Solve Cantilever Question: Mechanical Engineering Student

  • Thread starter Thread starter LostStudent5
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Cantilever
AI Thread Summary
A first-year Mechanical Engineering student is seeking help with a cantilever beam problem, specifically to determine the y-reaction force and moment reaction at point A. The student has attempted calculations based on equilibrium equations but is arriving at incorrect results. Forum members clarify that since point B is a hinge, it cannot transfer moment loads, which affects the bending moment analysis. Another contributor suggests that the student's given answer of 35 kNm is likely incorrect, providing an alternative analysis that results in a maximum bending moment of 60 kNm at point A. The discussion emphasizes the importance of correctly understanding hinge behavior in static equilibrium problems.
LostStudent5
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Hey guys, first-year Mechanical Engineering student here and a new forumer of this site too. I got a static question that I need help with.

Question:

h15uYCn.jpg


Relevant Equations:

Sum of all forces in the y direction = 0
Sum of all moments = 0

Attempted Working:


I just need help finding the y-reaction force and moment reaction at A. I believe I can solve the rest of the question once I figure this out. What I did was:

Ray + P = 0 by considering equilibrium of beam AB in the y direction
RA = -P

Ray + P + Rb/c = 0 by considering equilibrum of the entire beam AC (where Rb/c is the reaction force of the roller at 3L/2 from the LHS of the beam)

Rb/c = -Ray - P = -P - P = -2P

Sum of moments at A (anticlockwise is positive):

Rb/c(3L/2) + PL - M1 - M2 - Mr = 0 where Mr is the moment reaction at A (assumed to be clockwise)
Mr = Rb/c(3L/2) + PL - M1 - M2 = -2P(3L/2) + PL - M1 - M2 = -2PL - M1 - M2

This yielded me the wrong final answer. I apologise for not providing you guys with some free-body diagrams. I hope you can see what I've tried to do here.

Any feedback is appreciated! Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hi LostStudent5, thanks for posting your work in a logical manner, its a big help for us. Have you considered the fact that since point B is a hinge, it cannot transfer a moment load to the cantilever beam element?
 
Mech_Engineer said:
Hi LostStudent5, thanks for posting your work in a logical manner, its a big help for us. Have you considered the fact that since point B is a hinge, it cannot transfer a moment load to the cantilever beam element?
Sorry, I don't understand what you mean by that. Does that mean the moment load M2 cannot affect the bending moments of the cantilever beam, so we can just ignore the second beam entirely when considering bending moments of the cantilever beam? Or does that mean the bending moments around point B are zero?

Thanks for responding.
 
Sorry for the late response, this thread dropped off my radar. Regarding your question, the hinge cannot transfer moment so if you visualized a bending moment diagram the bending moment at the hinge would be zero, but the shear force will still transmit through the hinge. Does this make sense?
 
Mech_Engineer said:
Sorry for the late response, this thread dropped off my radar. Regarding your question, the hinge cannot transfer moment so if you visualized a bending moment diagram the bending moment at the hinge would be zero, but the shear force will still transmit through the hinge. Does this make sense?
No problems.

Yes, it makes sense now. However, I still got the wrong answer. This is my working out:

yWNA3OZ.jpg

0kqRRFe.jpg


I don't know where I went wrong. All y-reactions are intially assumed upwards and the moment reaction at A is assumed clockwise. The actual answer is 35 kN/m.

Thanks for your help so far. I really appreciate it.
 
It seems to me your "given answer" of 35 kNm is in fact incorrect.

My work (attached in PDF) shows the maximum bending moment to be 60 kNm (at point A). Your analysis method seems correct (analyze the hinged portion of the beam first, the cantilever portion next). Analyzing in this direction finds a reaction force of 7.5 kN at point B (and a normal force of 2.5 kN at the roller). When you carry this reaction force into the cantilever beam section, the resulting bending moment at point A is 60 kNm CCW, and the reaction force at point A is 2.5 kN.

Secondly if we "work forward" from the given answer of 35 kNm (pg. 3 of PDF), Rb ends up being 1.25 kN, resulting in a non-compression force at the roller and conflicting solution results between the force balance and moment balance due to unbalanced forces. Where did your given answer come from?
 

Attachments

  • Like
Likes Greg Bernhardt

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
8K
Replies
14
Views
9K
Replies
1
Views
5K
Back
Top