Basic physics confusion in my structure

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a physics problem involving two stacked boxes, where the confusion lies in determining the correct mass to use when calculating the force on the bottom block. The initial misunderstanding stems from combining the masses of both boxes instead of focusing solely on the bottom block, which is necessary for applying Newton's laws correctly. The correct approach is to analyze the forces acting on the bottom block independently, which leads to using only its mass in calculations. The frictional forces between the blocks and the floor further complicate the scenario, but the key takeaway is that each block can be treated separately when analyzing forces. This clarification highlights the importance of understanding how to apply physics principles to individual components in a system.
x86
Gold Member
Messages
256
Reaction score
18
My physics core is a little bit weak, and this one question confuses me.

Homework Statement


A 3kg box sits on top of a 7 kg box. The object accelerates at 1 m/s^2. Find the force applied on the bottom block; if there are no forces besides this one.


Homework Equations


F= ma


The Attempt at a Solution


So, my initial attempt was F = m * a. m = 7kg + 3kg = 10 kg. F = 10 N.

However, this is incorrect. The answer is supposed to be 3 kg. They only take the bottom block into account and this is extremely confusing for me. Of course, this is from an even larger kinematics question; but this is the only step I do not understand. And it's basically exactly the same as the one I'm asking now.

Why do we use 3 kg, and not 10 kg?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What is "the object" here?
 
The object would be the two blocks, relative to the ground. Could one split this larger object into two smaller objects, and say the force on the bottom block is 7N and the force on the top block is 3N?

I'll tell you the bigger question, that I summarized.

So basically there's two blocks sitting on top of each other. The friction between the blocks is 15 N and the friction between the block and the floor is 10 N.

This means on the bottom block there is a force of 5 N (forward) [since the top block is the one moving, and the frictional force is causing the bottom block to move]

So I'm confused as what mass to use now to find the acceleration.

F = ma

Would it be the mass of the two blocks combined, or can I just use the mass of the bottom block? This is very confusing for me. The correct answer uses only the mass of the bottom block, but I don't understand why
 
Last edited:
I suggest that you state the problem EXACTLY as it was given.
 
I apologize for not being clear.

Okay, so basically there is this block:

knight_Figure_08_32.jpg


The friction between the two blocks (Us = 0.6) and between the floor and the block is Us = 0.2

I draw a freebody diagram and see for the bottom block there is a force of friction with the floor to the left and a force of friction with the block on top to the right, causing said block to move right.

We can say that Ff_block - Ff_floor = ma

Which gives me 9.8 N = ma

I'm confused as to what to use for the mass. The correct answer uses 3kg for the mass, but it should be using 7kg as that's the objects weight. So it seems as if they are splitting the block up. How can they do this? I don't understand how they can use 3 kg for the mass
 
What are you supposed to find? What else is given?
 
x86 said:
I'm confused as to what to use for the mass. The correct answer uses 3kg for the mass, but it should be using 7kg as that's the objects weight. So it seems as if they are splitting the block up. How can they do this? I don't understand how they can use 3 kg for the mass
If you are analyzing forces on the bottom block then of course you'll use the mass of that block in applying Newton's laws.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
Doc Al said:
If you are analyzing forces on the bottom block then of course you'll use the mass of that block in applying Newton's laws.

Ah that's all I really wanted to know, I guess. I was confused, because I was thinking of both blocks as one object
 
Back
Top