Question about electricity towers and poles

  • #1
35
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

I have several questions about poles and towers.

a. Does all of transmission towers carries three-phase powers? Is there no transmission towers designated for single-phase?

b. Does all towers are for transmission purposes only? Is there any towers in the world used for distribution instead of poles?

c. How do I know if a pole carries single-phase or three-phase? Does the look, style, or shape of a certain pole dictates what it carries?

d. How to tell if the wires I am seeing between poles are primary voltage line or secondary voltage line?

e. I saw this phrase in one website : "Grounded wires on the utility side of the system do not generally have insulation."
>> I. what does the utility side means?
>> II. why does it has no insulation? it would be risky right?
Notes:

1. Please answer the question according to number.
2. Label your answer according to what number you are answering
3. This question generally ask about some "real" aspects which might be too obvious to some of you. Please don't be rude
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
1,176
214
I have several questions about poles and towers.

a. Does all of transmission towers carries three-phase powers? Is there no transmission towers designated for single-phase?

b. Does all towers are for transmission purposes only? Is there any towers in the world used for distribution instead of poles?

c. How do I know if a pole carries single-phase or three-phase? Does the look, style, or shape of a certain pole dictates what it carries?

d. How to tell if the wires I am seeing between poles are primary voltage line or secondary voltage line?

e. I saw this phrase in one website : "Grounded wires on the utility side of the system do not generally have insulation."
>> I. what does the utility side means?
>> II. why does it has no insulation? it would be risky right?
a. Most of them,yes. However, there are towers for HVDC transmission (they carry two wires of opposite DC polarities). And there are "small towers" carrying a 25 kV AC single phase line to power railways. Some other examples of single phase HVAC transmission are in existance too.

b. No, some of them carry links for communications as well. Don't understand second question... big electrical towers are usually called pylons.

c. Count the wires or number of insulators per tower, for HV range usually it works. Yes, it does.

d. You can't tell. Primary and secondary sides are determined by direction of flow of the energy.

e.
I. In that context, a LV side where energy is consumed.Utility line has a broader meaning though.
II. Is "grounded" wire in 4-wire cables insulated or not?
At place of actual grounding it must be uninsulated (otherwise, grounding wouldn't have a purpose)
 
Last edited:
  • #3
SteamKing
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
12,798
1,666
I have several questions about poles and towers.

a. Does all of transmission towers carries three-phase powers? Is there no transmission towers designated for single-phase?

b. Does all towers are for transmission purposes only? Is there any towers in the world used for distribution instead of poles?

c. How do I know if a pole carries single-phase or three-phase? Does the look, style, or shape of a certain pole dictates what it carries?

d. How to tell if the wires I am seeing between poles are primary voltage line or secondary voltage line?

e. I saw this phrase in one website : "Grounded wires on the utility side of the system do not generally have insulation."
>> I. what does the utility side means?
>> II. why does it has no insulation? it would be risky right?
Notes:

1. Please answer the question according to number.
2. Label your answer according to what number you are answering
3. This question generally ask about some "real" aspects which might be too obvious to some of you. Please don't be rude
I gotta a question. Is this for homework?
 
  • #4
35
0
I gotta a question. Is this for homework?
No it was not a homework. I am currently student of engineering course and all of those questions came from myself and there as part of my curiosity
 
  • #5
35
0
b. No, some of them carry links for communications as well. Don't understand second question... big electrical towers are usually called pylons.
What I am trying to say here is, does majority/all of pylons are dedicated for transmission purposes only? I believed that poles served as way of distributing voltages ( in other words I believed that poles are used in distribution system).

Count the wires or number of insulators per tower, for HV range usually it works. Yes, it does.
I am asking about "How do I know if a POLE carries single-phase or three-phase?" not towers/pylons.
To emphasize this is when I walked outside of our house ( to be specific, on the streets), I saw several electrical poles. Some of them are made of wood, steel, and concrete. Then how would I know if that particular pole carries Three-Phase power or Single-Phase power?

II. Is "grounded" wire in 4-wire cables insulated or not?
I don't get this part. Are you asking me Sir? Well, I don't know the answer.

At place of actual grounding it must be uninsulated (otherwise, grounding wouldn't have a purpose)
Then I ask Sir why there is no insulation? It would be risky right?
 
