Superconductors and high voltage

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the feasibility of constructing an electromagnet using a specific high-temperature superconductor, Tl2Ba4Ca2Cu10Ox, and the implications of applying high voltage (1 million volts) to it. Participants explore theoretical and practical aspects of superconductors, high voltage applications, and the design of electromagnets, touching on concepts from physics and engineering.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant proposes building an electromagnet with superconducting wire and questions the insulation requirements due to the expected lack of resistance in the superconductor.
  • Another participant cites Ohm's Law, suggesting that with zero resistance, infinite current could theoretically flow, but practical limitations would prevent this due to magnetic quenching.
  • Some participants recommend using a Van Der Graaf generator for high voltage experiments, noting that superconductors are more suited for high current applications rather than high voltage low current scenarios.
  • Concerns are raised about the feasibility of using Tl2Ba4Ca2Cu10Ox as a superconductor, including questions about its critical temperature and the challenges in producing wire from it.
  • One participant discusses the impossibility of applying a voltage bias to a superconductor with zero DC resistance, emphasizing the need for a current source instead.
  • A participant shares a conceptual design involving a spinning ring and coils to generate thrust, expressing confidence in its potential despite skepticism about the underlying physics.
  • There are corrections regarding the chemical formula of the superconductor, indicating confusion among participants about its properties.
  • Questions arise about the necessary current for the proposed electromagnet, with no clear answers provided.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of views, with no consensus on the feasibility of the proposed electromagnet design or the specific properties of the superconductor in question. Disagreements exist regarding the application of high voltage to superconductors and the practical challenges involved.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention limitations related to the critical current of superconductors, the challenges in producing superconducting wire, and the potential for voltage to increase uncontrollably, leading to circuit failure. There is also uncertainty regarding the properties of the superconductor mentioned, including its critical temperature and practical applications.

reddevil2576
Messages
54
Reaction score
18
I have an idea to build a electromagnet out of superconducting wire out of the Tl2Ba4Ca2Cu10Ox superconductor discovered earlier this year that's superconducting at 40 degrees below zero in Fahrenheit and I'm wanting to supply 1 million volts or a little more to it and see what happens. and since its a superconductor and will have virtually have no resistance will i not need that thick of insulation since the least resistance path will be through the wire? Any help will be appreciated thanks.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
Ohm's Law is:
V = I * R

Consequently, with 0 resistance, you'll have infinite current. (In practice, the current will rise to the point where magnetic quenching occurs, and the current that's circulating about screeches to a spectacular halt).

They're normally inductively pumped, and not directly hooked up to a power supply (as I understand it).

What's your background in? Not to be a downer, but this question, along with the other one about making a million volt power supply leads me to question whether you have the technical wherewithal and access to the necessary materials to carry out your plan.

Also, a place to get started, superconducting magnet:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_magnet
 
Hi,

If you want to play with high voltages, get a small Van Der Graaf generator.
On a dry day even a small one can be so scary you won't want to go anywhere near it.

Superconductors will be fun when the price comes down and the superconducting temperature gets up closer to room temperature, but even then they will not be suitable for high voltage low current work.
They are best where very high currents are used, like making powerful magnets for levitation and particle acceleration.

A coil that can generate such high voltages will have a lot of inductance and this will cause the high voltage to spark through insulation even if there was no resistance. So, you would certainly need excellent insulation.
 
There are quite a few problems with your idea:

First of all, AFAIK there is no HTS material with a Tc of over 230K (at least not at ambient pressure, I don't remember what the record is at high pressures). Isn't Tc of Tl2Ba4Ca2Cu10Ox (I don't even remember if that is the correct formula) something like 120K?
Also, are you sure that it is even possible to make a wire out of it? My guess would be no(making HTS cables is quite tricky, it took years of research to design the first generation of practcal cables and even longer to come up with the generation that is now becoming available).

Secondly, you can't voltage bias something with zero dc resistance, there is no way to apply even 1V to a superconducting wire; if you try you will just force your source to try to deliver as much current as it can.

Thirdly, now even if we assume that you can actually find a source which could both deliver 1MV and a resonable amount current this still won't get you anywhere. All that will happen as you try to increse the voltage is that the current will rapidly increase (it won't be infinite since it will be limited by the resistive parts of the circuit); sooner or later you will reach the critical current of the superconductor; the voltage will now rapidly increse and something will melt...¨
The current when this happens will be significant: Jc varies quite a bit between different superconductors and obviously also depends on how close to Tc you are; but if we assume that you are at 0.7Tc or so Jc will probably be in the range 10^4-10^5 A/cm^2 or so

Btw, Jc tests are done using CURRENT sources and the compliance is set to prevent them from deliving too much power to the DUT.
 
ok well i don't know a lot about the million volt set-ups I've taken classes in electricity and i understand a lot about that. I'm not wanting something to just shot a projectile my idea is completely different I've explained my idea on here once before and i got deleted so i was just trying to figure it out on my own without help but anyways here's my idea. use a ring instead of a metal bar that isn't composed of ferrous material so it doesn't get affected by the magnetic field I am producing and have some ferrous pieces bolted to the ring in strategic places and have a coil on the top right and bottom of course youll need a way more elaborate design than this this is just the basic idea. i want to make the top right and bottom coil and make the ring spin clockwise let's say and then have a fourth ring on the left working against the direction of the ring. and after its spinning so fast turn that one on but it won't be able to actualy stop the ring just constantly applying a force against it so i can have an upwards force on the coil and try to get thrust out of this idea. i believe it will work i know ur not supposed to be able to make linear force with centrifugal force but I am going for it. i think it will work. i have a few ideas to try out with times to fire all the coils i just need to build this thing then ill go from there. and your question about superconductors not going about 130k go to superconductors.org it will tell u about this one it was only discovered a month or 2 ago and they say that they released it without a patent since were so close to being able to have a superconductor at room temperature they took one that was discovered in janruary of this year i believe and replaced one of the items with thallium oxide and got one that was superconducting at supposedly 40 degrees Fahrenheit. thanks for the replys
 
sorry i have a correction i don't know where i got that formula from its Tl5Ba4Ca2Cu9Oy for the superconductor i want to make.
 
Umm. you have no idea how to generate 1MV, do you?
 
not really thought about a tesla coil id like to do it without capacitors but i don't know if u can.
 
Roughly how many amps will you need for this coil?
 
  • #10
i don't know how many amps. i need a very powerful electromagnet.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
8K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 23 ·
Replies
23
Views
6K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
4K