Chemistry: How do I write an ionic equation for this reaction?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around writing the ionic equation for the reaction between barium hydroxide and phosphoric acid. The participant is struggling with the concept of dissociation, noting that phosphoric acid is a weak acid and does not fully dissociate in solution, while barium hydroxide is a strong base that completely dissociates. There is confusion about whether to include spectator ions in the ionic equation and how to represent the partial dissociation of phosphoric acid. It is suggested that for simplicity, one might assume that phosphoric acid remains undissociated in this context. The conversation highlights the complexities of representing weak acids in ionic equations, especially when classroom teachings did not cover these nuances.
HunterDX77M
Messages
42
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



I was doing this problem for HW online, that asks to write the ionic equation for a reaction, but I'm completely stuck. After using all my attempts (i.e., I can no longer submit the answer even if it is right, :frown: ) I still couldn't get the right answer. We've only done very simple ionic equations in class, so I couldn't apply what we did in class to the problem. Anyway here is the reaction to make an ionic equation for:

Ba(OH)_2 (aq) + H_{3}PO_{4} (aq) \rightarrow

Homework Equations



Not applicable.

The Attempt at a Solution



Here is the last answer I attempted. Wolframalpha told me that the compound phosphoric acid (H3PO4) was "very soluable" so I separated it into ions. That was about all it was able to help me with. I assumed that the phosphate separated from the hydrogen atoms to combine with the barium and create an insoluable solid (according to my textbook, any non-alkali metal combined with phosphate is insoluable). So with all that, I thought the ionic equation would logically be:

3H^{+}(aq) + 2{PO_4}^{-3}(aq) + 3Ba^{+2}(aq) + 2OH^{-}(aq) \rightarrow Ba_3(PO_4)_2(s) + 3H^{+}(aq) + 2OH^{-}(aq)

This is wrong as my fifth and final attempt told me . . . The super vague reason the system gives me for this being wrong is that "Your answer contains an ambiguous or incomplete reaction equation. Check all the components on the reactant-side of the equation. Check all the components on the product-side of the equation." If you need anymore information on my thought process or anything like that, please ask. Thanks in advance for any help.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Do you need to remove the spectator ions?
 
BloodyFrozen said:
Do you need to remove the spectator ions?

For the net ionic equation, yes, I have to remove the spectator ions. But for this equation (just the plain old ionic equation) I must keep the spectator ions.
 
H++OH- - don't you think they will react?

Phosphoric acid is soluble, but it is a weak acid, so it is not dissociated completely.

Barium hydroxide is weakly soluble, but it is a strong base, so it is completely dissociated.

It is a little bit tricky if you ask me. Not clear to me what they can expect.
 
Borek said:
H++OH- - don't you think they will react?

Umm, do they make water? I'm not sure.

Borek said:
Phosphoric acid is soluble, but it is a weak acid, so it is not dissociated completely.

How do you represent something that only partially dissociates in the equation, though?
 
HunterDX77M said:
Umm, do they make water? I'm not sure.

Yes.

How do you represent something that only partially dissociates in the equation, though?

That's why I have no idea what kind of answer they expect. 1M solution of phosphoric acid acid is approximately 8% (H++H2PO4-) and 92% H3PO4. It is not something you can write in a simple way.
 
Borek said:
1M solution of phosphoric acid acid is approximately 8% (H++H2PO4-) and 92% H3PO4.

Wow we definitely didn't learn that in class. I think based on other problems we're supposed to make the simplifying assumption that the compounds either completely separate or don't separate at all. Is there any way to do this problem with that in mind?
 
The closest would be to assume molecular (undissociated) H3PO4.
 
Back
Top