Solving Simple Index Questions with Brackets and Fractions

  • Thread starter Thread starter lloydowen
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around simplifying an expression involving indices and fractions. The initial confusion stems from the order of operations, specifically whether to simplify inside the brackets or multiply out the fractions first. Participants emphasize the importance of simplifying the numerator and denominator separately to avoid errors, ultimately leading to the correct expression. The final answer derived from the simplification process is x^8.5, correcting earlier miscalculations. The conversation highlights common mistakes in applying index laws and the value of systematic approaches in solving such problems.
lloydowen
Messages
78
Reaction score
0
Simple Indicies Question [SOLVED]

Homework Statement


I'm having a little problem with indicies, I know it's simple for someone with a lot of question.

So I'm wondering what to do first in this question, brackets or should I multiply out the fractions inside the brackets?

I have to simplify it that's all :)

Homework Equations



Image%202011-12-03%20at%203.41.54%20PM.png


The Attempt at a Solution



I don't have an attempt yet sorry :(
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
I'd start by working out the inside of the brackets first. I think that'll be the easiest.
 
Thanks for the reply, so when I worked it out and simplified it first I got (x^2.5 x^2 x^-3)^2 which would equal to something like x^3, but in derive the answer is x^17..

What am I doing wrong :(?
 
lloydowen said:
I got (x^2.5 x^2 x^-3)^2

That X-3 isn't correct, is it??
 
Well I thought it was... What else could it be? I wish I had a good course tutor in College, I literally teach myself almost everything! *try*
 
lloydowen said:
Well I thought it was... What else could it be? I wish I had a good course tutor in College, I literally teach myself almost everything! *try*

You have F = \left( \frac{X^4 X^5 X}{X^{1.5} X^3 X^{-3}}\right)^2 . The first step is to simplify the quantity inside the bracket, to obtain F = (X^a)^2. So, the first order of business is to figure out what is 'a' in the following:
\frac{X^4 X^5 X}{X^{1.5} X^3 X^{-3}} = X^a. After that, the rest is easy: (X^a)^2 = X^{2a} .

RGV
 
Sorry, common mistake, so it would be X^3?
 
Here's what I got... That previous post is very complicated :o

Image%202011-12-03%20at%204.43.59%20PM.png
 
You need to slowly apply these rules, you keep making mistakes.

a^b\cdot a^c=a^{b+c}

\frac{a^b}{a^c}=a^{b-c}

\left(a^b\right)^c=a^{bc}
 
  • #10
How is X^{-3} defined?? What is \frac{X}{X^{-3}}??

Are you aware of the identity \frac{a^n}{a^m}=a^{n-m}??
 
  • #11
Thanks guys I have solved this problem now :) I will keep going over and over until I get it perfect.
 
  • #12
Could you show us just to be sure? Because two wrongs can sometimes accidentally make a right :-p

And assuming you used the formulae correctly, just a tip, it'll probably be easier if you simplify the numerator first, then the denominator, then apply the quotient rule.
 
  • #13
What I did first was simplify the insides of the brackets. To do this I applied the 2nd law of indicies and take away the denominator from the numerator for example, first of all I got x^2.5 because 4-1.5 = Positive 2.5... Then the same for the next one in the brackets.

Now the last fraction in the equation at first I forgot the rule of two the same signs make positive and the opposite signs make a negative. So x-(-3) would be equal to x^3.

Then once I got all of them, I added them up to form (x^7.5)^2

(x^7.5)^2
=x^17
 
  • #14
lloydowen said:
What I did first was simplify the insides of the brackets. To do this I applied the 2nd law of indicies and take away the denominator from the numerator for example, first of all I got x^2.5 because 4-1.5 = Positive 2.5... Then the same for the next one in the brackets.

Now the last fraction in the equation at first I forgot the rule of two the same signs make positive and the opposite signs make a negative. So x-(-3) would be equal to x^3.

Then once I got all of them, I added them up to form (x^7.5)^2

(x^7.5)^2
=x^17

OK, that works, but you still have made some errors. However, what people are suggesting is that you do it more systematically, by simplifying the numerator and denominator separately:
\mbox{numerator} = X^4 X^5 X = X^{4+5+1} = X^{10} and
\mbox{denominator} = X^{1.5} X^3 X^{-3} = X^{1.5 + 3 - 3} = X^{1.5}, to get \mbox{ratio} = \frac{\mbox{numerator}}{\mbox{denominator}} = \frac{X^{10}}{X^{1.5}} = X^{10 - 1.5} = X^{8.5}. There is less chance of making an error when you do it this way.

RGV
 
  • #15
Oh right I see what you mean! I told you my Tutor was rubish :P I'll get into that routine then, Thank you! :)
 
  • #16
lloydowen said:
(x^7.5)^2
=x^17

How did you get from (x7.5)2=x17?
 
  • #17
Mentallic said:
How did you get from (x7.5)2=x17?

Ah Sorry I must of confused my self somewhere... I meant x^8.5 at least that's what I have on paper..
 
  • #18
Ahh ok just a typo then, because you did it twice :wink:
 
  • #19
Lmao not sure why I did it twice, I was very tired that night :P
 
Back
Top