Combined Gas Law: Find Volume V2

  • Thread starter Thread starter serendipityfox
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Gas Gas law Law
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving a gas law problem using the combined gas law with given values for pressure, volume, and temperature. Participants highlight the need to convert temperature to Kelvin and clarify the ambiguity of the pressure measurement (psia vs. psig). There is confusion regarding the initial volume and the correct calculations, leading to different answers among users. Ultimately, one participant arrives at a volume of 1.07 liters after correcting their initial assumptions. The consensus suggests that the question may be intended to differentiate between varying levels of student understanding.
serendipityfox
Messages
17
Reaction score
7
Homework Statement
1.1L volume O2 collected in balloon, at 295K, 13.6 psi.
next day... 32C, 0.98 atm
what is the volume in the balloon.

a) 0.107L
b) 1.07L
c) 10.7L
d) 107.0L
Relevant Equations
pv/t = pv/t
1atm = 14.7psi
P1= 13.6 V1= 1.1 T1= 22 P2 = 14.4 V2= x T2 = 32
my answer is 1.51L

am i missing something? 
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Yes, an explanation what the numbers represent. Hint: 22 is NOT T1 in your relevant equation.
 
Damn! I need to convert to Kelvin for gas problems, right
 
  • Like
Likes scottdave and BvU
"13.6 psi" in the problem statement is ambiguous. Is that psia or psig? Doubly confusing since a "balloon" suggests pressure higher than ambient. You can work out the answer both ways and then see whether the available choices allow you to eliminate one possibility. I call that a crummy question.
 
Does increasing the pressure cause the volume to decrease or increase?

Does decreasing the temperature cause the volume to decrease or increase?
 
I get none of the answers that are given.
 
I got (b) 1.07 liter by assuming the 13.6 psi initial condition is psia. Also note, the initial volume is 1.1 liters; I missed that the first time thru (thinking it was 1 liters).
 
gmax137 said:
I got (b) 1.07 liter by assuming the 13.6 psi initial condition is psia. Also note, the initial volume is 1.1 liters; I missed that the first time thru (thinking it was 1 liters).
I also got 1.07 now. Initially I used 293 instead of 305 for some reason.
 
Last edited:
thanks for the answers, i am happy with what i have... i am now sure the question is designed to dilineate two levels of students, and so there's no need for me to progress further for now.
 
Back
Top