  • #6
1,176
214
What I am trying to say here is, does majority/all of pylons are dedicated for transmission purposes only? I believed that poles served as way of distributing voltages ( in other words I believed that poles are used in distribution system).
Yes, pylons are dedicated to transmission of electrical power, to carry HV lines. Sometimes they carry fiber optic cables for communications purposes too.Poles and smaller towers serve to carry overhead lines of smaller voltages and for distribution. Sometimes you see 3 bare wires for medium and low voltage hanging to a pole, and sometimes, in the case of a low voltage, poles may carry just one thick overhead power cable. In that cable there are wires of all 3 phases, and they must be insulated.

I am asking about "How do I know if a POLE carries single-phase or three-phase?" not towers/pylons.
To emphasize this is when I walked outside of our house ( to be specific, on the streets), I saw several electrical poles. Some of them are made of wood, steel, and concrete. Then how would I know if that particular pole carries Three-Phase power or Single-Phase power?
See previous answers. Vast majority of electrical poles carry all 3 phases.
Then I ask Sir why there is no insulation? It would be risky right?
When you see bare wires on pole, insulators on poles and surrounding air is only insulation, and no other insulation is needed in that case. Advantage is that uninsulated overhead wires can carry more current than insulated cable given same cross section of conductors.
 
  • #7
davenn
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
9,128
7,081
Advantage is that uninsulated overhead wires can carry more current than insulated cable given same cross section of conductors.
am questioning that answer ... if the conductor cross-section is the same, the current carrying capacity will be the same
regardless of if it is insulated or not

The real advantage is ... the uninsulated power lines save huge amounts of money in the cost of the plastic insulation

Dave
 
  • #8
berkeman
Mentor
56,841
6,819
I think he's thinking about the lower heat dissipation of insulated cables leads to a higher temperature rise given all the other factors are the same. I'm not sure how much that would lead to derating the cable, but your point is also valid that it makes the wire cheaper when it has no insulation.
 
  • #9
1,176
214
am questioning that answer ... if the conductor cross-section is the same, the current carrying capacity will be the same
regardless of if it is insulated or not
It isn't. Aerial bundled cables (and power cables in general) harder dissipate heat than separated naked conductors in air. Besides their upper temperature due to overloading is lower since it can hurt their insulation. Interestingly, seems that fact isn't listed in the linked wiki page

The real advantage is ...
There are advantages as well as disadvantages.
 
  • #10
davenn
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
9,128
7,081
It isn't. Aerial bundled cables (and power cables in general) harder dissipate heat than separated naked conductors in air.
You have only now brought up bundled cables ( which is irrelevant) ... the general conversation was just about insulated or uninsulated conductors

Berkeman covered that nicely :)

cuz for bundled cables you MUST have insulated anyway lots of sparks otherwise ;)

As I saw in my neighbours dropper cable early in the morning last week
I got woken up by bangs outside ... thought some one was breaking into my car (which is parked outside the bedroom window)
nope all OK , went back to bed and the bangs continued, next time I looked out I saw a flash of light hmmmm

got dressed and investigated ... the 240V dropper cable ( contains a phase and neutral) to my neighbours home was arcing and showing sparks
with the appropriate bangs. Adding to the mix was rainwater running down the outside of the cable till it got to the damaged section and provided an even better path between the phase and neutral conductors :)

Had to phone the fire service who came out and they contacted the power authorities. and here comes the worst part of it .... the fire brigade left BEFORE the power guy arrived ... I happened to glance out my window and saw neither there and went to investigate. The cable had now broken right through and the live end was now sitting /dangling down in the middle of the footpath and still arcing away happily, ready to zap some poor unsuspecting early morning jogger ( in the dark)
Another call to fire service saw their return and securing the area till the power guy arrived :eek::rolleyes:

Dave
 
  • #11
1,176
214
You have only now brought up bundled cables ( which is irrelevant) ... the general conversation was just about insulated or uninsulated conductors
Well, as concerns current carrying capability it is relevant not just if they are insulated or not, but also if they are bundled or not (active surface to dissipate heat comes into play), materials, cable designs, enviroment etc. That's one separate big topic. Anyway, OP was merely interested what electrical poles, consoles, pylons/towers carry, and I hope my answers were of some help. And there is much more to tell and if he/she wants to know more, googling key words like "transmission of electrical energy" will be helpful undoubtly.
 
  • #12
Svein
Science Advisor
Insights Author
2,025
649
e. I saw this phrase in one website : "Grounded wires on the utility side of the system do not generally have insulation."
>> I. what does the utility side means?
>> II. why does it has no insulation? it would be risky right?
Utility side: The wires between the consumer and the nearest transformer.
Grounded wires are at ground potential. Therefore no risk.
 
