Circuit analysis - current dissipated and pot. difference

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
DevonZA
Messages
181
Reaction score
6

Homework Statement

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution



1.
Circuit schematic with two loop currents I1 and I2: E=10V source and R1=10 ohms on the left loop, R2=20 ohms and E=12V source on the right, R3=40 ohms shared in the middle branch.


2. i) Use mesh analysis to solve for circulating currents I1 and I2.
ii) What is the current dissipated by resistor R1?
iii) What is the potential difference across resistor R3?

3

i)
.
Circuit schematic of a single loop with a 10 V battery on the left, labelled E=10V, and resistors R1=10 ohms on the top and R3=40 ohm on the right; corners labelled A, B, E, F and a clockwise mesh current labelled I1.


Loop ABEFA

E1-I1RI-(I1-I2)R3=0
10-10I1-40(I1-I2)=0
-50I1+40I2=-10
50I1-40I2=10 ... EQUATION 1

Circuit schematic with nodes B, C, D and E: R2 = 20 ohms on the top branch, R3 = 40 ohms on the left branch, E2 = 12 V battery on the right branch, and a mesh current labelled I2 circulating in the centre.


Loop BCDEB

-I2R3-I1R3-I2R2-E2=0
-40I2-40I1-20I2-I2=0
-40I1-60I2=12 ... EQUATION 2

EQ 1 X 4 = 200I1-160I2=40
EQ 2 X 5 = -200I1-300I2=60 +[/B]
= -460I2=100
I2=-0.217A

Substitute I2 into equation 1: 50I1-40(-.217)=10
I1=0.0264Aii) I=V/R
= 10/10
=1A

iii) I3=I1+I2 (KCL)
=(0.0264)+(-0.217)
= -0.1906AVR3 = I3xR3
= -0.1906x40
= -7.624V
 
Loop BCDEB

-I2R3-I1R3-I2R2-E2=0
In their passage through R3, currents I1 and I2 are in opposite directions, so partly cancel. This means their contributions to the R3 voltage will have opposite polarities, one will have a + sign, the other a - sign.

Before using your I1 and I2 values in parts (ii) and (iii) you should have first checked that they correctly satisfy Kirchoff's Laws and your circuit. Do they?
 
Firstly - do we take exit or entrance polarities? By this I mean if we have are working in a clockwise direction would the effect of I2 on R3 be +I2R3 or -I2R3? The examples in my study guide suggest that we use exit polarities. If so then I would do the following:

Loop BCDEB (clockwise)

+I2R3-I1R3+I2R2+E2=0
40I2-40I1+20I2+I2=0
-40I1+60I2=12 ... EQUATION 2


 
Okay I think I have it now:

Loop BCDEB

+12V+40ohm(I2-I1)+2ohmI2=0
40ohmI1-60ohmI2=12V

Eq 1. x 4 200ohmI1-160ohmI2=40V
Eq. 2 x 5 200ohmI1-300ohmI2=60V -
140ohmI2=-20V
I2=-0.14A

Subst I2 into equation 1: 50ohmI1-40ohm(-.014)=10V
50ohmI1=4.4V
I1=0.088A

I3=I1-I2
= 0.088-(-0.14)
= 0.288A

 
DevonZA said:
Firstly - do we take exit or entrance polarities? By this I mean if we have are working in a clockwise direction would the effect of I2 on R3 be +I2R3 or -I2R3? The examples in my study guide suggest that we use exit polarities.
It makes no difference whether you consider clockwise to be positive or negative, just so long as you stay consistent.

If so then I would do the following:

Loop BCDEB (clockwise)

+I2R3-I1R3+I2R2+E2=0
That's right, so far.