What is the correct radius for spinning a rope with mass?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Panphobia
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Mass Rope
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around determining the correct radius for a mass on a rope in a physics problem. Initially, there was confusion regarding whether the radius should be calculated using Lsin20°, but it was clarified that the mass is moving in a vertical circle as a pendulum, making the radius equal to the length of the rope (L). Participants discussed the implications of the y and x-axis positioning and confirmed that the radius does not change based on the angle. Ultimately, the misunderstanding was resolved, affirming that the length of the rope is indeed the correct radius for this scenario. The conversation concludes with a sense of clarity and gratitude for the assistance provided.
Panphobia
Messages
435
Reaction score
13

Homework Statement



nlsmts.png


Homework Equations



mv^2/r
v^2/r

The Attempt at a Solution


My physics midterm is tomorrow and I was doing review today, so I did this question, then looked at the professor's solutions. For the radius in both equations he used the length of the rope, but shouldn't the radius be Lsin20? Also the way he positioned his y and x-axis was that the Y axis was parallel to tension(EXTRA INFO).
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hi Panphobia! :smile:

(your professor can't spell "vertical"! :wink:)
Panphobia said:
For the radius in both equations he used the length of the rope, but shouldn't the radius be Lsin20? Also the way he positioned his y and x-axis was that the Y axis was parallel to tension(EXTRA INFO).

I think you're misunderstanding "swings in a vertical circle".

It means that the circle is in a vertical plane. :wink:

(Lsin20° would be for a horizontal circle)
 
Yea that is what I meant, it is pointing down. So is my professor wrong? OHHHH CRAPP didn't know it was a pendulum, sorry man this question was dumb :(
 
no, the ball is moving in the plane of the paper, and so the radius of the circle is L :confused:
 
Yea I pointed out earlier that it is moving as a pendulum and not in a circle.
 
if the radius of the circle is L, why would you use Lsin20° ? :confused:
 
I figured that out earlier, I thought original that it the mass was spinning about the vertical axis at angle theta, THEN the radius would be from the end of the mass to the vertical axis. But later I read the question more in depth and found that it was a pendulum, and if it is a pendulum then the radius is the length of the rope.
 
(isn't that what i said? :confused:)

so is it all ok now? :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
Yes thank you for your help!
 
Back
Top