Statistical mechanics with a negative amount of atoms

  • Thread starter Catria
  • Start date
146
4
My advanced statistical mechanics prof told me that it wouldn't make any physical sense to allow N (the number of particles in a system) to be negative. But, somehow, I think that this possibility should be theoretically left open; perhaps there are some systems whose statistical behavior would be best explained if we allowed N < 0.

My question is: what would happen if we wanted to solve stat-mech problems of systems with negative quantities of particles?
 
2,956
5
Do you know why thermodynamic temperature must be a positive quantity?
 
146
4
Do you know why thermodynamic temperature must be a positive quantity?
Is it possible to have a thermodynamic themperature > 0 with N < 0?
 

Vanadium 50

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
23,369
5,742
Your professor is right. What does it even mean to say "I have negative four atoms in this box"? Sure, you can always plug numbers into equations, but that doesn't mean what comes out makes any sense.
 
146
4
Come to think of it, a system whose statistical behavior is that of N < 0 would be quantum in nature, regardless of whether the system contains bosons or fermions.
 

Mute

Homework Helper
1,381
10
My advanced statistical mechanics prof told me that it wouldn't make any physical sense to allow N (the number of particles in a system) to be negative. But, somehow, I think that this possibility should be theoretically left open; perhaps there are some systems whose statistical behavior would be best explained if we allowed N < 0.

My question is: what would happen if we wanted to solve stat-mech problems of systems with negative quantities of particles?
Which systems' statistical behavior do you think would be best explained if we allowed N < 0? Do you have any examples in mind?

I doubt there's any physical meaning to having a negative number of particles, even in quantum statistical mechanics. Even in ensembles in which you allow particle fluctuations, they don't have fluctuations to less than zero particles in the system.
 

Related Threads for: Statistical mechanics with a negative amount of atoms

Replies
0
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
598
Replies
0
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
33
Views
6K
  • Last Post
Replies
16
Views
2K
Top