Solving for Angular Velocity and Rotation Angle in a Collision System

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on solving a physics problem involving a rotating system with a rod and attached masses after a collision with putty. For part a, participants emphasize the need to apply conservation of angular momentum, noting the relationship between initial and final angular velocities and the moment of inertia of the system. There is confusion regarding how to incorporate the velocity of the putty into the equations, with suggestions to clarify the relationships between the lengths and velocities involved. In part b, the derivation of the angle through which the system rotates before stopping is discussed, with participants encouraged to consider the work done by torques and the change in kinetic energy. The conversation highlights the complexity of the problem and the importance of correctly applying physical principles to arrive at the solution.
vu10758
Messages
95
Reaction score
0
The problem is problem 6 at

http://viewmorepics.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=viewImage&friendID=128765607&imageID=1460003525

A long thin rod of mass M and length L with two balls of mass M1 (same mass for both) attached is allowed to rotate about the horizontal axis shown. The bar is initially stationary. It is then hig with a piece of putty of mass M2 and speed v which sticks to one of the M1's.

a) Find the angular velocity of the system after the collision. The correct answer should be 6M2*v/ (6M1L + 3M2L + ML)

b) What angle will the system rotate through before coming to a stop? Assume that it must be between 180 and 270 degrees.



For part a,

Am I suppose to use the conservation of angular momentum.

IW = I_f*W_f
(1/12)ML^2 *w= (1/12)(M1+M2)*L^2*W_f

I am stuck though since I don't know how to account for v.

For part b,

The answer is 180 + arcsin(V^2/gL)

I don't know how to get to v^2/gL.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The rod with attached masses has a moment of inertia you can calculate and no initial angular momentum. You account for v by looking up the fundamental definition of angular momentum (for a moving particle; not the derived expression involving moments of inertia for a rigid assumbly of particles). It involves the mass and velocity and what else?
 
Angular momentum = m*r*v

I know that I for a rod is (1/12)ML^2

so L = Iw

then

L = (1/12)ML^2*v^2/L^2
L = (1/12)MV^2*L^2

r = 2L



If I have

IW = I_f*W_f

W_f = I/I_f * W

W_f = (1/12)ML^2/(I_f) * W

I am stuck. I don't know what to do from here.
 
vu10758 said:
Angular momentum = m*r*v

I know that I for a rod is (1/12)ML^2

so L = Iw

then

L = (1/12)ML^2*v^2/L^2
L = (1/12)MV^2*L^2

r = 2L



If I have

IW = I_f*W_f

W_f = I/I_f * W

W_f = (1/12)ML^2/(I_f) * W

I am stuck. I don't know what to do from here.
You need to fix the relationships between r and L and between v and ω. Be careful to distinguish the initial particle velociy from the velocity after the collision, and be careful about the lengths involved in the problem.
 
I made some mistakes. L = 2r, r = (1/2)L

w=v/r
w^2=v^2/r^2 or v^2/(1/2*L)^2 = 4v^2/L

Is M in this case 2M1 since we have two masses in the system before collision. Should the mass be 2M1 + M2 after collision?
 
For conservation of the angular momentum of the interacting system:

L_{before}=L_{after}

therefore

L_{putty}=L_{system}

\frac{l}{2}p_{putty} = \left(I_{rod} + I_{m_1m_2} + I_{m_1}\right) \omega
 
Thanks. For part b, I still don't know where v^2/gl come from. G is an acceleration due to gravity, l is a length, and v^2 is m^2/s^2. After division, v^2/gl is just a number with no unit. However, I don't know where the term come from.
 
Try and approach it along these lines

W_{torques} = \Delta K

The system experiences two torques, \Gamma _1,\ \Gamma_{12} which is from the weights of m1 and (m1 + m2). The torques will change as the system rotates so you need to integrate to find the work done by these.

The final kinetic energies are zero. So we are left with only the initial rotational kinetic energies of the three components of the system.
 
Last edited:
Note that from part a that

\omega _i = \frac{pl}{2 I_s}

where I_s is the moment of inertia of the system

also note that the change in kinetic energy of the system will be

\Delta K = -\frac{1}{2} I_s {\omega _i}^2
 
Last edited:
  • #10
Changed previous post.
 
Back
Top