Problem with Approximations Using Differentials

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
rhdinah
Messages
17
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


I am working on this problem and having difficulty getting the required answer. It is the exact problem as here , but I’m still not getting it.

BTW this is problem 10, Section 4, Chapter 4 Partial Differentiation from M. Boas’s book Mathematical Methods in the Physical Sciences, 3rd edition.

A force 500 nt is measured with a possible error of 1 nt. Its component in a direction 60° away from its line of action is required, where the angle is subject to an error of 0.5°. What is (approximately) the largest possible error in the component?

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


We are going to use differentials here.

##Component = F_1*sin(\theta)##

##\frac{d Component}{Component} = \frac {d F_1}{F_1} + \frac {d sin(\theta)}{sin(\theta)} d \theta##

##\frac{d Component}{Component} = \frac {d F_1}{F_1} + \frac {cos(\theta)}{sin(\theta)} d \theta##

##Largest \left|\frac{d Component}{Component}\right| = \left|\frac {d F_1}{F_1}\right| + \left|\frac {cos(\theta)}{sin(\theta)} d \theta\right| = \frac{1}{500}+\frac{cos(\frac{\pi}{3})}{sin(\frac{\pi}{3})} * \frac{0.5}{60} = .002 + cot(\frac{\pi}{3}) * \frac{0.5}{60} = .002 + 0.00481 = 0.00681##

So the ##Component = 500 sin(\frac{\pi}{3}) = 433##

##Component Error = 433*0.00681 = 2.95## … which is not the correct answer of 4.28 nt

So if someone can direct me to my error I'd certainly appreciate it! Thank you!
 
You have used ##d\theta/\theta## instead of ##d\theta## in your computation. Note that you also need to put it in radians based on how you treated the derivative.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: rhdinah
Thank you Orodruin! Let me put your ideas in motion!

##Largest \left|\frac{d Component}{Component}\right| = \left|\frac {d F_1}{F_1}\right| + \left|\frac {cos(\theta)}{sin(\theta)} d \theta\right| = \frac{1}{500}+\frac{cos(\frac{\pi}{3})}{sin(\frac{\pi}{3})} * \frac{0.5\pi}{180} = .002 + cot(\frac{\pi}{3}) * \frac{0.5\pi}{180} = .002 + 0.00504 = 0.00704##

So the ##Component = 500 sin(\frac{\pi}{3}) = 433##

##Component Error = 433*0.00704 = 3.05## … which is still not the correct answer of 4.28 nt

So I suspect there's something seriously wrong with my approach ... my equation ... any further ideas that could lead me to a correct solution please? :-) Thank you!
 
What is the component of a force in a direction to which it makes an angle ##\theta##?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: rhdinah
Yes, thank you so much! I looked at my original diagram and realized that I had the trig wrong! Shame on me! I was mislead a bit by the ref thread. I should have trusted my original diagram and not listened to the banter on that thread.
Handwritten diagram of a force vector F1 at 60° above the positive x-axis, with the angle labelled 60° ±0.5°; F2 is marked along the x-axis, and a dashed line drops from the tip of F1 to the x-axis.

To correct this:
##Largest \left|\frac{d Component}{Component}\right| = \left|\frac {d F_1}{F_1}\right| + \left|\frac {sin(\theta)}{cos(\theta)} d \theta\right| = \frac{1}{500}+\frac{sin(\frac{\pi}{3})}{cos(\frac{\pi}{3})} * \frac{0.5\pi}{180} = .002 + tan(\frac{\pi}{3}) * \frac{0.5\pi}{180} = .002 + 0.0151 = 0.0171##

So the ##Component = 500 nt\hspace{.1cm} cos(\frac{\pi}{3}) = 250 nt##

##Component Error = 250 nt*0.0171 = 4.28 nt## … which is the correct answer.##\hspace{1cm}\square##
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten vector diagram with x and y axes; a vector F1 at 60° from the positive x-axis, labeled 60° and 0.5°, with a dashed line dropped to the x-axis showing its horizontal component labeled F2.
    IMG_0248.jpg
    28.8 KB · Views: 551