Maximizing Displacements in SHM: Is ωt = -Φ/2 the Correct Value?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jahnavi
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Particles Shm
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the maximum displacement between two particles in simple harmonic motion (SHM) and the correctness of the equation ωt = -Φ/2. Participants analyze the displacements y1 and y2, concluding that maximum displacement occurs when cos(2ωt + Φ) = 1, leading to a maximum value of 3A/2. There is debate over the calculation of the phase angle Φ, with some participants suggesting errors in its derivation. Ultimately, the correct maximum displacement is confirmed to be A(√7/4), with participants discussing methods to verify their results without calculators.
Jahnavi
Messages
848
Reaction score
102

Homework Statement


shm.png


Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution



The displacements of the two particles are given as

y1 = Asin(ωt)
y2 = Asin(ωt+Φ)

y2 - y1 = Asin(ωt+Φ) -Asin(ωt)

y2 - y1 = 2Acos[(2ωt+Φ)/2]sin(Φ/2)

Maximum value of displacements between particles is given as 3A/2 . This will happen when cos(2ωt+Φ) = 1 or ωt = -Φ/2

When displacement is maximum , then 3A/2 = 2Asin(Φ/2)

Φ = sin-1(3√7/8)

Is that correct till know ?

I think value of ωt = -Φ/2 is not correct as it gives opposite signs in displacements .
 

Attachments

  • shm.png
    shm.png
    14.6 KB · Views: 830
Physics news on Phys.org
Jahnavi said:
I think value of ωt = -Φ/2 is not correct as it gives opposite signs in displacements .
Having opposite signs makes sense, so when you calculate the difference it would be something like y1-(-y2) resulting a maximum displacement(The particles are further apart when they are on the either side of equilibrium position, compared to when they are on (one and)the same side of the equilibrium position)

That still leaves out the final part of the problem(calculating the displacement when it is equal). Do you need any help in how to proceed?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Jahnavi
How should I find the time at which the particles have the same displacement and hence find this displacement ?
 
Last edited:
Jahnavi said:
y2 - y1 = 2Acos[(2ωt+Φ)/2]sin(Φ/2)
make use of this equation.

If the displacements are equal then what happens to the LHS? And so what can you deduce about the RHS?
 
  • Like
Likes Jahnavi
Jahnavi said:

Homework Statement


View attachment 218454

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution



The displacements of the two particles are given as

y1 = Asin(ωt)
y2 = Asin(ωt+Φ)

y2 - y1 = Asin(ωt+Φ) -Asin(ωt)

y2 - y1 = 2Acos[(2ωt+Φ)/2]sin(Φ/2)

Maximum value of displacements between particles is given as 3A/2 . This will happen when cos(2ωt+Φ) = 1 or ωt = -Φ/2

When displacement is maximum , then 3A/2 = 2Asin(Φ/2)

Φ = sin-1(3√7/8)

Is that correct till know ?

I think value of ωt = -Φ/2 is not correct as it gives opposite signs in displacements .

Where did ##\sqrt{7}## come from?

You can continue with the same ideas to find when ##y_2 = y_1## now that you know ##\phi##.
 
phoenix95 said:
make use of this equation.

If the displacements are equal then what happens to the LHS? And so what can you deduce about the RHS?

I get t = π/(2ω) - Φ/(2ω) , t is the time when displacements are equal .

Is that right ?
 
Jahnavi said:
I get t = π/(2ω) - Φ/(2ω)

Is that right ?
You are on the right track.

Now since you got t, you can use these
Jahnavi said:
y1 = Asin(ωt)
y2 = Asin(ωt+Φ)
to get the displacement.

I would recommend using the second equation(Try with both equations and find out why:smile:).
 
  • Like
Likes Jahnavi
Jahnavi said:
I get t = π/(2ω) - Φ/(2ω) , t is the time when displacements are equal .

Is that right ?

