Pressure, temperature, and volume relation in liquids

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the relationship between pressure, temperature, and volume in liquids, contrasting it with the well-documented behavior of gases. Participants explore how static pressure affects temperature in liquids, the mechanisms behind water pressurization in municipal systems, and the nature of pressure in different states of matter.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant questions how doubling the static pressure in a liquid affects its temperature, suggesting that it might rise proportionally, similar to gases.
  • Another participant introduces the concept of isentropic temperature increase per unit pressure, noting that for liquids and solids, this increase is relatively small compared to gases.
  • A practical inquiry is raised regarding how water companies increase pressure, with suggestions including filling water towers to higher levels.
  • Some participants speculate about the potential for liquids to hold static pressure and the role of molecular elasticity in this context.
  • Concerns are expressed about visualizing static pressure in liquids compared to dynamic pressure, with analogies drawn to various pressure models like vapor pressure and hydrostatic pressure.
  • One participant clarifies that resistance to compression in liquids is due to electrostatic repulsion rather than the creation of static charge.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the effects of pressure on temperature in liquids and the mechanisms of water pressurization. There is no consensus on how static pressure can be effectively visualized or modeled in liquids.

Contextual Notes

Participants note limitations in understanding the behavior of liquids under pressure, including the dependence on definitions of static and dynamic pressure and the complexities of molecular interactions.

physical1
Messages
42
Reaction score
0
Physics books and websites are full of Ideal Gas info and solutions when it comes to relating pressure, volume, and temperature. How about liquids? And solids?

For example let us say a liquid in a horizontal pipe is under double the static pressure than it was originally. By static pressure I do not mean hydrostatic - I mean static as in the other pressure factor of water (not sure what it is called.. static pressure ignoring hydrostatic pressure). Your water company decides, whelp, let's increase the city water pressure! Say originally we had a horizontal copper pipe full of water. At the one end of the pipe is a tap that is closed. At the other end of the pipe is the incoming city water company (city pressure). Water temperature is 20 degrees celsius (room temp) in the pipe originally, and a pressure of "1". Then the city increases water pressure to "2". The units do not matter, just say the pressure doubled. The water did not move, because the tap was shut. Yet the static pressure doubled. Would the temperature rise, twice as much to 40 degrees celsius due to the pressure increase? For simplicity, let's say the copper pipe never expanded and none of the taps can leak.

Ideal liquid laws?

Liquids transmit pressure - but, when they are not moving, AFAIK they hold a static pressure, almost like a "charge". I wonder if since liquids are virtually incompressible, an increase in static pressure causes the liquid to heat up ideally. We could think of a liquid under pressure like a gas under pressure which cannot change volume, due to its special container that doesn't let it change volume (the liquid itself!). i.e. if an ideal gas does not change volume, does not move, but increases in pressure - will it change in temperature proportional to change in pressure? (Yes, but ideal liquids?)

As for solids - well supposedly the fairly solid "earth" is under pressure causing tremendous heat in the center - kind of empirical evidence that pressure causes heat in solids. So this might answer my question - but still! I have to ask about liquids specifically too.

A practical aside: how does a water company actually create more pressure if the town demands it - larger pump? Or more pumps are added in series? I am also having trouble seeing how static water pressure can be increased without the pump turbine blades snapping in half due to the virtuallly incompressible water. I can visualize the dynamic pressure increasing once someone turns a tap on - but static pressure of liquids is a bit more tricky to visualize. Can a pump simply "shudder" and basically stay static, but still waste energy performing molecular work - increasing static pressure but not moving the water as a whole. Doesn't a pump motor have to move somewhat in order to perform work - but if the water cannot move..? Well I suppose it is like turning on an electric lawn mower, and having a man grab the blade and hold it in one static position. Motor still performs work on the muscles of the man somehow, even though motor is not moving?
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
The term I think you're looking for is

<br /> \left(\frac{\partial T}{\partial P}\right)_S<br />

which is the isentropic increase in temperature per unit pressure, or the temperature increase when a material is pressurized quickly. (If it's pressurized slowly, its temperature stays the same as the surrounding environment.) Through a couple of partial derivative identities, we can show that this term is equivalent to

<br /> \frac{T\alpha}{\rho c_P}<br />

where T is the temperature, \alpha the volumetric thermal expansion coefficient, \rho the density, and c_P the constant-pressure specific heat capacity. The thermal expansion coefficient is much lower, and the density much higher, in liquids and solids compared to gases, so the temperature increase upon pressurization is relatively small. Try calculating it for different materials.

For the town water pressurization question: I'm just guessing, but couldn't one just fill the water tower to a higher level?
 
Mapes said:
The term I think you're looking for is
...
the isentropic increase in temperature per unit pressure, or the temperature increase when a material is pressurized quickly.

Yes this helps, thank you.

Mapes said:
For the town water pressurization question: I'm just guessing, but couldn't one just fill the water tower to a higher level?

That would be a simple practical solution. In that case gravity potential is used to store the energy..

I wonder if another potential could be used if they did not have that option. I am thinking that somehow the hidden elasticity of the molecules in a liquid can be charged up. Intra-molecular potential creating static charge. I mean, hydrostatic pressure from gravity is not the only charge water can hold? Or is it? Example: how people on farms far away increase water pressure using pumps? I'll look into it. That again in my mind right now is more easy to see as dynamic pressure in the moment when you need it.

I am visualizing a windshield washer pump and again I see the dynamic pressure easily, but the static pressure is very temporary and not stored for long period of time. Hmm. Can the static liquid pressure be stored without gravity? There is vapor pressure of water, which is kind of related.. almost like evidence that the hidden elastic in water exists. It is interesting that we have different pressure models - vapor pressure, hydrostatic pressure, and they are not all in the same pressure, we model them almost as separate pressures with different behaviors. Yet pressure as a whole is tied together in the end. The analogy I see is when water pressure increases, the vapor pressure elastic contracts. When water pressure decreases, the vapor pressure elastic expands. Once the elastic expands enough, the elastic breaks and snaps and water boils (intra molecular bonds are broken).
 
Last edited:
Sure, water can be pressurized, just like any other fluid, by increasing the pump speed. It's just harder to visualize than pressurization by gravity, as you've noticed.

But no static charge is created; resistance to compression is caused by electrostatic repulsion of existing charges in the atoms.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • · Replies 35 ·
2
Replies
35
Views
6K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 53 ·
2
Replies
53
Views
8K
  • · Replies 109 ·
4
Replies
109
Views
9K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
938
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 23 ·
Replies
23
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K