Synchronised Clocks

  • Thread starter rab99
  • Start date
  • #1
rab99
104
0
Referring to Fig A

We have a spaceship in the spaceship is an observer at point D.

There is also 4 identical clocks, clock 1 (C1), clock 2 (C2), clock 3 (C3) and clock 4 (C4).

At the same point as the observer is a light so there is a light at point D as well.

The observer also has a stopwatch.

While the spaceship is on the launch pad the observer spaces the clocks so they are all equidistant from the light as measured by the observer. So the distance from D to C3 is the same distance as D to C4 which is the same as the distance D to C2 which is the same as the distance D to C1.

V is the velocity of the spaceship and the arrow denotes it direction. Both V and the direction we will say for now are unknown.

All of the clocks, lights and observers are at rest wrt the space ship.

The observer wants to perform and experiment to determine if he is moving and in what direction.

The observers will synchronise the clocks using the Einstein methods of synchronizing clocks. By emitting a flash of light and the photons from the light synchronises the clocks.

While the spaceship is on the launch pad ie assume V = 0 and direction = 0 the observer synchronises the clocks.

He then walks from clock to clock, clock1 first then clock 2 then clock 3 then clock 4. Using his stop watch he times how long it takes to walk from clock to clock. At each clock he notes the time on the clock and the time on his stop watch.

The times he gets for the four clocks are T1 for Clock 1, T2 for Clock 2, T3 for clock 3 and T4 for clock 4.

The times he gets on his stop watch when walking between D and clock 1 is tD_1
The times he gets on his stop watch when walking between clock 1 and clock 2 is t1_2
The times he gets on his stop watch when walking between clock 2 and clock 3 is t2_3
The times he gets on his stop watch when walking between clock 3 and clock 4 is t3_4

He discovers that all the clocks are synchronised ie T1 = T2 = T3 = T4

He then collects all the clocks together at point D and compares the times on each clock just by looking at them and again he discovers that all the clocks are synchronised ie T1 = T2 = T3 = T4


Then spaceship takes off and accelerates up to a constant velocity V and the observer performs exactly the same experiment as he did above. The observer doesn’t know that he is moving and doesn’t know what V is.

He walks from clock to clock same as above will the clocks be synchronised ie T1 = T2 = T3 = T4?

He then collect all the clocks together at point D and compares the times on each clock just by looking at them will the clocks be synchronised ie T1 = T2 = T3 = T4?
 

Attachments

  • fig A.JPG
    fig A.JPG
    17.2 KB · Views: 334

Answers and Replies

  • #2
rab99
104
0
I beleieve clocks c4 and c3 will be synchronised C2 and C1 wont
 
  • #3
rab99
104
0
I add this

there is a second spaceship identical to the spaceship above well call them ship 1 and ship 2.

If spaceship 1's clocks are not synchronised the oberver in spaceship 1 turns on a light. The oberever in ship 1 can see the light in ship 2 and visa versa.

When both space ships are on the launch pad the experiment is performed. As the clocks synchronise no light is turned on

ship 1 then zooms off into spaceship 2 stays on the launch pad.

The experiment is again performed in both ships.

If ship 1's clocks don't synchronise the light is turned on in ship 1. Ship 2 sees the light in ship 1 and knows ship 1 is moving

ship 1 sees no light in ship 2 so he knows ship 2 isn't moving

ship 1 sees the light in ship 1 and he knows he is moving.
 
  • #4
rab99
104
0
I further add

If the clocks in ship 2 don't synchronise then the light is turned on in ship 2
 
  • #5
chroot
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
10,275
40
Since there's no question here, and since you have a history of attempting to challenge special relativity without first understanding it, I'm locking this thread.

- Warren
 

Suggested for: Synchronised Clocks

  • Last Post
2
Replies
51
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
594
Replies
3
Views
380
  • Last Post
Replies
20
Views
657
Replies
15
Views
719
Replies
12
Views
637
  • Last Post
Replies
15
Views
494
Replies
5
Views
753
Replies
63
Views
3K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
38
Views
1K
Top