What's Wrong with My Concrete Density Calculation?

  • Thread starter Thread starter chattkis3
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a concrete density calculation involving a hollow spherical cavity. The user initially set up the equation incorrectly by using a plus sign instead of a minus sign in the volume calculation. After clarification, it was confirmed that the correct formula should subtract the volume of the cavity from the total volume. The user experienced frustration due to a computer program rejecting their answer, which was attributed to potential issues with significant figures set by the professor. Ultimately, the user acknowledged the mistake and expressed gratitude for the assistance received.
chattkis3
Messages
12
Reaction score
0
Been working on this for hours!

Ive honestly given this problem 3 or more hours to no avail.

"An irregularly shaped chunk of concrete has a hollow spherical cavity inside. The mass of the chunk is 38 kg, and the volume enclosed by the outside surface of the chunk is 0.025 m3. What is the radius of the spherical cavity?"

This is what I have set up which is not working:
density of concrete = M / (Voutside surface - Vcavity)

what's wrong with that?? thankkks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
shouldn't it be?

\rho_{concrete} = \frac{M}{V_{outside}-V_{cavity}}
 
Last edited:
What makes you think it's wrong?
 
Im getting a negative number if I do M / (Voutside + Vsphere) ... and the value I get (using a density for concrete of 2200) is .12m And the computer program is telling me that is wrong. I feel like I am missing something??
 
I get a different answer. Check you calculations. Remember that
V_{sphere}=\frac{4\pi r^{3}}{3}
 
I don't think you're missing anything. Your original method is correct; your answer seems correct also.
 
Sirus, did you use my original equation with Voutside - Vcavity or Voutside + Vcavity

??
 
Ah, that's why! Yes, I used Cyclovenom's equation with a plus sign, which I think is incorrect. I think Doc Al is right. Try entering the answer with various precisions (round to a different number of decimals) and see if the program accepts your answer.
 
WOW, thanks for that. Let's just say I want a couple hours of my life back. The program is not suppose to be set up to worry about sig figs. But apparently my professor changed that option? **annoyed** thanks for the advice though everyone.
 
  • #10
Oh sorry, actually it was suppossed to be a minus, the question on the top was just because i was :confused: because it wasn't working.
 
Back
Top