Transistor output resistance and thermal voltage

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the thermal voltage of pn junctions and the small signal output resistance of BJTs in amplifier circuits. Participants explore the theoretical and practical aspects of these concepts, seeking clarity on their application in small signal analysis.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant questions whether the thermal voltage (VT) is consistent across all pn junctions or if it varies with doping and diode types, referencing the formula VT = k*T/q.
  • Another participant clarifies that kT/q represents the thermal energy of carriers and is the same for all semiconductors at a given temperature, but device characteristics can differ due to other factors.
  • Concerns are raised about the small signal output resistance (ro) and the Early voltage (VA), with participants noting a lack of practical guidance in textbooks on how to derive these values.
  • A participant suggests that the Early voltage can be determined from collector curves in datasheets, explaining how to find it graphically.
  • Discussion includes the definition of ro as the slope of the collector current versus VCE curve in saturation, emphasizing its dependence on collector current.
  • Another participant mentions that many datasheets provide the common emitter output resistance indirectly through the parameter h_{oe}, which is the reciprocal of ro.
  • It is noted that in practical circuits, the external collector resistor often dominates the parallel combination with ro, making ro less significant in many analyses.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express varying levels of understanding regarding the thermal voltage and output resistance, with some agreeing on the definitions and implications while others seek further clarification. There is no consensus on the practical derivation of ro and VA, indicating ongoing uncertainty in the discussion.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight limitations in textbooks regarding practical applications of theoretical concepts, particularly in deriving values for output resistance and Early voltage. The discussion reflects a reliance on datasheets and graphical methods for practical analysis.

tindel
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
A couple questions:

I'm in the process of making some small amplifiers and using bjt's in the small signal realm. I have used bjt's as switches for quite a while, so I am quite familiar with their basic operation. I was reviewing small signal analysis trying to refresh my memory about how to do the analysis when I came across a couple variables that I'm not sure how to incorporate them into my analysis in a practical sense.

First, thermal voltage of a pn (diode) junction - VT - which my book describes as a 'constant', which is a function of temperature. VT is defined as

VT= k*T / q

where
k is Boltzmann's constant = 1.38 x 10^-23 joules/kelvin,
T= temperature kelvin,
q= magnitude of electronic charge = 1.6 x 10^-19 coulomb

Is this true for all pn junctions - or does this change with doping, diode types, etc?


Second - small signal output resistance, ro - my book does an awful job explaining how to arrive at this value, practically speaking. They give the following equation for the output resistance ro = (VA + VCE) / IC. I have never seen ro or VA in a datasheet. I'm not sure what VA even is. I do understand that ro is a function of collector current due to vce, so I understand why it's used, I just don't understand when I have a circuit I'm analyzing, how to come up with a value of ro!

True to form - my old electronics book tells me how to do all the calculations, but doesn't explain how to arrive at the value in a practical sense. A quick google search also turned up nothing.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
The term kT/q is not really a parameter of the diode (or transistor) itself, but is actually just the thermal energy of the carriers in the semiconductor, expressed in electron volts. The electrical properties of diodes and transistors do depend upon this quantity, but also on many other parameters of the device. So in summary, yes this quantity is the same for all semiconductors at a given temperature, but the characteristics of those different devices can still be different due to other factors like physical dimensions, doping levels and the intrinsic semiconductor material itself.
 
Last edited:
tindel said:
A couple questions:

I'm in the process of making some small amplifiers and using bjt's in the small signal realm. I have used bjt's as switches for quite a while, so I am quite familiar with their basic operation. I was reviewing small signal analysis trying to refresh my memory about how to do the analysis when I came across a couple variables that I'm not sure how to incorporate them into my analysis in a practical sense.

First, thermal voltage of a pn (diode) junction - VT - which my book describes as a 'constant', which is a function of temperature. VT is defined as

VT= k*T / q

where
k is Boltzmann's constant = 1.38 x 10^-23 joules/kelvin,
T= temperature kelvin,
q= magnitude of electronic charge = 1.6 x 10^-19 coulomb

Is this true for all pn junctions - or does this change with doping, diode types, etc?

I cannot answer about the doping, but yes V_T=\frac {kT}{q}\; holds for all transistor and diodes.

Second - small signal output resistance, ro - my book does an awful job explaining how to arrive at this value, practically speaking. They give the following equation for the output resistance ro = (VA + VCE) / IC. I have never seen ro or VA in a datasheet. I'm not sure what VA even is. I do understand that ro is a function of collector current due to vce, so I understand why it's used, I just don't understand when I have a circuit I'm analyzing, how to come up with a value of ro!

True to form - my old electronics book tells me how to do all the calculations, but doesn't explain how to arrive at the value in a practical sense. A quick google search also turned up nothing.

A lot of transistor data sheets provide collector curves for different Ib. To find the early voltage, extend the straight portion of the curve ( the saturation region) to the left side where Vce going to negative. Keep extending all and they all will meed at Ic = 0. Read off the Vce and that's the early voltage.

r_0\; is defined as change of collector current to change of Vce. That is the slope of the collector curve when the transistor is in saturation region ( the straight part of the curve). As you can see, the slope is different for every Ib. Therefore r_0\; is collector current dependent. Normally r_0\; is not that important as you have collector resistor R_L\; which is usually much lower. The total load resistance is r_0\; parallel with R_L\; which essentially just R_L\; when it is a lot lower than the output resistance. It is important when you use it as a current source where you need very high impedance at the output. In IC, most circuit use active load, then it is more important as it affect the gain of the transistor if this is the load on the collector.
 
Last edited:
tindel Second - small signal output resistance said:
o[/SUB] - my book does an awful job explaining how to arrive at this value, practically speaking. They give the following equation for the output resistance ro = (VA + VCE) / IC. I have never seen ro or VA in a datasheet. I'm not sure what VA even is. I do understand that ro is a function of collector current due to vce, so I understand why it's used, I just don't understand when I have a circuit I'm analyzing, how to come up with a value of ro!
Apart from using the "Early voltage" (as explained by yungman above) many datasheets will specify the common emitter r_o indirectly via the parameter h_{oe}. This parameter is in fact the reciprocal of r_o.

Remember that in an actual circuit that the (external) collector resistor will be in parallel with r_o in the small signal model. Very often this external R_C is much lower than r_o and so dominates the parallel combination (meaning that you can often ignore r_o without introducing too much error in the analysis).
 
Thanks uart and yungman - The data you gave on both the early and thermal voltages is very useful. I understand that ro is very large, and with small output resistances, relative to ro I understand that it is not much of a concern unless you have large output resistances.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
5K
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
2K
Replies
68
Views
7K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
16
Views
11K