Differentiating Op-Amp basic exercise

[Femme_physics]

Homework Statement

Given here is an Operational Amplifier, its feeding Voltages are +-10.

A) Calculate Vin to get a Vout of -2V, point out the direction of the current in this case (From a to b or b to a)

http://img72.imageshack.us/img72/2550/needheed.jpg

The Attempt at a Solution

http://img844.imageshack.us/img844/4493/blury.jpg

Is this the right formula?The Vx's are at point a and c, that I know.

 

[I like Serena]

How did you get this formula?
And what is V1?

Do you have a list of relevant equations?

 

[technician]

This is an amplifier with negative feedback. The main things you need to know about such an amplifier are:
1) The V at the - and the V at the + inputs can be assumed to be equal (V at a = V at c = +4V)
2) the input resistance is infinite, this means that no current flows into or out of the - and + input terminals.
the thing to do now is calculate some currents.
Current will flow from V in through R1 towards the - input, so Iin = V/R1, V is the voltage ACROSS R1
Iin = (Vin- 4)/R1... check that you are OK with this !
This current does NOT flow into the -input, so it must go up through R2.
This current passing through R2 will produce a PD = I x R2
So a voltage of R2 x (Vin-4)/R1...( 2Vin -8) ... put in the values of R1 and R2) will be developed across R2 (this is the familiar form of the equation for the gain of an amplifier of this sort... I hope you recognise it!)
I have the current flowing from left to right through R1 and R2 so this means that the voltage at the right hand end of R2 must be the voltage at the - terminal MINUS the voltage we have calculated across R2 (are you still with it?)
So V at the right hand 'pointed end' of the amplifier must be 4 -(2Vin - 8)
so V = 12 -2Vin .
Because of the 4V battery connected to the end of the amplifier Vout = V at end of amplifier -4
So 12 -2Vin -4 = Vout
So 8 - 2Vin = Vout
If Vout =-2 then 8-2Vin = -2... gives Vin =+5V
I hope you can follow this !
I will make my next post assuming that Vin = 5 volts and follow it through.

There is a lot to follow here ! I hope you get something from it.
I will make another post explaining what happens assuming that Vin = +5V

 

[technician]

Now here is what happens if we know that Vin = 5V.
(You have to accept that the V at the - input = The V at the + input) This is ESSENTIAL
V across R1 = 5-4 = 1 Volt
Therefore current through R1 = V/R = 1/5000 = 0.0002A
No current flows into the - terminal, therefore this current MUST flow through R2 (10,000)
So the voltage developed across R2 = I x R2 ... = 0.0002 x 10,000 = 2V
The voltage at the Right hand end of R2 is therefore 2 volts LOWER than at the left hand end
Therefore the voltage at the RIGHT end of R2 is (4-2) = +2V (remember the volts at the - input =4V).
There is a 4V battery connected with its + terminal to the Right end end of R2 so the voltage at the -terminal of the battery is -4 volts lower than at the + end.
The + end is at +2V so the -end (Vout) must be -2V
Hope this helps

 

[Femme_physics]

How did you get this formula?
And what is V1?

Do you have a list of relevant equations?

Yes, teacher gave it to us...

V1 is what in the drawing, I guess?

http://img809.imageshack.us/img809/425/diffformulas.jpg

This is an amplifier with negative feedback.

Because Vin goes into the minus, right?

1) The V at the - and the V at the + inputs can be assumed to be equal (V at a = V at c = +4V)

Yes, we called those Vx in class.

2) the input resistance is infinite, this means that no current flows into or out of the - and + input terminals.

I was trying to google "how op-amps" work after this statement. I didn't find one that refers to this line. But I'll try to ask my classmates/teacher.

the thing to do now is calculate some currents.
Current will flow from V in through R1 towards the - input, so Iin = V/R1, V is the voltage ACROSS R1
Iin = (Vin- 4)/R1... check that you are OK with this !

It's -4 and not +4 because this is occurring on the minus leg?

I'll comment and ask more questions later, I'm trying to do few at a time...

