Find out specification for a component

  • Thread starter Thread starter Yan9370
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Component
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around determining the specifications, particularly heat conductivity, of a heat component on a PCB, specifically a resistor modeled in SolidWorks. The user observed a significant discrepancy between simulated and actual temperatures, prompting the need for calibration. Participants suggested that the lack of a datasheet complicates the process, as it typically contains essential thermal resistance data. They emphasized the importance of understanding how the component's heat dissipation is modeled and recommended consulting the manufacturer for precise specifications. Overall, accurate thermal modeling and manufacturer guidance are crucial for resolving the discrepancies in temperature readings.
Yan9370
Hello Guys,
I am having a heat component on a PCB, constant voltage is applying on the heat source for a period of time.I can measuring the temperature of the heat component before and after the testing. Just wondering is there any way to find out the specification of the heat component ? Like the heat conductivity ?
I have attached my 3D model for the heat component below.

Thank you so much!
 

Attachments

Last edited by a moderator:
Engineering news on Phys.org
Yan9370 said:
Hello Guys,
I am having a heat component on a PCB, constant voltage is applying on the heat source for a period of time.I can measuring the temperature of the heat component before and after the testing. Just wondering is there any way to find out the specification of the heat component ? Like the heat conductivity ?
I have attached my 3D model for the heat component below.

Thank you so much!
Welcome to the PF. :smile:

What is a "Heat component on a PC Board"? Why would you on-purpose put a hot or heating component on a PC Board? Usually you want your electronic components on your PC Board Assembly (PCBA) to be as cool as possible.

Can you provide more details? Can you post a datasheet for this component? Why do you want a heated component on a PCBA?
 
berkeman said:
Welcome to the PF. :smile:

What is a "Heat component on a PC Board"? Why would you on-purpose put a hot or heating component on a PC Board? Usually you want your electronic components on your PC Board Assembly (PCBA) to be as cool as possible.

Can you provide more details? Can you post a datasheet for this component? Why do you want a heated component on a PCBA?

Sorry, I wasn't very clear.
I created a 3D model on SolidWorks(the one that i attached) with a electronic components on PCB, according to the simulation results on SolidWorks, the electronic component was heated up to 65 degree. However, in real test that i did it only heated up to 34 degree.The component was originally at room temperature.
I would like to calibrate SolidWorks simulation results with this real resting. Unfortunately, i don't have datesheet for this electronic component. So that is why i am wondering is there any way to figure out the specification for this electronic component.

Hope this would make my self a bit more clear.
Thank you !
 
Yan9370 said:
Sorry, I wasn't very clear.
I created a 3D model on SolidWorks(the one that i attached) with a electronic components on PCB, according to the simulation results on SolidWorks, the electronic component was heated up to 65 degree. However, in real test that i did it only heated up to 34 degree.The component was originally at room temperature.
I would like to calibrate SolidWorks simulation results with this real resting. Unfortunately, i don't have datesheet for this electronic component. So that is why i am wondering is there any way to figure out the specification for this electronic component.

Hope this would make my self a bit more clear.
Thank you !
I get a security warning when I try to open that PDF file. How did you pick the "components" for your simulation? How are you modeling them? Are you just putting in power dissipation numbers and physical sizes? How are you modeling the heat sinking provided by the component pins and PCB traces? That may be one reason that your real-world PCBA components are not heating up as much as in your simulation.
 
berkeman said:
I get a security warning when I try to open that PDF file. How did you pick the "components" for your simulation? How are you modeling them? Are you just putting in power dissipation numbers and physical sizes? How are you modeling the heat sinking provided by the component pins and PCB traces? That may be one reason that your real-world PCBA components are not heating up as much as in your simulation.

I just used a 50ohm resistor. I modeled the components and the PCB with scale 1:1 in SolidWorks and simply putting in power to the electronic component as a volume heat source. I don't have datasheet for the components but i found a similar one online : https://ca-en.alliedelec.com/caddock-mp9100-50-0-1-/70089611/

Is there any way to find out the specific heat and thermal conductivity of this component?

Thank you!
 
Can you clarify...

The only component on the PCB is a resistor in a T0-247 package?
How much power is it dissipating in the model and in real life? The same?
Where are you measuring/comparing the temperatures? On the case of the T0-247? In the air above it?

In real life the power is dissipated in the middle of the T0-247 package and it's conducted to the outside (Thermal resistance, Junction to Case is 1.50 °C⁄W). I'm not familiar with SolidWorks but how does it model a "volume heat source"? I dare say the surface temperature isn't the same as it would be for a T0-247 dissipating the same power.
 
Yan9370 said:
Unfortunately, i don't have datesheet for this electronic component. So that is why i am wondering is there any way to figure out the specification for this electronic component.

Quoting from pg 2 of the data sheet at: http://www.caddock.com/Online_catalog/Mrktg_Lit/MP9000_Series.pdf
Momentary Overload: 1.5 times rated power with
applied voltage not to exceed 1.5 times maximum
continuous operating voltage for 5 seconds. ∆R
±(0.5 percent + 0.0005 ohm) max.


Roughly, this type of spec. gives you an idea of how long it takes the innards of the device to exceed the maximum storage temperature, but that's not specified for this component. Instead they specify overload to keep within the resistance tolerance. You could calculate maximum internal temperature using the worst-case temperature coefficient of resistance from the data sheet.
But really, I suggest you ask the manufacturer.
 
Back
Top