Yes, although I would say ##\omega t = \pi/2 - \phi/2## or ##\omega t = 3\pi/2 - \phi/2##
 
I am getting value of displacement = Acos(Φ/2) , where Φ = sin-1(3√7/8) .

Is that right ?
 
  • Like
Likes phoenix95
  • #10
@phoenix95 , but the answer given is A(√7/4)
 
  • #11
Jahnavi said:
but the answer given is A(√7/4)
I don't think that is correct

Because if you take the displacement(from the answer given), and substitute it in this:
Jahnavi said:
y1 = Asin(ωt)
it would give you ωt=sin-1(√7/4)

If you take the above value and the phase you calculated(which I think is correct), and substitute in the equation below:
Jahnavi said:
y2 - y1 = 2Acos[(2ωt+Φ)/2]sin(Φ/2)
you won't get y2-y1=0.
 
  • #12
PeroK said:
Where did ##\sqrt{7}## come from?

Φ = 2sin-1(3/4) = sin-1(3√7/8) .

@PeroK , do you think answer calculated in post#9 is correct ?
 
  • #13
Jahnavi said:
@phoenix95 , but the answer given is A(√7/4)

This is correct. Your calculation of ##\phi## is wrong, as I tried to point out above.
 
  • #14
PeroK said:
This is correct. Your calculation of ##\phi## is wrong, as I tried to point out above.

When displacement is maximum , then 3A/2 = 2Asin(Φ/2)

Is this correct ?
 
  • #15
Jahnavi said:
When displacement is maximum , then 3A/2 = 2Asin(Φ/2)

Is this correct ?

Yes.
 
  • #16
PeroK said:
Yes.

Then I am getting the same results as in post#12 . Please point out the error .
 
  • #17
Jahnavi said:
I am getting value of displacement = Acos(Φ/2) , where Φ = sin-1(3√7/8) .

Is that right ?

Okay, this is correct. The problem is how you get from this to your answer. I just used:

##\phi/2 = \sin^{-1}(3/4)##

I see what you did now. You used the double angle formula to get ##\phi = \sin^{-1}(3 \sqrt{7}/8)##. I see now. That's right, but it just complicates things. Why not stick with the equation for ##\phi/2##?
 
  • Like
Likes Jahnavi
  • #18
PeroK said:
This is correct. Your calculation of ##\phi## is wrong, as I tried to point out above.

Sorry, your calculation for ##\phi## was correct. I didn't do that calculation at all and when I checked it quickly, I got it wrong! Apologies for the confusion.
 
  • #19
Ok .

Now , I am getting the answer A(√7/4) . Is this what you are also getting ?
 
  • #20
Jahnavi said:
Ok .

Now , I am getting the answer A(√7/4) . Is this what you are also getting ?

Yes.
 
  • Like
Likes Jahnavi
  • #21
PS in fact, now that the problem is done, there was no need to use the inverse trig functions at all.

The first equation you get is that ##\sin(\phi/2) = 3/4##. Just leave it like that!

And, the second equation you get is for the equal displacements:

##y_1 = y_2 = \pm A \cos(\phi/2)##
 
  • Like
Likes Jahnavi
  • #22
@PeroK ,

As a cross check to verify whether the result A(√7/4) is correct , I put this value in place of y1 . From this I get ωt = sin-1(√7/4) .

Now when I put this value of ωt and value of Φ = sin-1(3√7/8) , I should get y2 = A(√7/4) .

But instead I am getting y2 = A(5√7)/16 .

May be I have made some calculation mistake .

Could you please verify .
 
  • #23
Jahnavi said:
@PeroK ,

As a cross check to verify whether the result A(√7/4) is correct , I put this value in place of y1 . From this I get ωt = sin-1(√7/4) .

Now when I put this value of ωt and value of Φ = sin-1(3√7/8) , I should get y2 = A(√7/4) .

But instead I am getting y2 = 5√7/16 .

May be I have made some calculation mistake .

Could you please verify .

