The net force on a moving positive charge

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating the net force acting on a moving positive charge in the presence of both electric and magnetic fields. The electric field is 5.4 x 10^3 N/C and the magnetic field is 1.2 x 10^-3 T, with a positive charge of 1.8 µC moving perpendicularly to both fields. The initial approach incorrectly adds the forces directly, but it's clarified that since the forces are perpendicular, they must be combined using vector addition, specifically the Pythagorean theorem. A diagram is suggested to visualize the forces, confirming their directions and the need for trigonometric functions to find the resultant force. The correct method involves calculating the net force as the vector sum of the electric and magnetic forces.
Dart82
Messages
56
Reaction score
0
The net force on a moving positive charge...

Homework Statement


A magnetic field has a magnitude of 1.2 x10^-3 T, and an electric field has a magnitude of 5.4 x10^3 N/C. Both fields point in the same direction. A positive 1.8 µC charge moves at a speed of 2.9x10^6 m/s in a direction that is perpendicular to both fields. Determine the magnitude of the net force that acts on the charge.

Homework Equations


Force = qE
Force = qvBsin(theta)

Electric force + Magnetic force = Net force


The Attempt at a Solution


qE + qvBsin(theta) = net force

(1.8e-6 C * 5.4e^3 N/C ) + ( 1.8e-6C * 2.9e^6m/s *1.2e^-3T*sin(90) =

.0972N + .006264N = .1035N of net force
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Indeed, the electric force has a magnitude of F1=qE and the lorenz force F2=qvBsinθ=qvB because θ=π/2.
What you`re doing wrong is the "qE + qvBsin(theta) = net force" part.
That`s only true if you right it with vectors.
You want the magnitude of the net force. Draw a diagram with the forces acting on the charge, and you`ll easily get the answer
 
im not sure i follow...i made a diagram of the forces acting on the charge (don't laugh):
green = magnetic field
blue = electric field
grey line = direction of velocity of + charge
black dot = + charge
[URL=http://imageshack.us][PLAIN]http://img211.imageshack.us/img211/9798/magneticfieldog1.png[/URL][/PLAIN]

the way I'm seeing it is the force from the magnetic field is pointing out of the page and the force from the electric field is pointed upward. the net force would be a combination of the two, so why can't i add them like vectors?
 
Thats not what you did, you just added them together
 
turdferguson said:
Thats not what you did, you just added them together

ok to correct myself, i made a diagram of what i believe the magnetic field and the electric field to look like. i realize the force of the magnetic field will be pointing out of the screen towards me; the force of the electric field will be directed parallel along the field. does that clear things up?
 
Your diagram is correct, no doubt about that. The forces` direction is as you say as well.
But this
"1.8e-6 C * 5.4e^3 N/C ) + ( 1.8e-6C * 2.9e^6m/s *1.2e^-3T*sin(90) =

.0972N + .006264N = .1035N of net force"
is absolutely wrong. You can't add together the two forces because they haven't the same direction, they are perpendicular to each other ...
So what are we doing in this occasions?
 
JK423 said:
Your diagram is correct, no doubt about that. The forces` direction is as you say as well.
But this
"1.8e-6 C * 5.4e^3 N/C ) + ( 1.8e-6C * 2.9e^6m/s *1.2e^-3T*sin(90) =

.0972N + .006264N = .1035N of net force"
is absolutely wrong. You can't add together the two forces because they haven't the same direction, they are perpendicular to each other ...
So what are we doing in this occasions?

ok, maybe I'm wrong again here but i think i need to find the force that acts in the middle of the 2 forces, since they are perpendicular. I am sure i would use some trigonometric function to accomplish this..
 
"add them like vectors" with the pythagorean theorem
 
Back
Top