Diagonal Series/Parallel Circuit

  • Thread starter mirroredeyes
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Circuit
6 replies · 5K views · last reply
mirroredeyes
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
I got my test back and was reviewing my question, to find out that I didn't even solve for R2,R3,R4 Current, correctly.

I only got 2.613A correct which was R1, could anyone possibly help me out. I know for parallel circuits voltage drop is equal across circuit but my R1 was in series with the combined resistors, meaning there was a voltage drop.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten solution to a circuit problem asking for the current through each resistor, showing a 100 V source, resistors R1 (30 ohm), R2, R3 (20 ohm), R4 (20 ohm), an equivalent 8 ohm parallel branch, total resistance 38 ohm, and circuit current 2.613 A.
    FRuq6yuh.jpg
    43.1 KB · Views: 596
  • Handwritten solution to a circuit problem: a 100V source with R1 30 ohm, R2 10 ohm, R3 20 ohm and R4 20 ohm, with R3 and R4 in series and R2 in parallel with them, reduced to an 8 ohm equivalent, giving circuit current 2.613 A and branch currents 2.161 A and 0.452 A.
    20190417_17215101.jpg
    41.4 KB · Views: 567
That image is too dim for me to see. Can you post a better one? Use brighter lighting to make the photo.
 
anorlunda said:
That image is too dim for me to see. Can you post a better one? Use brighter lighting to make the photo.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten solution to a series-parallel circuit problem: 100 V source with R1 = 30 ohm, R2 = 10 ohm, R3 = 20 ohm, R4 = 20 ohm, and a parallel reduction to 8 ohm giving total 38 ohm and circuit current 2.613 A.
    20190417_17215101.jpg
    41.4 KB · Views: 498
100/38 ≠ 2.613
Otherwise it looks ok to me.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: mirroredeyes
DaveE said:
100/38 ≠ 2.613
Otherwise it looks ok to me.

Thank you Dave! wow... how did I mess that one up badly. Would you say I should lose 3 marks though? I did properly apply the laws and solve but just made a calculation error.
 
OK so far but they also want to know how the 2.613A is shared between the other resistors. One way to find the remaining current: you can easily find the volts across the triangle of resistors and then the current through each leg.
 
mirroredeyes said:
Thank you Dave! wow... how did I mess that one up badly. Would you say I should lose 3 marks though? I did properly apply the laws and solve but just made a calculation error.
It's not really for me to say, ask your instructor.
If I was focused on teaching concepts, I wouldn't mark off that much. However, I would also want answer in more general terms like I1 = V/(R1+R2||(R3+R4)). Then the numbers would be found last, after the equations.
But, there is a school of thought in engineering classes that the final results matter. If your bridge collapses or your circuit electrocutes someone, no one cares why or how you were wrong. This is more like the real world, where you need to check your results for errors (there will be errors, we all do that). Sometimes instructors want to make that clear with harsh penalties.