##\sin(\phi/2) = 3/4 \Rightarrow \phi/2 = 0.848##

##\omega t_0 = \pi/2 - \phi/2 = 0.723##

##y_1 = A\sin(\omega t_0) = 0.661A##

##y_2 = A\sin(\omega t_0 + \phi) = A \sin(2.419) = 0.661A##
 
  • Like
Likes Jahnavi
  • #24
OK. Thanks !

But I am not supposed to use a calculator .So ,I need other ways to check my work . Please see this .

y2 = Asin(ωt+Φ) ,

Put ωt = sin-1(√7/4) and Φ = sin-1(3√7/8) on the RHS .

Using the formula sin-1x+sin-1y = sin-1[x√(1-y2)+y√(1-x2)]

I get y2 = A(5√7)/16 .

Why am I not getting the exact result ?
 
  • #25
Let's do the general problem where the maximum displacement is ##\alpha A##, where ##0 \le \alpha \le 2##.

Now, we don't get tangled up with all those surds!

##\sin(\phi/2) = \alpha/2, \ \ \cos(\phi/2) = \sqrt{1 - \alpha^2 /4}##

##\omega t_0 = \pi/2 - \phi/2, \ 3\pi/2 - \phi/2##

##y_1 = A \sin(\omega t_0) = A\sin(\pi/2 - \phi/2), \ A\sin(3\pi/2 - \phi/2) = \pm A\cos(\phi/2)##

##y_2 = A \sin(\omega t_0 + \phi) = A\sin(\pi/2 + \phi/2), \ A\sin(3\pi/2 + \phi/2) = \pm A\cos(\phi/2) \ \ ## (this is now a cross check, done algebraically, regardless of whether you know ##\phi## or not!)

In this case, ##\alpha = 3/2##, hence ##\cos(\phi/2) = \sqrt{7}/4##

And no calculator needed.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Jahnavi and ehild
  • #26
Jahnavi said:
OK. Thanks !

But I am not supposed to use a calculator .So ,I need other ways to check my work . Please see this .

y2 = Asin(ωt+Φ) ,

Put ωt = sin-1(√7/4) and Φ = sin-1(3√7/8) on the RHS .

Using the formula sin-1x+sin-1y = sin-1[x√(1-y2)+y√(1-x2)]

I get y2 = A(5√7)/16 .

Why am I not getting the exact result ?

You make it too complicated. You got that ##\omega t = \pi/2 - \phi/2##. ##y_2 = A\sin(\pi/2 +\phi/2) = A \cos (\phi/2) ##.
 
  • Like
Likes Jahnavi and PeroK
  • #27
ehild said:
You make it too complicated. You got that ##\omega t = \pi/2 - \phi/2##. ##y_2 = A\sin(\omega t +\phi/2) = A \cos (\phi/2) ##.

y2 = Asin(ωt+Φ) not Asin(ωt+Φ/2)
 
  • #28
Jahnavi said:
y2 = Asin(ωt+Φ) not Asin(ωt+Φ/2)
Thanks, it should have been π/2+Φ/2. I corrected it.
 
  • #29
I agree with both of you that I have made things complicated . Sorry !

Still , what is the mistake in my work in post#24 ?
 
  • #30
Jahnavi said:
OK. Thanks !

But I am not supposed to use a calculator .So ,I need other ways to check my work . Please see this .

y2 = Asin(ωt+Φ) ,

Put ωt = sin-1(√7/4) and Φ = sin-1(3√7/8) on the RHS .

Using the formula sin-1x+sin-1y = sin-1[x√(1-y2)+y√(1-x2)]

I get y2 = A(5√7)/16 .

Why am I not getting the exact result ?

cos(Φ) should be -1/8.
sin (Φ/2) = 3/4 cos (Φ/2) =√7/4 --> Φ/2=48.6°, Φ=97.2 ° cos (Φ) is negative.
 
  • #31
Back
Top