Basis of degree of freedom for monoatomic and diatomic mixture

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the ratio Cp/Cv for a mixture of 16 grams of helium (a monatomic gas) and 16 grams of oxygen (a diatomic gas). Participants clarify that helium is not diatomic, which is a common misconception, and emphasize the need to use the correct degrees of freedom for each gas type. The formula for the effective lambda factor of the mixture is introduced, leading to a calculation that results in a Cp/Cv ratio of approximately 1.64. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding the properties of monatomic and diatomic gases in thermodynamic calculations. Overall, the participants seek clarity on the derivation of the formulas used in the calculations.
nomorevishnu
Messages
34
Reaction score
0
hi guys

16 grams of helium gas is mixed with 16 grams of oxygen...
what will be the ratio Cp/Cv of the mixture...

how to calculate it?? i thought on the basis of degree of freedom for monoatomic and diatomic mixture...but that can take me to the answer only by approximation...how do we arrive in a a formula that could get me answer...
 
Physics news on Phys.org
nomorevishnu said:
16 grams of helium gas is mixed with 16 grams of oxygen...
what will be the ratio Cp/Cv of the mixture...

how to calculate it?? i thought on the basis of degree of freedom for monoatomic and diatomic mixture...but that can take me to the answer only by approximation...how do we arrive in a a formula that could get me answer...
Aren't they both diatomic?

AM
 
how?

y do u say that these two are diatomic?

He...its completely satisfied without bonding
He is a noble gas...so y do u say it is diatomic...

moreover someone help me solve the problem yaar...
 
Monatomic Gases:
Helium, Neon, Argon, Krypton, Xenon, Radon
Single atom, or monatomic, gases have the smallest Specific Heat CV.

Diatomic Gases:
Oxygen, Nitrogen, Hydrogen
 
nomorevishnu said:
y do u say that these two are diatomic?

He...its completely satisfied without bonding
He is a noble gas...so y do u say it is diatomic...

moreover someone help me solve the problem yaar...

Of course you are right. I was seeing He and thinking H.

What is the ratio of the number of He atoms to O2 molecules?

AM
 
hi

y isn't anyone helping me get the answer?
please if someone can explain the problem to me...it would do a world of good to me...


please please please...the question again...

16 grams of helium gas is mixed with 16 grams of oxygen...
what will be the ratio Cp/Cv of the mixture...

how to calculate it?? i thought on the basis of degree of freedom for monoatomic and diatomic mixture...but that can take me to the answer only by approximation...how do we arrive in a a formula that could get me answer...
 
nomorevishnu Let helium be the gas 1 and oxygen be the gas 2 .

No. Of moles of Helium: 4 = n1
" " " " oxygen: 0.5 =n2

Lamda factor for a mixture is given by:

L= n1( Cp1) + n2 (Cp2) / n1(Cv1) + n2 (Cv2)

Where Cp1/Cv1=5/3 ( for monoatomic helium)

Cp2/Cv2=7/3 for diatomic oxygen


Answer you get is: 1.62
 
nomorevishnu said:
hi

y isn't anyone helping me get the answer?
please if someone can explain the problem to me...it would do a world of good to me...


please please please...the question again...

16 grams of helium gas is mixed with 16 grams of oxygen...
what will be the ratio Cp/Cv of the mixture...

how to calculate it?? i thought on the basis of degree of freedom for monoatomic and diatomic mixture...but that can take me to the answer only by approximation...how do we arrive in a a formula that could get me answer...
Have you worked out the proportion of numbers of atoms of He to number of molecules of O2?

AM
 
well...i knew that equation...and the answer


but to find the effective lambda...how do we get to such an equation...any proof...its not given in Resnick and Halliday
 
  • #10
nomorevishnu said:
well...i knew that equation...and the answer


but to find the effective lambda...how do we get to such an equation...any proof...its not given in Resnick and Halliday
You have to go to basic principles:

dU = (Cp - Cv)nT = nRT so:

C_p/C_v = \gamma = (C_v + R)/C_v = (1 + R/C_v)

So for the mixed gas:

(C_{peff} - C_{veff})n_{total}dT = n_{total}RdT

C_{peff} = (R + C_{veff})

(1)C_{peff}/C_{veff} = \gamma_{eff} = (R/C_{veff} + 1)

Now:

Vdp = (C_{vHe}n_{He} + C_{vO_2}n_{O_2})dT = C_{veff}n_{total}dT

(2) C_{veff} = (C_{vHe}n_{He} + C_{vO_2}n_{O_2})/n_{total}

Substitute from (2) into (1).

I get 1.64

AM
 
Back
Top