alternative methods discussed involve using a small NC router for layered assembly and employing techniques like papier-mâché for mold creation. Overall, the focus is on finding economical and practical solutions for constructing the relief map.
DaveC426913
Gold Member
Messages
23,861
Reaction score
7,903
TL;DR Summary
Trying to figure out a practical way of making altitude layers for this relief map
I hope to make a 3D relief model of my town and environs.

First, rough idea, it will be 1m by 0.5m at 1:10,000. That will give me a map of the area 10km by 5km. Sort of this-ish:

1687892624857.png


As you can see, it's quite flat here, both abov e and below the escarpment. If I were to keep the vertical scale, that would make the plateau ("the mountain" is what it's called here) only 1.5cm high, and the rest would be as flat as a pool table. So I might boost the vertical scale by 5 or so. Even that gives me a total height of only 7.5cm.

(I haven't decided yet whether I want to smooth out the contours or leave them stepped.)

What I am trying to do is figure out how I can build the relief economically, cost- and effort-wise.

My first attempt was to cut out the altitude contours from sheets. At 150m, I might settle on 10m contours, which would make for 15 or so layers, each .5cm high.I printed out the contour maps of the area and glued then into foam core, and cut along the contour lines. That did not go nearly as well in reality as it did in my head. Even with an Xacto knife, the edges were mangled and the paper cut very poorly. I tried a hobby saw (just a toothed wire held taut between prongs) and that went poorly. I tried a hot wire, which also went poorly.

So I tried balsa sheets. This went pretty poorly too. I have to use the Xacto knife to saw, so I get a pretty rough, faceted edge.And there's yet another problem: Half my map is going to be 7.5cm thick and solid. That's a lot of material - and at quite a cost. I considered hollowing out everything under the mountain but - while that may save me some weight - it doesn't really save me materials. I just end up discarding a lot of it.

It's too big to 3D print, so I'm trying to do some lateral thinking and seeing if there's any methods I haven't thought of.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
DaveC426913 said:
TL;DR Summary: Trying to figure out a practical way of making altitude layers for this relief map

I hope to make a 3D relief model of my town and environs.

First, rough idea, it will be 1m by 0.5m at 1:10,000. That will give me a map of the area 10km by 5km. Sort of this-ish:

View attachment 328431

As you can see, it's quite flat here, both abov e and below the escarpment. If I were to keep the vertical scale, that would make the plateau ("the mountain" is what it's called here) only 1.5cm high, and the rest would be as flat as a pool table. So I might boost the vertical scale by 5 or so. Even that gives me a total height of only 7.5cm.

(I haven't decided yet whether I want to smooth out the contours or leave them stepped.)

What I am trying to do is figure out how I can build the relief economically, cost- and effort-wise.

My first attempt was to cut out the altitude contours from sheets. At 150m, I might settle on 10m contours, which would make for 15 or so layers, each .5cm high.I printed out the contour maps of the area and glued then into foam core, and cut along the contour lines. That did not go nearly as well in reality as it did in my head. Even with an Xacto knife, the edges were mangled and the paper cut very poorly. I tried a hobby saw (just a toothed wire held taut between prongs) and that went poorly. I tried a hot wire, which also went poorly.

So I tried balsa sheets. This went pretty poorly too. I have to use the Xacto knife to saw, so I get a pretty rough, faceted edge.And there's yet another problem: Half my map is going to be 7.5cm thick and solid. That's a lot of material - and at quite a cost. I considered hollowing out everything under the mountain but - while that may save me some weight - it doesn't really save me materials. I just end up discarding a lot of it.

It's too big to 3D print, so I'm trying to do some lateral thinking and seeing if there's any methods I haven't thought of.
Hi, DaveC,

A million years ago (give or take) I made architectural models and had to do this very often. We used rigid urethane foam. It’s available in different densities. We used lighter foam for smoothed contours, heavier if left stepped. Doing this by hand is tedious and very messy-a lot nasty dust gets made. We had a DIY 1/1 pantograph cutter with a vacuum attachment-it was still nasty.

