Variation principle -- looking for resources to read and understand

Click For Summary
The discussion centers on seeking resources for understanding the variation principle in the context of Lagrangian mechanics, particularly for electromagnetic Lagrangians. A user expresses difficulty in performing variations for specific Lagrangian forms, such as those incorporating terms like AμJμ and additional components like L' = βRμνgρσFμρFνσ. Participants recommend several textbooks that cover the Lagrangian formulation and variational principles, including "Spacetime Geometry" by Sean Carroll, "Emily Noether's Wonderful Theorem" by Neuenschwander, "SR and Classical Field Theory" by Susskind, "Elementary Particles" by Griffiths, "QFT for the Gifted Amateur" by Lancaster and Blundell, and "QFT in a Nutshell" by Zee. There is a consensus that foundational understanding of classical mechanics and field theory is essential before delving into quantum field theory, with suggestions to prioritize certain texts for beginners.
Pouramat
Messages
27
Reaction score
1
Summary:: Can anyone introduce an informative resource with solved examples for learning variation principle?

For example I cannot do the variation for the electromagnetic lagrangian when ##A_\mu J^\mu## added to the free lagrangian and also some other terms which are possible:
$$
L = \sqrt{-g}(\frac{-1}{4}F^{\mu \nu}F_{\mu \nu}+A_\mu J^\mu)
$$
also I want to add ##L' = \beta R^{\mu \nu} g^{\rho \sigma}F_{\mu \rho}F_{\nu \sigma}## to lagrangian and then do the variation to see what is the difference, but I cannnot.
Do you know any good resources to understand with solved examples?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
How have you got this far in your physics studies without learning the Lagrangian formulation and variational principle?

I must have at least four text-books that cover this in one form or other. E.g. Spacetime Geometry, by Sean Carroll.
 
PeroK said:
How have you got this far in your physics studies without learning the Lagrangian formulation and variational principle?

I must have at least four text-books that cover this in one form or other. E.g. Spacetime Geometry, by Sean Carroll.
Can you give me another reference except Carroll?
 
Pouramat said:
Can you give me another reference except Carroll?
Emily Noether's Wonderful Theorem - Neuenschwander

SR and Classical Field Theory (The Theoretical Minimum) - Susskind

Elementary Particles - Griffiths

QFT for the Gifted Amateur - Lancaster & Blundell

QFT in a Nutshell - Zee
 
I would first study the action principle within classical mechanics and then classical field theory before I'd go into quantum field theory. For this I'd recommend Landau and Lifshitz vols. 1 and 2.

If you start with the latter, don't take Zee's book. It's fun to read if you know the subject from somewhere else. It's not a good source to start learning it, because it wants to put too much in the nutshell and is thus too superficial to explain QFT for a beginner. Lancaster and Blundell is way better.
 
Many years ago, as the internet was coming of age, I burned over 500 pounds of technical manuals. I realized I can look things up on the internet faster than I can find something in a technical manual. And just about anything I might need could be found online. But letting go of my several shelves worth of college text and other science books is another matter. I can't bring myself to get rid of them but there is very little if anything I can't find online now. Books are heavy and a pain...
This thread only works as a summary from the original source: List of STEM Masterworks in Physics, Mechanics, Electrodynamics... The original thread got very long and somewhat hard to read so I have compiled the recommendations from that thread in an online (Google Drive) spreadsheet. SUMMARY Permits are granted so you can make comments on the spreadsheet but I'll initially be the only one capable of edition. This is to avoid the possibility of someone deleting everything either by mistake...