Stuck with a problem on linear thermal expansion of solids

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a problem related to linear thermal expansion of solids, specifically involving a square made of two different metals with distinct coefficients of thermal expansion. The user seeks help in proving that the angle between the diagonals changes by (α - β)t/2 when the temperature increases by t. Initial attempts at solving the problem yield incorrect results, prompting further clarification and calculations from other participants. A suggestion is made to use calculus for verification, leading to a conclusion that the problem may contain a printing error. The conversation highlights the complexities of thermal expansion and the importance of precise calculations in physics problems.
subho123
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
stuck with a problem...on linear thermal expansion of solids

Homework Statement



I just read a problem 2day...it's on linear thermal expansion of soild...can anyone guide me through...it says..." A sqaure ABCD is made with two different metals...the coefficient of thermal expansion of the metal which made AB & CD is alpha (don't know how to type alpha) & the same of the metal which made BC & AD is beta (??)..Now if the temperature of the system is increased by t. then prove the angle between the diagonals will change by (alpha - beta).t/2 " ?

can u pls help...

thanks

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution

 
Physics news on Phys.org
Welcome to PF!

Hi subho123! Welcome to PF! :wink:

(have an alpha: α :wink:)

The square will become a rectangle, and the angle between the diagonals of a rectangle is twice … ? :smile:
 


thanks tiny-tm for replying so quickly & helping regarding the symbols...well i had an attempt at this...but the value that i m getting...is (α - B).t which is not desired one...let me tell u what i have done...

let the length of the each side of the square is x...then for the increasement of temp by t the side AB & CD will bcom x(1+α.t) & similarly BC & AD will bcom x(1+β.t)..now after temp increase the sqaure will bcome a rectangle ABCD. let the angle DBC is θ. Now, if the diagonals intersect at P, then clearly the angle DPC is 2θ. and the angle DPC has increased by (2θ - Π/2) for the tmp increased.
Now from rectangle ABCD we can say..tanθ = x(1+α.t)/x(1+β.t) = (1+α.t)/(1+β.t)= (1+α.t)(1 +β.t)-1 = (1+α.t)(1 -β.t) = {1+(α-β).t} [as α & β are very small so their higher powers are negligible]

now tan2θ = 2{1+(α-β).t} /1 - {1+(α-β).t}2 = -{1+(α-β).t} /(α-β).t}

now let the change in angle = A = (2θ - Π/2)

tanA = tan((2θ - Π/2)= -tan(Π/2 - 2θ) = -cot2θ = (α-β).t /{1+(α-β).t} = (α-β).t{1-(α-β).t} = (α-β).t i have tried upto this is ...now this isn't the answer...will anybody help me...

thanks
 
Hi subho123! :smile:

hmm … i make it the same as you …

tanθ = 1 + (α-β).t …

then using calculus (if you haven't done calculus, never mind, it should give the same answer, so it's a good way of checking) …

sec2θ dθ/dt = (α-β), and sec2θ is approximately 2 (because θ is approximately 45º),

so 2dθ/dt = (α-β),

and so the change in 2θ is approximately (α-β)t
 


Thanks tiny-tm for the clarification...it seems that the sum has a printing mistake...
 
Thread 'Collision of a bullet on a rod-string system: query'
In this question, I have a question. I am NOT trying to solve it, but it is just a conceptual question. Consider the point on the rod, which connects the string and the rod. My question: just before and after the collision, is ANGULAR momentum CONSERVED about this point? Lets call the point which connects the string and rod as P. Why am I asking this? : it is clear from the scenario that the point of concern, which connects the string and the rod, moves in a circular path due to the string...

Similar threads

Back
Top