Depending on your budget, you could have the topo cut by a topo shop. You might be able to find one online or go to an architectural model shop. When I was in business 30 years ago a topo of the size and detail you’re considering would cost around $250.

Good luck,

John
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes BillTre, DaveC426913 and sophiecentaur
johntpl said:
Depending on your budget, you could have the topo cut by a topo shop. You might be able to find one online or go to an architectural model shop. When I was in business 30 years ago a topo of the size and detail you’re considering would cost around $250.
I guess, yeah. That's a service now. You just give them your coords and a scale (and some cash) and they send it to you engraved in some nice wood.
 
My wife has a paper cutter (consumer grade) but I doubt but things that it will cut things that thick. But a commercial fab shop might be able to it for you.
Alternatively, a commercial laser cutter might be able to do it.
 
DaveC426913 said:
TL;DR Summary: Trying to figure out a practical way of making altitude layers for this relief map

It's too big to 3D print, so I'm trying to do some lateral thinking and seeing if there's any methods I haven't thought of.
1. Cut layers with a cheap small x-y NC router, from a sacrificial material, in smaller pieces that will fit together. During fabrication, different thicknesses and materials are OK.
2. Maybe profile the cut edges by controlling thickness with the z-axis.
3. Assemble, then if there are any gross asperities, grind or sand the landscape. Include a flat-earth step at the sides to stand it up and give it strength later.
4. Place the approximate model inside a plastic or rubber bag, shrink on with a vacuum. The thickness of the material will decide the surface averaging and the gloss finish.
5. Make a papier-mâché or fibreglass mould / copy from the model.
6. To prevent mirror reflections, paint the surface with matt paint, or paste glue and sprinkle fine sand.
 
  • Like
Likes DaveC426913
I made a small one, about 16 inches square and 5 inches high, a couple years ago.
I used foam board and glued the maps on with rubber cement. Cutting was done with an X-Acto knife and MANY No. 11 blades (the cuts get ragged with a dull blade). Tracing the coutour line for each layer with a contrasting color (I used Blue) was a big help. Following/cutting a convoluted line without that extra cue is... Umm... 'difficult'.

A sealant was needed after assembly because an ink-jet printer was used. Spray-cans of sealant did NOT work well - they dissolved the ink! An artist neighbor had some brush-on sealant that did the job if applied in a very thin, almost dry, layer.

One trick was realizing that the smaller (higher elevation) pieces could be cut from the center of a larger, lower elevation, layer. That reduced the printing and gluing operations too. Of course I realized this after the first couple layers were assembled; but it worked out OK. On completion, a couple holes in the base layer were cut to insert thumb and forefinger to hold the map up for display. Those finger holes needed sealant too, not only to hold the material together, but the edges are rough enough to make your fingers sore.

A small (5.5 x 8.5 in.) legend sheet with a brief explanation was also printed, mounted on scrap foam board, and displayed on a cheap wire stand from the local stationary store.

It was on display in the Community Center for a month or so and then donated to a local primary school.

Have Fun!
Tom
 
Last edited:
Some time ago I posted this Raspberry PI DIY Mass Spec using Raman Scattering. It's was something of a cumbersome project though, needing a 3D printer and special heat-resistant plastic giving of carcinogenic fumes during printing. To be blunt it was also not very mobile and interpreting the results was further cumbersome Recently though, I've been told that Arduino, and it's various sensor packages, has matured to the point where it's a usable alternative. Now I realize that a cigarette...
Thread 'Nonlinear rubberband type thing - "k" dropping fast as it is stretched'
What materials can I try in order to get a curve of displacement versus force that looks somewhat like this.. (of course, there would be a small kink around the origin where the ends of the rubberband are closer together than its length, which is not shown here). I am looking for something that will last at least 100 stretch cycles and is not messy, so for example liquid based colloidal stuff won't be suitable. Is there something one can whip up using silicone and some additive, say? Or...

Similar threads

Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
8
Views
5K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
6K
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
8
Views
3K
Replies
28
Views
1K
Back
Top