Solving for the third one should be straightforward.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tonyb24
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Triangle Trig
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving a triangle with given sides and angles using the sine and cosine laws, specifically focusing on angles A and C. Initial attempts led to incorrect calculations, such as finding b^2 = -6, which prompted a reevaluation of the squaring process. After correcting the calculations, b was determined to be √6, and the challenge shifted to finding angle A without a calculator, emphasizing the need for exact values. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding basic trigonometric values and relationships to solve the triangle accurately. Overall, the participants are working through the problem methodically, seeking to clarify their understanding of trigonometric principles.
Tonyb24
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
triangle-base.gif

Homework Statement


Completely solve this triangle. No calculators please.
A=?
B=Pi/3
C=?
a=(1+sqrt(3))
b=?
c=2

Homework Equations


Cosine law: b^2=a^2c^2-2ac(cos(B))
Sine law: Sin(A)/a=Sin(B)/b

The Attempt at a Solution


b^2=-6
You can plug in 1/2 in (cos(B)) right away.
Other attemps, don't ask what I did but I ended up finding A=pi/3 and that makes no sense.
 

Attachments

  • triangle-base.gif
    triangle-base.gif
    2.4 KB · Views: 1,173
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Tonyb24 said:

Homework Statement


Completely solve this triangle
A=?
B=Pi/3
C=?
a=(1+sqrt(3))
b=?
c=2

Homework Equations


b^2=a^2c^2-2ac(cos(B))
Sin(A)/a=Sin(B)/b

The Attempt at a Solution


b^2=-6
You can plug in 1/2 in (cos(B)) right away.
Other attemps, don't ask what I did but I ended up finding A=pi/3 and that makes no sense.
Welcome to the PF.

Can you show the figure with the triangle? You can Upload a PDF or JPEG file with the button in the lower right...

Is it like this?

https://www.calculatorsoup.com/images/triangletheorems/triangle-base.gif
triangle-base.gif
 

Attachments

  • triangle-base.gif
    triangle-base.gif
    2.4 KB · Views: 1,160
Tonyb24 said:
View attachment 216306

Homework Statement


Completely solve this triangle. No calculators please.
A=?
B=Pi/3
C=?
a=(1+sqrt(3))
b=?
c=2

Homework Equations


Cosine law: b^2=a^2c^2-2ac(cos(B))
Sine law: Sin(A)/a=Sin(B)/b

The Attempt at a Solution


b^2=-6
Obviously, this isn't right. Please show your work leading up to this value. I suspect that you made a mistake in squaring ##1 + \sqrt 3##
Tonyb24 said:
You can plug in 1/2 in (cos(B)) right away.
Other attemps, don't ask what I did but I ended up finding A=pi/3 and that makes no sense.
 
Mark44 said:
Obviously, this isn't right. Please show your work leading up to this value. I suspect that you made a mistake in squaring ##1 + \sqrt 3##
I squared 1+sqrt(3) as (1+sqrt(3))^2=(1+2sqrt(3)+3) =4+2sqrt(3)
For context, this was on my test. Was wondering if someone could solve this from scratch.
So
plugging everything in

b^2= (4+2sqrt(3))+4-(2(1+sqrt(3))(2)Cos(pi/3)
add 4+4+2sqrt(3)=8+2sqrt(3), and finish the"-2acCos(pi/3)" part
b^2=(8+2sqrt(3))-(2+2sqrt(3)(2)(1/2)
(2)(1/2)=1 so cancel that. simplify..
b^2=6
b=sqrt(6)

Lol ok. I messed up my negatives. This is one of many different forms of answers I got. I also tried factoring the hole thing in many different ways during the test and pluging it into the Sine law, but it was very hard to arcsin these. I do not know how to do arcsin(a+b) It was not in any lecture. And then for angle C starting to stack arcsines was starting to seem a bit ridiculous for some reason.

Now, how to find A without a calculator?
Sin(A)/a=Sin(B)/b

Sin(A)/(1+sqrt(3))=Sin(pi/3)/b
Sin(A)=(1+sqrt(3))((sqrt(3)/2))/sqrt(6))
Sin(A)=(1+sqrt(3))(sqrt(3)/2sqrt(6))
Sin(A)=(1+sqrt(3))(1/2sqrt(2))

So I know 1/sqrt(2)=Sqrt(2)/2 .Anyways, this is what I was thinking on the test and was like dammit...

Sin(A)=((1/2sqrt(2))+(sqrt(3)/2sqrt(2))
Sin(A)= (1+sqrt(3))/2sqrt(2)

So how do I arcsine[(1+sqrt(3))/2sqrt(2)] on paper without a calculator? Maybe try to move things around?
arcsin[1/2sqrt(2)+1/2sqrt(3/2)] errm? What? Can I even simplify this way?
 
Last edited:
I thought the clue was in the "don't use a calculator" bit. The calculations must be easy, or maybe you don't need calculations.

You said yourself,
You can plug in 1/2 in (cos(B)) right away.
So, how did you know that?
Do you know any other angles with easy trig ratios? And how do you know them?
 
Last edited:
Tonyb24 said:
Now, how to find A without a calculator?
Sin(A)/a=Sin(B)/b
I would use sides b and c, rather than sides a and c.
I think that the "don't use a calculalator" means to give the exact values for the angles, rather than the approximations that you get with a calculator. Unless I've made a mistake, C will be the arcsin of a number that involves ##\sqrt 6##.
 
Merlin3189 said:
I thought the clue was in the "don't use a calculator" bit. The calculations must be easy, or maybe you don't need calculations.

You said yourself,
So, how did you know that?
Do you know any other angles with easy trig ratios?
I know pi pi/2 pi/3 pi/4 and pi/6. I can do some fractions like 7pi/12 using ex.: sin(pi/4+pi/3)=sin(7pi/12)=Sin(pi/4)Cos(pi/3)+Sin(pi/3)Cos(pi/4)
The don't use a calculator bit means exact answers as Mark said.
 
So how do you remember sin(π/3) or cos(π/4) say?
Perhaps you just know them off by heart. In that case how did you find out their exact values, that calculators and tables don't give you?
 
  • #10
An easy thing to do is drop a vertical line from the apex of angle C to the base, c. Now you will have two right triangles facing each other with a common side and you can use simple trig to get the lengths of the various sides. From those lengths , figure out what the angles must be.
 
  • Like
Likes Merlin3189
  • #11
You have ##b## correct. It's easy to get C using the law of sines with B (have no fear about the ##b=\sqrt 6##). Then once you know two angles...
 

Similar threads

Back
Top