What is the intersection point of two objects on a position vs time graph?

10 replies · 3K views · last reply
nmnna
Messages
22
Reaction score
3
Homework Statement
Given a position vs time graph.
1)Find ##\frac{v_{2}}{v_{1}}##
2)At what time the objects will meet?
3)Find ##\frac{\Delta{x_2}}{\Delta{x_1}}##, if the second object started moving from the origin.
Relevant Equations
##v = \frac{\Delta{x}}{t}##
The graph:
Graph of x1 and x2 against time, with the horizontal axis 0 to 8 and the vertical axis 0 to 7. Green line x1 starts at 3 on the vertical axis; blue line x2 starts at 0 at time 1 and rises steeper.

1) $$v_1 = \frac{\Delta{x}}{t} = \frac{5 - 3}{3} = \frac{2}{3}$$
$$2 = \frac{\Delta{x}}{t} = \frac{4 - 0}{5 - 1} = 1$$
$$\frac{v_2}{v_1} = \frac{1}{2/3} = \frac{3}{2} = 1.5$$

2)Points of intersection of the lines with the x-axis: ##I## (0; 3) and ##II## (0; -1), thus
$$\frac{2}{3}t + 3 = t - 1$$
$$t=\frac{-4}{(\frac{2}{3} - 1)} = 12 \ \text{seconds after starting motion}$$

I'm confused about the 3rd part.
If the second object starts moving from the origin then the graph should look something like this
Position versus time graph with x on the vertical axis and t on the horizontal axis, showing two straight lines. Line x1 starts at 3 and rises to meet x2 at (9, 9). Line x2 starts at the origin and passes through (9, 9).

We can clearly see that the objects met when 9 seconds passed and calculations lead to the same value as well:
$$\frac{2}{3}t + 3 = t$$
We know that the velocity of the first one is ##\frac{2}{3} \frac{\text{m}}{\text{sec}}##, we can find the distance it passed in 9 seconds, which is ##6## meters, for the second one I got ##9## meters. So the ratio ##\frac{\Delta{x_2}}{\Delta{x_2}} = \frac{9}{6} = 1.5##.
But the answer in my textbook is 1.375
Where I went wrong?
This is a translation from another language so if something is not clear please tell me.
 
Last edited:
nmnna said:
I'm confused about the 3rd part.
So am I . The only explanation I can give that comes out at the book answer is:
3) Assume the point of intersection is the same as in part 2 -- but object 2 started from the origin.

##\ ##
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: hmmm27 and Steve4Physics
BvU said:
So am I . The only explanation I can give that comes out at the book answer is:
3) Assume the point of intersection is the same as in part 2 -- but object 2 started from the origin.
I thought about this situation too, but by solving this i got ##\frac{12}{2/3\times12+3} = \frac{12}{11} \approx 1.09##, which is not the expected answer...
 
What is the position of the intersection point in 2) ?

##\ ##
 
BvU said:
What is the position of the intersection point in 2) ?

##\ ##
Graph of two straight lines plotted on x-y axes, one blue and one green, crossing at about x = 12, y = 11; the blue line is steeper.
 
You can get their answer if you assume that object 2 starts at the position of the origin of the x-axis. (Don't change the original graph for object 2.) Assume object 1 starts at x = 3. The problem should have explicitly stated this if this is what they intended. With this interpretation, the two objects do not start their motions at the same time.
 
Last edited:
TSny said:
You can get their answer if you assume that object 2 starts at the position of the origin of the x-axis. (Don't change the original graph for object 2.) Assume object 1 starts at x = 3. The problems should have explicitly stated this if this is what they intended. With this interpretation, the two objects do not start their motions at the same time.
As I understand from your answer my solution should look something like this, right?
$$\frac{\Delta{x_2}}{\Delta{x_1}} = \frac{(2/3\times12) + 3}{(9\times1) - 1} = \frac{11}{8}$$
[edit] This is wrong
 
I think in order to get the answer you want, you have to consider that the objects will meet at t=12sec. but the second object will have a different velocity. In that case you get : 11/8=1.375. The velocity of the second object has to be 11/12 so that : 12*(11/12)=11=(2/3)*12+3.
 
nmnna said:
As I understand from your answer my solution should look something like this, right?
$$\frac{\Delta{x_2}}{\Delta{x_1}} = \frac{(2/3\times12) + 3}{(9\times1) - 1} = \frac{11}{8}$$
PS This is wrong
I don't understand your calculation. The numerator appears to be calculating the position of object 1 at t = 12, but you're using this for ##\Delta x_2##.

Graph of x against t with two straight lines: a green line starting at x1 = 3 on the vertical axis, and a blue line starting at x2 = 0 at t = 1, both rising with positive slope.


One way to interpret part 3 is to assume that the brown dots represent the starting points of the two objects.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: nmnna
As noted by BVU in the second post in this thread, the book answer for part 3 is correct if (as stated) the 2nd object's line is changed to go through (0,0), and also the original intersection between the objects' lines (12,11) stays the same.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: nmnna
As shown below: green has done 8, red has done 11.

Graph of y against x with gridlines: a blue straight line, a green straight line and a red straight line, with a black circle marking where the lines meet near x = 12, y = 11; the red line starts at the origin.


##\ ##
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: nmnna