Can Emission Theory Produce Doppler-Shift Formula?

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Happiness
Messages
686
Reaction score
30
Printed text from a textbook page: "Of the various emission theories, only the original source one is consistent with the ordinary optical result of the Doppler effect for a moving mirror. Explain."


Emission theories propose that the velocity of light depends on the velocity of the light source. But the ordinary Doppler effect assumes the velocity of light remains as ##c## with respect to the ether medium, even when the light source is moving at speed ##v## with respect to the ether. They are saying different things, so how could they be consistent?

Explicitly, the original-source emission theory suggests that the velocity of light measured in the ether frame is ##c+v## when the source moves ahead at speed ##v## with respect to the ether, while the Doppler effect says the velocity of light is still ##c##.

Further, for a mirror moving at speed ##v## (with respect to the ether) towards a light source (stationary with respect to the ether), the Doppler effect gives the frequency of the reflected light as ##f=\frac{c+v}{c-v}f_o##, where ##f_o## is the frequency of the incident light. I don't understand how the original-source emission theory could come up with the same formula.

Explanations of the various emission theories are in the text below.

Source: Introduction to Special Relativity by Robert Resnick
Photo of a printed book page, a text passage on emission theories of light and the Michelson-Morley result, discussing that light velocity depends on the source.

Printed book page of text discussing emission theories of light and the Michelson-Morley experiment, including references to de Sitter observations on double stars and a Michelson-Morley experiment using an extraterrestrial light source.

Footnote text comparing three emission theories: original source theory (velocity stays c relative to the source), ballistic theory (velocity becomes c relative to the mirror), and new source theory (velocity becomes c relative to the mirror image of the source), citing Refs. 8.
 
Just compute the travel of two wave crests under the assumptions of the original emission theory as you quoted it. You readily arrive at the SR correct formula. Note that this analysis is the same as for SR in the emitter frame.