Calculate Change in Entropy of Water & Ice System

  • Thread starter Thread starter tdusffx
  • Start date Start date
tdusffx
Messages
58
Reaction score
0
One kg of ice at 0°C is added to one kg of boiling water. The mixture comes to
equilibrium. What is the change in entropy in cal/K of the system? (Lf = 80cal/g)

a. 300
b. 100
c. 200
d. 50
e. 25

Qcold = -Qhot

Mw*Cw*dT + Lf*Mw = -Mw*Cw*dT + Mw*Lv

All has Mw in common, therefore it should cancel out

Cw*dT + Lf*Mw = -Cw*dT + Mw*Lv

(1cal/g)(Tf - 0) + 80cal/g = -(1cal/g)(Tf-100) + 540cal/g;
I converted the latent heat of vaporation (2.26x10^6J/kg)*(1/4186cal*kg/J*g) ~
540cal/g

after equating the two sides, I got 280C for Tf

My answer for Tf doesn't seem reasonable because the Final Temp should be in between
0-100C

Anyways, My other problem is getting the dQ

I have no idea how to get it...or maybe I do..when it doubt I just ask people out!

dS = dQ/T

if my T is right then just finding dQ problem

Thanks in advance folks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
tdusffx said:
One kg of ice at 0°C is added to one kg of boiling water. The mixture comes to
equilibrium. What is the change in entropy in cal/K of the system? (Lf = 80cal/g)

a. 300
b. 100
c. 200
d. 50
e. 25

Qcold = -Qhot

Mw*Cw*dT + Lf*Mw = -Mw*Cw*dT + Mw*Lv

All has Mw in common, therefore it should cancel out

Cw*dT + Lf*Mw = -Cw*dT + Mw*Lv
Why didn't you cancel the "Mw" out in each term?
Dividing each term in your original equation by mW gives
Cw*dT+ Lf= -Cw*dT+ Lv

(1cal/g)(Tf - 0) + 80cal/g = -(1cal/g)(Tf-100) + 540cal/g;
I converted the latent heat of vaporation (2.26x10^6J/kg)*(1/4186cal*kg/J*g) ~
540cal/g

after equating the two sides, I got 280C for Tf

My answer for Tf doesn't seem reasonable because the Final Temp should be in between
0-100C

Anyways, My other problem is getting the dQ

I have no idea how to get it...or maybe I do..when it doubt I just ask people out!

dS = dQ/T

if my T is right then just finding dQ problem

Thanks in advance folks.
 
I did cancel! ...
 
Then you must mean something different by "cancel" than I do.

You start with
"Mw*Cw*dT + Lf*Mw = -Mw*Cw*dT + Mw*Lv"

and conclude
"Cw*dT + Lf*Mw = -Cw*dT + Mw*Lv"

What exactly did you do in order to "cancel"? Did you divide both sides of the equation by something? Did you add or subtract something from both sides?
 
There are two things I don't understand about this problem. First, when finding the nth root of a number, there should in theory be n solutions. However, the formula produces n+1 roots. Here is how. The first root is simply ##\left(r\right)^{\left(\frac{1}{n}\right)}##. Then you multiply this first root by n additional expressions given by the formula, as you go through k=0,1,...n-1. So you end up with n+1 roots, which cannot be correct. Let me illustrate what I mean. For this...
Back
Top