 

[technician]

Op amps have such a high gain (100,00+) that you can assume that any difference in volts at a or c is negligible.
That is why it is OK to say Va = Vc = your Vx (in this question because of the 4 volt battery connected to the + input the voltage at the - input must be +4 volts
An ideal voltage amplifier should have infinite resistance so that no current is drawn from the source. (in a similar way an ideal voltmeter should have infinite resistance)
Op amps are designed to have an extremely high input resistance (Millions of ohms) so it is safe to assume that no (negligible) current flows into the input.
The V at the - input has to be the same as the V at the +input which is +4V.
The - at the - input tells you what the amplifier does to a Voltage at this input.
If V at the - input increase in the + direction then the effect is to make the OUTPUT voltage decrease (go in the negative direction.
The - input is called the 'inverting' input.
Think of a see saw with the pivot very close to one end. Push the end down and the other end goes up.
Hope this helps

 

[I like Serena]

Well, your formula does not make sense to me.

And I also do not understand why your teacher called it a differentiating amplifier.
It isn't.
It's also not a differential amplifier, although your new formula is for that.



Here's a picture of a differential amplifier.

The corresponding formula (symbols from the picture) is V_{out} = (V_2 - V_1) {R_f \over R_1}



What you have looks more like an inverting amplifer.
Here's the picture:

The corresponding formula (symbols from the picture): V_{out} = -{R_f \over R_{in}}V_{in}.




With the extra batteries included, your formula should be (I'm not going to explain it now):
V_{out} = V_1 - (V_{in} - V_1) {R_2 \over R_1} - V_2
However, this does not look like your formula.

 

[technician]

I agree with 'I like Serena' final equation taking V1 to be the battery connected to the + input and V2 to be the battery connected at the output.
In your case V1 and V2 are equal to 4V so the equation reduces to
Vout = 4 - (Vin -4)R2/R1 -4
Vout = (4 - Vin)R2/R1
Substituting Vout =-2 and R2 =10k and R1 = 5k gives Vin = +5volts

 

[technician]

A completely irrelevant point!... I have never met such a circuit in practice.
It looks like an exercise to test your ability to analyse op amp circuits

 

[Femme_physics]

Thanks technician, ILS!

There is a second clause asking me what is Vin if Vout = 8V

So I think I got it right now http://img412.imageshack.us/img412/1879/voutvin.jpg

Well, your formula does not make sense to me.

And I also do not understand why your teacher called it a differentiating amplifier.
It isn't.

Sorry, I may have made a mistake mishearing/miscopying...

 

[I like Serena]

Looks good! ;)

But do you know how to get the formula?

 

[Femme_physics]

Looks good! ;)

Thanks, master!

But do you know how to get the formula?

Well, yea, I ask Klaas ...


You mean the development of the formula? No, not really. It's a bit blurry to me.

 

[technician]

You have made a tiny mistake in the equation
+8 = +4 - (Vin - 4) x 2 -4
+8 = +4 -2Vin +8 -4
+8 = -2Vin +8
0 = -2Vin
so Vin = 0
Can you see where you missed a - x a -
You have got it ! well done

 

[Femme_physics]

Oopsie daisy! Silly me. Thanks.

http://img214.imageshack.us/img214/9742/105ok.jpg

 

[technician]

well done. Your original post was Op-amp basic exercise ! This was NOT a BASIC exercise !

 

[Femme_physics]

well done. Your original post was Op-amp basic exercise ! This was NOT a BASIC exercise !

Oh, didn't know...though it seems pretty basic to me. What would you call it?

 

[technician]

It is unusual and there is one more thing you may need to worry about!
In the last calculation with Vout = 8V this means that the voltage at the output of the amplifier would be +12V (8V + that 4V battery)
If you go back to your original post you will see that the power supply is +10 to -10.
The voltage at the output of the amplifier cannot be greater and cannot be less than +10 and -10 so there is an inconsistency here ! I wonder if, whoever set the question, was aware of this ?
It is a detail that is easily overlooked.
I would love to know what your teacher/tutor makes of this
Try to let me know
By the way, the most basic set up to look at is when there are no extra batteries added
The equation then becomes Vout = -Vin x R2/R1

 

[Femme_physics]

In the last calculation with Vout = 8V this means that the voltage at the output of the amplifier would be +12V (8V + that 4V battery)

Oh! I was not aware of this, technician. I will ask my teacher tomorrow morning as I have a class with him.