  • #13
dlgoff
Science Advisor
Gold Member
3,802
1,704
  • #14
8,244
5,062
What I am trying to say here is, does majority/all of pylons are dedicated for transmission purposes only? I believed that poles served as way of distributing voltages ( in other words I believed that poles are used in distribution system).
It sounds like you have some strange ideas about the difference between transmission and distribution. I don't know what you mean by "distributing voltages." I suggest you read both of these articles on Wikipedia. Power Distribution, and Electric Power Transmission. You will l not find universal agreement on the definition of where transmission ends and distribution begins.

Your questions are also confusing regarding what is seen sometimes, versus seen primarily. Those terms are hard to define.

I am in The Florida Keys right now. Here, there is only one highway, and one set of poles/towers. They are forced to carry transmission and distribution and communications on the same poles/towers. On a global scale that is unusual, but in some places it is normal.

zoki85 gave you the best practical advice: look overhead at the number of wires, and the number of insulators, and try to figure out their function and the voltage level.
 
  • #15
8,244
5,062
Here is a picture of a pole/tower in my vicinity. I show it not to overwhelm you, but to illustrate just how much you can teach yourself by looking carefully and trying to reason out the functions one step at a time based on what you actually see.

20150128_091823.jpg


From top to bottom:
  1. A single wire with no insulators. This is the shield wire that protects the pole from lightning. This wire carries no power.

  2. Three wires with many insulators each. This is a three-phase power transmission circuit.

  3. Two crossbars with three wires each, and fewer insulators. (fewer insulators means lower voltage) These are two three-phase distribution circuits.

  4. A single mystery wire. You can not be certain by looking that its function whether power rather than communication. I believe it is a single-phase low voltage distribution cable with two insulated conductors inside a plastic sheath and spiral wrapped on the outside with a bare wire. Zoom in and look carefully and you can see that the spiral wire is grounded to the tower.

  5. Two wires going off to the left. Look carefully and you can see that they have no insulators at all. They are attached directly to the metal tower. These are not electrical wires, they are guy wires helping to support another pole on the other side of the highway.

  6. Two black sheathed sets of cables for communications. These carry telephone, and cable TV, and Internet. Possibly, there are both wires and fiber optic cables inside. In all cases (I believe) you will find communications cables lower on the pole/tower than electric power cables. That is required for safety of linemen, and it greatly reduces the chances of those wires getting struck by lightning and thus endangering people talking on the phone.

  7. Not shown in the picture. If you look around the base of the metal tower, you will see that it is attached to an earth ground.
In the second picture below, you see another tower. Three wires from one of the distribution circuits go to nearby wooden poles that supports three distribution transformers (barely visible at the bottom of the picture). Cables from those transformers go to nearby buildings. A black communication cable also branches off to the buildings on the right.

20150128_092027.jpg


Just stop, look, think, and be patient. The purpose of the things you see may become clear.
 
  • #16
jim hardy
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2019 Award
Dearly Missed
9,839
4,868
That's the Fla Keys - I remember when those metal towers went in, just after Hurricane Andrew blew down the wooden ones bringing in power from Miami.
We were a couple weeks with very limited power , from diesel generators in Marathon.
 
  • #17
dlgoff
Science Advisor
Gold Member
3,802
1,704
Here is a picture of a pole/tower in my vicinity.
That's the Fla Keys - I remember when those metal towers went in, ...
Do I see a Florida Power Engineers Association in the making? Or maybe a party in Fl? Can I come? :olduhh:
 
  • #18
35
0
Just stop, look, think, and be patient. The purpose of the things you see may become clear.
You really get what I am asking and you answered it amazingly! Thank You for elaborating it to me! As well as other kind users that help and try to explain it to me. Thank you very much all of you Sir/Maam

  • Three wires with many insulators each. This is a three-phase power transmission circuit.
  • Two crossbars with three wires each, and fewer insulators. (fewer insulators means lower voltage) These are two three-phase distribution circuits.
As far as I know. the poles are used in distribution and towers.pylons are used for transmission. I am very amazed in that pole that carries both transmission and distribution line :)
 

Related Threads on Question about electricity towers and poles

  • Last Post
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
21
Views
42K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
13
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
657
Replies
9
Views
5K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
913
Top