Trig problems giving a hard time.

  • Thread starter Thread starter labin.ojha
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Hard Time Trig
AI Thread Summary
Two trigonometric problems are discussed: proving that if sin(θ) - cos(θ) = 1, then sin(θ) + cos(θ) = ±1, and proving that if tan(θ) + sec(θ) = 10, then sin²(θ) + cos²(θ) = 1. The first problem can be solved by squaring both sides and applying trigonometric identities, leading to the conclusion that sin(θ) + cos(θ) = ±1. The second problem is identified as an identity, which complicates the approach since it is always true regardless of the initial expression. The discussion highlights the confusion caused by the second problem's nature and suggests that it may have been removed from newer editions of the textbook.
labin.ojha
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
I was having some free time and decided to do some mathematics from my high school mathematics book.These two problems remained, and I am completely clueless to the solution approach.

Homework Statement



A. If sin(θ)-cos(θ)=1, prove that sin(θ)+cos(θ)=±1
B. If tan(θ)+sec(θ)=10, prove that sin^{2}(θ)+cos^{2}(θ)=1

Homework Equations


The Attempt at a Solution



The approach to both problems were similar, I squared both sides of the given equations, and used trig identities at an attempt of simplifying.

That got me nowhere. :frown:

Pointers would be helpful. :smile:
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
labin.ojha said:
A. If sin(θ)-cos(θ)=1, prove that sin(θ)+cos(θ)=±1
B. If tan(θ)+sec(θ)=10, prove that sin^{2}(θ)+cos^{2}(θ)=1
I squared both sides of the given equations, and used trig identities at an attempt of simplifying.
That certainly works for A. If you still can't see it, please post your working.
For B, pay close attention to what is to be proved.
 
haruspex said:
That certainly works for A. If you still can't see it, please post your working.
For B, pay close attention to what is to be proved.

Found a way for A:

sin(θ)-cos(θ)=1
[Squaring]
sin^{2}(θ)-2sin(θ)cos(θ)+cos^{2}(θ)=1=sin^{2}(θ)+cos^{2}(θ)
sin^{2}(θ)+cos^{2}(θ)=sin^{2}(θ)+2sin(θ)cos(θ)+cos^{2}(θ)
1=(sin(θ)+cos(θ))^{2}
[Taking square roots]
sin(θ)+cos(θ)=\pm1

For B, the 'to prove' equation is an identity but getting it from the given expression is being a problem
because as I square the both sides , it gets messier and hopeless.
 
Last edited:
labin.ojha said:
Found a way for A:

sin(θ)-cos(θ)=1
[Squaring]
sin^{2}(θ)-2sin(θ)cos(θ)+cos^{2}(θ)=1=sin^{2}(θ)+cos^{2}(θ)
sin^{2}(θ)+cos^{2}(θ)=sin^{2}(θ)+2sin(θ)cos(θ)+cos^{2}(θ)
1=(sin(θ)+cos(θ))^{2}
[Taking square roots]
sin(θ)+cos(θ)=\pm1

For B, the 'to prove' equation is an identity but getting it from the given expression is being a problem
because as I square the both sides , it gets messier and hopeless.

If the equation to be proved is an identity, you don't have to get it from the other expression. It's just plain always true.
 
Dick said:
If the equation to be proved is an identity, you don't have to get it from the other expression. It's just plain always true.

Yes, it is. But I'll look for the solution and post it here as soon as i get it . :smile:

EDIT:
the question seems to have been removed from the new edition of the book, mine was an old one.
 
Last edited:
labin.ojha said:
Yes, it is. But I'll look for the solution and post it here as soon as i get it . :smile:

There's really nothing to look for or get. This is exactly like proving "If x=2 then x=x." x=x is true regardless of whether x=2 is true. So "If x=2 then x=x." is a true statement.
 
labin.ojha said:
EDIT:
the question seems to have been removed from the new edition of the book, mine was an old one.

Removing it is a good idea. In the context of proving trig stuff, it's only going to cause confusion.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
Back
Top