Thanks. I will let you know, I promise.

By the way, the most basic set up to look at is when there are no extra batteries added
The equation then becomes Vout = -Vin x R2/R1

Duly noted

 

[I like Serena]

Thanks, master!

That's all right.

Well, yea, I ask Klaas ...

He must be really smart then!
Who is he?

You mean the development of the formula? No, not really. It's a bit blurry to me.

Oh well, perhaps some day soon the fog will rise.

 

[Femme_physics]

Nice pic!

He must be really smart then!
Who is he?

He is Klaas, The Klaasmaster of all Classes

Oh well, perhaps some day soon the fog will rise.

I bet!

 

[Femme_physics]

Oh! I was not aware of this, technician. I will ask my teacher tomorrow morning as I have a class with him.

Thanks. I will let you know, I promise.

As promised! Yes, you were right, my teacher confirmed it and also added it was not his exercise, and that there must be a mistake.

 

[technician]

Thank you so much for letting me know.
I hope you feel good about op-amps !

 

[Femme_physics]

Almost! trying to figure out their basis of operation https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=552064".

And of course, you're the one who should be thanked!

 

[technician]

I have looked at your 'here'
It is a basic circuit.
I will put something together for you about op amps. There are lots of technical details and it is easy to get confused by them. Most of them are not important.
The basic principles are not hard to get to grips with.
I will keep in touch with you about op amps
Cheers

 

[Femme_physics]

Yes, most websites I've seen do include a lot of seemingly unnecessary confusing nitty-gritty info.

I will put something together for you about op amps. There are lots of technical details and it is easy to get confused by them. Most of them are not important.
The basic principles are not hard to get to grips with.
I will keep in touch with you about op amps

Well, I'm always here, ready to read watcha got
Cheers

 

[cepheid]

Well, your formula does not make sense to me.

And I also do not understand why your teacher called it a differentiating amplifier.
It isn't.
It's also not a differential amplifier, although your new formula is for that.
Here's a picture of a differential amplifier.

The corresponding formula (symbols from the picture) is V_{out} = (V_2 - V_1) {R_f \over R_1}

Hey Serenophile,

Maybe you can explain something. I thought that every op-amp was a differential amplifier in the sense that it amplifies the difference between the + input and the - input. Why, then, is there a specific configuration referred to as a differential amplifier above? Is it just because op-amps are never operated open-loop, and what you have above is the stable, closed-loop op-amp design that happens to produce a differential output?

 

[cepheid]

I should also probably contribute something useful to this thread rather than just hijacking it, right? Umm...okay. To the OP: here is a link to a site with some info on op-amps:

http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/electronic/opampcon.html#c1

 

[I like Serena]

Hey Serenophile,

Maybe you can explain something. I thought that every op-amp was a differential amplifier in the sense that it amplifies the difference between the + input and the - input. Why, then, is there a specific configuration referred to as a differential amplifier above? Is it just because op-amps are never operated open-loop, and what you have above is the stable, closed-loop op-amp design that happens to produce a differential output?

Hey Asterophile!

Yes it amplifies the difference by a million.
But for a difference we do not want amplification by a zillion, we want *just* the difference.
An additional complication with amplification by a zillion, or open-loop in general, is that the op-amp gets saturated and just gives off either max + or max -.

As an added bonus the differential amplifier configuration allows us to set an amplification that deviates from 1.

I should also probably contribute something useful to this thread rather than just hijacking it, right? Umm...okay. To the OP: here is a link to a site with some info on op-amps:

http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/electronic/opampcon.html#c1

Nice link.

 

[Femme_physics]

While we use this thread to ask questions...how do you call this Op-Amp?

http://img143.imageshack.us/img143/802/thisstype.jpg

 

[technician]

It is an inverting amplifier because the input is connected to the -input