Proving trigonometric identities in a belt and pulley proble

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on verifying the trigonometric identity for theta in the equation L = piD + (d-D)theta + 2Csin(theta), specifically proving it equals arc-cosine[(D-d)/2C]. Participants clarify the geometric relationships involved, emphasizing the importance of accurate sketches to visualize the problem. One user corrects their approach, realizing the need to properly position variables and understand the right triangle formed by the belt and circles. The conversation highlights the necessity of thorough documentation of thoughts to aid in problem-solving. Overall, the exchange reinforces the value of visual aids and collaborative problem-solving in understanding complex trigonometric identities.
Terrell
Messages
316
Reaction score
26

Homework Statement


verify that theta in L = piD + (d-D)theta + 2Csin(theta) is equal to arc-cosine [(D-d)/2C]

2. The attempt at a solution
you can see my attempt in the second picture uploaded. i don't think i even got it right
 

Attachments

  • pulleys trignometry.png
    pulleys trignometry.png
    78.2 KB · Views: 622
  • pulley problem sol'n.png
    pulley problem sol'n.png
    14.7 KB · Views: 600
  • Like
Likes a_Vatar
Physics news on Phys.org
Terrell said:

Homework Statement


verify that theta in L = piD + (d-D)theta + 2Csin(theta) is equal to arc-cosine [(D-d)/2C]

2. The attempt at a solution
you can see my attempt in the second picture uploaded. i don't think i even got it right
You are close, but you put A to the wrong place, and c is not the hypotenuse of a right triangle in your picture.
The line x (the connecting belt) makes a right angle with the radius of both circles, and you need to draw a parallel with it from the centre of the smaller circle. You get the yellow rectangle and the green right triangle. Find x and theta from that. Prove both formulas in the OP.
upload_2016-3-21_6-52-44.png
 
ehild said:
You are close, but you put A to the wrong place, and c is not the hypotenuse of a right triangle in your picture.
The line x (the connecting belt) makes a right angle with the radius of both circles, and you need to draw a parallel with it from the centre of the smaller circle. You get the yellow rectangle and the green right triangle. Find x and theta from that. Prove both formulas in the OP.
View attachment 97665
wow! how did i not see that. thanks! 2(theta) equals to arccosine (D-d)/C right? so to further simplify... theta equals to arccosine[(D-d)/2C] did i got that right?
 
Terrell said:
wow! how did i not see that. thanks! 2(theta) equals to arccosine (D-d)/C right? so to further simplify... theta equals to arccosine[(D-d)/2C] did i got that right?
Yes, cos(θ)=(R-r)/c, that is arccos((D-d)/(2c))=θ. But you also have to prove the other formula, for the length of the belt.
 
one thing i learned is i really have to put all of my thoughts on paper to make things easier. thanks for the help i think i got! check the new image uploaded :)
 

Attachments

  • arc lengths of 2 wheels.png
    arc lengths of 2 wheels.png
    16.9 KB · Views: 566
Terrell said:
one thing i learned is i really have to put all of my thoughts on paper to make things easier. thanks for the help i think i got! check the new image uploaded :)
It is correct now. And you really need sketches. I am very old and have much experience, but still my first thing is to make a sketch before starting to solve a Physics or Geometry problem.
 
  • Like
Likes Terrell
ehild said:
It is correct now. And you really need sketches. I am very old and have much experience, but still my first thing is to make a sketch before starting to solve a Physics or Geometry problem.
thank you a lot for responding to my thread! i will keep that in mind! :D best of luck
 

Similar threads

Back
Top