Determining Cv Value for Ideal Gases

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the Cv value for ideal gases, specifically air. Users clarify that Cv for diatomic gases like air is 2.5R, and the confusion arises from mixing up Cv with Cp, where the provided solution mistakenly uses Cp instead of Cv. The correct relationship is established as Cp = Cv + R, and for air, the ratio Cp/Cv is typically taken as 1.4. The participants conclude that understanding the degrees of freedom of molecules helps in determining Cv, and the method discussed proves effective for solving similar questions. The conversation emphasizes the importance of distinguishing between Cp and Cv in thermodynamic calculations.
Jaydude
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Stuck on part of this question regarding Cv value:
ImageUploadedByPhysics Forums1427240006.441874.jpg

ImageUploadedByPhysics Forums1427240150.894969.jpg


I don't understand how one can get the value for Cv,

I tried saying Cp - Cv = R (1)
Cp/Cv = 1.5.so rearrange gives Cp=1.5Cv (2)

Now sub 2 into 1 and that gives 0.5Cv = R
But according to solutions that's wrong, Cv is 1010 and I can't get that value!

Please point me in the right direction,

Kind regards ,

Jay
 
Physics news on Phys.org
For air (which is diatomic), Cv = 2.5 R.

Chet
 
Chestermiller said:
For air (which is diatomic), Cv = 2.5 R.

Chet

I see, if R has value 287, then Cv is 717.5 - still not the value used according the solutions which is 1010

Jay
 
Jaydude said:
I see, if R has value 287, then Cv is 717.5 - still not the value used according the solutions which is 1010

Jay
The 1010 value is the constant pressure heat capacity, not the constant volume heat capacity. Divide it by 1.4 to get the constant volume heat capacity.

Chet
 
Chestermiller said:
The 1010 value is the constant pressure heat capacity, not the constant volume heat capacity. Divide it by 1.4 to get the constant volume heat capacity.

Chet

My mistake and confusion - sorry!

I want to start again to make it clear for myself:

In the solutions he uses Cp - R rather than Cv, why? We could have just used value for Cv like you said equal to 2.5R

Ignoring above and continuing like the solutions, how is Cp value obtained? Eg you said it for Cv, what about Cp ? I guess we could times Cv by 1.5 but that defeats the purpose of using Cp - R when we already knew the value of Cv!

(When I try your way of using Cv, the final answer varies slightly)

Kind regards,
 
Last edited:
Jaydude said:
My mistake and confusion - sorry!

I want to start again to make it clear for myself:

In the solutions he uses Cp - R rather than Cv, why? We could have just used value for Cv like you said equal to 2.5R
I don't know why. To figure that out, I would have to be able to read his mind.
Ignoring above and continuing like the solutions, how is Cp value obtained? Eg you said it for Cv, what about Cp ? I guess we could times Cv by 1.4 but that defeats the purpose of using Cp - R when we already knew the value of Cv!
For an ideal gas, Cp = Cv + R. Cv is determined by the number of degrees of freedom of the molecule: Cv=0.5fR. For air at typical temperatures, f = 5, including 3 translational degrees of freedom and 2 rotational degrees of freedom. Even if these relationships are not used, one can always measure the heat capacity of a material.

Chet
 
Chestermiller said:
I don't know why. To figure that out, I would have to be able to read his mind.

For an ideal gas, Cp = Cv + R. Cv is determined by the number of degrees of freedom of the molecule: Cv=0.5fR. For air at typical temperatures, f = 5, including 3 translational degrees of freedom and 2 rotational degrees of freedom. Even if these relationships are not used, one can always measure the heat capacity of a material.

Chet

After researching that I can see what you did there.
For diatomic molecules which is air use Cv = 2.5R . To determine Cp simply use Cp/Cv = k, and usually k is taken as 1.4 unless given.

I used this technique on other questions and it works every time so far, including the question posted above - brilliant!

Thank you!
 
Back
Top