Why won't any electrons flow through the resistor R2?

In summary, the question posed is about a circuit that appears to have a parallel branch with a resistor, but the answer shows that no current flows through that resistor. The conversation then discusses the mathematical reasoning behind this and what would happen if an additional resistance is added in parallel. In the limiting case where the additional resistance approaches zero, the current will only flow through the remaining resistances in the circuit.
  • #1
Plutonium88
174
0
So I was doing a circuit with some friends, and the circuit breaks down such that There is what looks like a parallel circuit, with one branch containing just the wire, and the other branch containing a resistor. The answer to the question shows that the electrons will not flow through this resistor(R2). Why is this the case? Is there literally no electrons going throug the resistor? How do they know not to take that path?

So the answer R = R1 + R3

Mathematically how do we know this is being discluded? Or are we just assuming nothing will go through the resitor R2?
 

Attachments

  • circ.jpg
    circ.jpg
    4.8 KB · Views: 410
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Try putting in a resistance on the other leg and calculating what current will go through each. Then see what happens when the extra resistance goes to zero.
 
  • #3
haruspex said:
Try putting in a resistance on the other leg and calculating what current will go through each. Then see what happens when the extra resistance goes to zero.

So in the limiting case where R2 -> 0 you just end up with the other resistance?
 
  • #4
Plutonium88 said:
So in the limiting case where R2 -> 0 you just end up with the other resistance?
According to the diagram, you already have a resistance R2. I'm adding a resistance R4 in parallel with it. Find an expression for the fraction of the current that would pass through that, then see what happens as R4 tends to zero.
 

FAQ: Why won't any electrons flow through the resistor R2?

1. What is the "Path Of Least Resistance"?

The "Path Of Least Resistance" is a concept in physics that describes the natural tendency of objects or systems to follow the easiest or most efficient route to achieve a certain goal or outcome.

2. How does the "Path Of Least Resistance" apply to electricity?

In the context of electricity, the "Path Of Least Resistance" refers to the path that an electric current will take through a material with the least amount of resistance. This is why wires made of highly conductive materials, such as copper, are commonly used for electrical wiring.

3. Can the "Path Of Least Resistance" be applied to human behavior?

Yes, the concept of the "Path Of Least Resistance" can also be applied to human behavior. It suggests that people will often choose the easiest or most convenient option when making decisions, rather than expending more effort or resources to achieve a desired outcome.

4. How does the "Path Of Least Resistance" impact natural phenomena?

In nature, the "Path Of Least Resistance" can be observed in various phenomena such as the flow of water, the growth of plants, and the formation of landforms. These natural processes tend to follow the path that requires the least amount of energy or resistance.

5. What are the implications of the "Path Of Least Resistance" in problem-solving and decision-making?

The "Path Of Least Resistance" can often lead to efficient and effective problem-solving and decision-making, as it encourages finding the easiest and most efficient solution. However, it can also lead to a lack of innovation and creativity if individuals always choose the easiest option without considering other possibilities.

Back
Top