What to do after Kleppner and Purcell?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Radarithm
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Kleppner Purcell
AI Thread Summary
For those seeking a mechanics book after K&K that covers Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics, Taylor is recommended, although it has limited coverage of Hamiltonian mechanics. Other notable suggestions include Calkin, Gregory, and Greiner. Griffiths' Electrodynamics is highly regarded and suitable to follow Purcell, with some recommending concurrent study to maximize understanding before advancing to more complex texts like Jackson. Regarding Griffiths' Quantum Mechanics, opinions vary; while it is considered a solid resource, it is advised to focus on mastering analytical mechanics and electromagnetism first. Comparatively, Griffiths' problems are generally seen as slightly easier than those in Purcell, with some suggesting that while Griffiths presents more advanced material, the problem difficulty does not significantly increase. Additionally, alternative texts like Melvin Schwarz's "Principles of Electrodynamics" and Zangwill's E&M book are mentioned as valuable resources, with Zangwill noted for its pedagogical strength.
Radarithm
Gold Member
Messages
158
Reaction score
2
What would be a good mechanics book after K&K that includes Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics? Also, would Griffiths' Electrodynamics be suitable after Purcell? What about Griffiths' Quantum Mechanics (ignoring the math pre-reqs)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Radarithm said:
What would be a good mechanics book after K&K that includes Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics? Also, would Griffiths' Electrodynamics be suitable after Purcell? What about Griffiths' Quantum Mechanics (ignoring the math pre-reqs)?

For mechanics, I think Taylor is pretty nice: https://www.amazon.com/dp/189138922X/?tag=pfamazon01-20

Griffith's Electrodynamics is a very good book. Some call it one of the best physics textbooks ever written, so yes: do that after Purcell.

I'm not really a fan of Griffith's QM, but others seem to like it a lot.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Likes 1 person
Radarithm said:
What would be a good mechanics book after K&K that includes Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics?

Calkin, Taylor, Greiner, Thornton and Marion are but a few (although I hate Thornton and Marion with a passion).

Radarithm said:
Also, would Griffiths' Electrodynamics be suitable after Purcell?

If you can, try your best to do them concurrently. This is the most efficient way to use Griffiths if you have Purcell. That way you can move on to more advanced EM texts (e.g. Jackson) without wasting extra time because Griffiths is only a hair's width more advanced than Purcell in terms of material covered.

Radarithm said:
What about Griffiths' Quantum Mechanics (ignoring the math pre-reqs)?

What about it? It's a brilliant QM book but you should focus on mastering analytical mechanics and EM first.
 
  • Like
Likes poseidon721 and Radarithm
Based on what I've read, I'm going to get Taylor, Gregory, and Griffiths E&M, QM can wait. Thanks for the help!
 
By the way, how do the problems in Griffiths compare (in difficulty) with those in Purcell? I'd be lucky to solve 3 2 star problems in Purcell (2nd Ed. When Morin added more problems). It reminds me of his intro to CM book, which really drove me crazy. In a good way.

Edit: I asked this because WannabeNewton said its a tad harder when it comes to material (which I'm fine with) but that doesn't necessarily mean harder questions (or does it?).
 
Last edited:
Radarithm said:
By the way, how do the problems in Griffiths compare (in difficulty) with those in Purcell?

Griffiths problems are on the whole easier but not by much, at least for me personally.
 
Principles of Electrodynamics by Melvin Schwarz is a good book that is not nearly as difficult as Jackson but much more mathematically sophisticated than either Griffiths or Purcell. Personally, I think Jackson is only OK. Zangwill is a much better graduate level E&M book than anything (including Jackson) on the market. Jackson is mainly concerned with showing you that he knows a lot of math. Zangwill is concerned with giving you insight into Electrodynamics and developing your intuition through examples, applications, and excellent pedagogy.
 
Back
Top