Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Single Phase Motor Hoist

  1. Jun 19, 2007 #1
    I have used a single phase motor (220 V 50 hz) in a hoist application. It is used to lift a given load up & down, but being a single phase motor, it sometimes never lifts the load & starts to rotate in single direction only i.e never lifts the load. When you press UP button, it rotates downwards, same for DOWN button.

    The thing is, the motor takes the easiest path and never lifts the load, while UP button is pressed, but instead rotates in opposite direction. Its a brake motor, whenever brake is released, the load/weight pulls down & motor tries to rotate in the same path. This is not happening always, since sometimes the motor is capable of lifting the load upwards.

    Please guide me to come out of this problem.

    thanx in advance.
  2. jcsd
  3. Jun 19, 2007 #2


    User Avatar

    It seems as if you're using the wrong motor and motion
    control system for the job if it's being so unreliable.

    In general for hoists, it's very preferable to have a
    counterweight of the same or similar weight of the object
    being hoisted attached to the same rope as the hoisted
    object on the other side of the pulley the load is attached

    This way with the counterbalance there's almost no
    static net force on the motor driving the hoist, so there's
    little or no load generated torque forcing the
    motor's rotation when the motor is at rest. Thus the
    only job of the motor is to overcome the friction and
    inertia of the system to accelerate the motion of the load
    and decelerate it when it's desired to stop the motion.

    Of course by the use of gears / pulleys or lever / cam
    action one can use a heavier or lighter counterweight
    than the actual load so long as the overall static force
    on the motor shaft is very much lessened by the balancing
    forces of the load and the counterweight.

    Also if the motor's starting torque is not sufficient to
    cause a starting rotation in the desired direction of motion,
    it would be beneficial to use techniques like gearing
    or higher ratio pulley systems such that the
    torque force on the motor's shaft due to the load is
    substantially lessened so that the motor's starting torque
    shall be sufficient to overcome whatever force / friction /
    inertia the load represents to the motor in any desired
    direction of motion and starting position.

    Of course using a motor with higher starting and sustaining
    torque could help matters.

    Using motion control devices like flywheels and
    variable clutches / transmissions could also help the
    motor more reliably drive the load, but the complication
    of adding these is usually prohibitive compared to just
    doing one of the more straightforward solutions like
    using a more suitable motor and pulley / gearing /
    counterweighting system.

    Good luck.
  4. Jun 19, 2007 #3


    User Avatar
    Gold Member

    Good response, Xez.
    I would add only that if the mechanism itelf can be reworked in such a (drastic?) fashion, the use of a non-reversing system such as a lead-screw would be appropriate for both ease of lifting and saftey (no external braking system needed). Alternatively, this same motor which is giving him trouble could be used to power a hydraulic pump.
  5. Jun 20, 2007 #4
    Thanx XEZ for the reply.
    Generally hoists/cranes dont have counterweight measures. Also in my case there is a space constraint where i cant employ counterweights. Again the motor is rated 2 times higher than the required capacity. Its a one ton hoist, but suspended load is only 500 kgs (0.5 ton). This was done not to overload the motor and for long life. As you told rightly, i used a high rated motor, so that no problems encountered. Roughly the motor uses only 50% of its capacity. And the hoist is standard one bought in market and used for various applications acros various fields. Therefore I cannot modify/redesign any parts and the hoist is proven in other similar areas. The point to be noted is most time motor functions in desired direction & very well lifts the suspended load. Sometimes it does not & rotates in opposite direction.

    Now the issue is, when it's able to run in desired direction, is there any possibility to enforce the motor externally by some method to run in desired condition? Or whenever the motor lifts, can we simulate the same condition, all the time?? so that the motor will not assume its own direction & rotates in forced direction, either ccw or cw?

    Any suggestion?? please!
  6. Jun 20, 2007 #5
    I agree with you that lead screw mechanism will do good. Actually it was in my earlier design of lead screw driving mecahnism. But any lead screw for that purpose, the system has be guided or channelised. otherwise the lead screw will fracture, when the system is in suspension or floating in the air like a hoist. There should be no disturbances to the lead screw & it should be fixed firmly such that no dynamic radial load acts on it. Good suggetion, Danger!
  7. Jun 20, 2007 #6


    User Avatar
    Gold Member

    Do you mean that this is a 'gallows' type lift, where the actuator forms one side of an inverted triangle? If so, then I agree with your assessment of a lead-screw's vulnerability. My solution to that would be to rigidly mount the screw mechanism in a vertical channel and use it to drive a mechanical linkage to the lever arm. If the 'follower' is tightly fitted to the channel, there should be almost no side force on the screw.
    A couple of other things come to mind. The first would be to add a ratchet mechanism to prevent downward motion when you want it to go up. The second would be to simulate the use of a counterweight by putting a variable-tension booster spring in parallel with the actuator.
    (I haven't worked out the details for either one of those yet.)
  8. Jun 21, 2007 #7
    The ratchet mechanism will do prevent downward motion but how to release it when you want the load to come down?? I remember a circuit which determines the direction of rotation of single phase motor & forces the motor to rotate in desired direction. I dont have the circuit & partlist details now.
    That circuit is slightly advanced than hoist pendent circuit. Hoist pendent will have an "UP" & " DOWN" switch, which will correspond to that direction of rotation, either CW or CCW, which will be triggered by a capacitor.
  9. Jun 21, 2007 #8


    User Avatar

    Well what specific technology kind of motor is it?
    Different motor types (e.g. single phase AC, three
    phase AC, DC, capacitor start, shaded pole, et. al.)
    have different failure modes and concerns associated
    with them.

    For capacitor start motors, for instance, it's quite common
    to have capacitors that are either improperly installed or
    which are somewhat degraded and need replacing.
    Since the capacitor specifically controls issues of starting
    and initial rotational orientation it could be an item
    to consider in the face of such problems as yours.

    You mention that your motor is rated for twice the
    load weight that you're using, which is a good thing.
    I will just mention, though, that the torque available
    when starting is different than the torque available
    when running at speed, so it's possible to have a motor
    which has ample torque when running but not so when
    starting. Since you say this motor and hoist mechanism
    is commonly used together for that purpose, and is rated
    for loads twice as high as your application, I'll assume
    that all aspects of the motor capabilities are suited to
    your usage (starting/running torque, duty, temperature,
    lifetime, et. al.).

    It is a common situation with motors to have one or
    more windings which may simply be defective due to
    broken connections or melted wire or short circuits due
    to winding insulation defects.
    It's certainly common for an old or abused motor to
    develop such troubles, but it's also possible for relatively
    new motors to unfortunately have such problems.
    Depending on your particular motor's technology
    it might be very reasonably expected that symptoms
    of a partially or fully failed phase winding would be
    exactly the problems that you are experiencing --
    inconsistent starting, inconsistent running direction,
    lack of available torque/power, et. al.

    Other things to verify would be:
    * Are you running the motor at its intended
    power frequency?

    * Are you attaching the motor to the AC power lines and
    to its direction control etc. with proper connections
    so that there are no missing phases, reversed wires,
    broken wires, connections made to terminals that are
    incorrect for the power voltage/phase that you're using,
    et. al.? Certainly a 240VAC motor winding attached to
    a 120VAC circuit, or motors with some reversed phase
    connections, et. al. might exhibit problems like you see.

    * Is the brake working properly, and when it is supposed
    to be disengaged, is the motor permitted to turn freely
    in either direction without friction?

    * Is the coupling / belt / pulley on the motor shaft
    working smoothly and not causing undue friction or
    misalignment when operating in any direction with any
    attached load?

    * Do you smell burning / melting type scents near the
    motor when it has been operating for a few operations
    over a few minutes?

    * Is your input voltage and current / power capacity
    within specification? Sometimes having other equipments
    drawing much power or connecting through too many
    lossy connections / cables can rob the motor of needed
    power, and some places just have unreasonably low
    power capacities due to utility undercapacity.

    * Is the motor properly lubricated?

    * Is the hoist connected with the proper arrangements
    of cables / pulleys / attachment points? Certainly
    accidentally switching pulley tracks or cable attachment
    points or some other such mechanical error could result
    in improper mechanical gearing of the motor to the load
    and thus exceeding the motor's capacity.

    I suspect that you'll find that there is either a mechanical
    or electrical fault that's been causing your problem;
    inspect everything closely, double and triple check even
    if your first glance and intuition is that everything is

    And, of course, be safe; having a hoist that's liable
    to unexpectedly drop its load or motor that may
    run amok isn't a very safe situation, so keep well clear
    of potential dangers due to unexpected failures / motions
    until you're certain that the safety / operational
    problems have all been identified and resolved!

Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook