Find the acceleration of the hanging block

Click For Summary
The discussion focuses on finding the acceleration of a hanging block in a two-block, two-pulley system, with all pulleys assumed to be massless and frictionless. Participants analyze forces acting on the blocks and the pulley, leading to equations involving tensions and accelerations. A key point is the relationship between the accelerations of the two blocks, where the acceleration of the block on the table is twice that of the hanging block. The final derived formula for the acceleration of the hanging block is a2 = m2g / (4m1 + m2). The conversation emphasizes the importance of understanding the mechanics of pulleys and the relationships between the variables involved.
  • #31
Emily_20 said:
For the first block (m1):
Fx T=m1a1 ✔ [/size][/color]

For the second block (m2):
Fy T-m2g=-m2a2 [/size][/color]

For the pulley:
T=0 [/size][/color]

Is it right now (I put a1 and a2)?
Those T's won't all be equal, though.

I thought you may not be au fait with pulleys, that's why I'm encouraging you to construct something similar to the arrangement you are analysing, so that you discover something new here. Anchor one end of the string to a nail in the wall, and tie the other end to a book lying on your table. Hang the string over the edge of the table, and hold a small round bottle or just a pencil in the loop of the hanging string so it serves the purpose of the lower pulley hanging in the rope. When you make the book slide 10cm along the tabletop towards the edge, how many cm does this cause the lower "pulley" sink?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
Fx 1T=m1a1

For the second block (m2):
Fy 2T-m2g=-m2a2

For the pulley:
1T+1T-2T=0
Is it right now?
 
  • #33
Emily_20 said:
Fx 1T=m1a1

For the second block (m2):
Fy 2T-m2g=-m2a2

For the pulley:
1T+1T-2T=0
Is it right now?

Your two equations are right but your last eq. is not correct.
There two many 'T's floating around. And also there are two tension as there are two strings.
I think this figure will make you clear
1418ljc.jpg


Now can you find relation between ##T_{1}## and ##T_{2}##?
 
  • #34
Fx 1T=m1a1

For the second block (m2):
Fy 2T-m2g=-m2a2

For the pulley:
1T+1T-2T=0

That looks better.
 
  • #35
Do you mean T2=T1? Thanks for help I appreciate it.
 
  • #36
Emily_20 said:
Do you mean T2=T1? Thanks for help I appreciate it.

No that's not correct.
As the pulley is mass less so no net force should act on it.
Now can you tell me what are the forces acting on the pulley?
Emily_20 said:
Thanks for help I appreciate it.
You are welcome.
 
  • #37
So Fnet for pulley equals zero? So no tension?
 
  • #38
Emily_20 said:
So Fnet for pulley equals zero? So no tension?

##F_{net}=0##
This does not means that no force acts on it.
Think of a situation in which a block is kept on the floor and it is being pushed in right direction by the force of ##20N## and in the left direction by the force of ##20N##. The two forces cancels each other so ##F_{net}=0## .
But two forces are still acting on it however they are canceled by each other.

So for pulley
There is ##2T_{1}## is acting in upward direction and ##T_{2}## is acting in downward direction.
So ##2T_{1}-T_{2}=0##
So ##2T_{1}=T_{2}##

Now you need to find relation between ##a_{1}## and ##a_{2}##.
 
  • #39
So now I have:

Fx T1=m1a1

For the second block (m2):
Fy T2-m2g=-m2a2

For the pulley:
2T1=T2

So:

2T1-m2g=-m2a2

2(m1a1)-m2g=-m2a2

Am I on the right track? Thank you!
 
  • #40
Emily_20 said:
So now I have:

Fx T1=m1a1

For the second block (m2):
Fy T2-m2g=-m2a2

For the pulley:
2T1=T2

So:

2T1-m2g=-m2a2

2(m1a1)-m2g=-m2a2

Am I on the right track? Thank you!

Correct.
Go ahead.
 
  • #41
Actually I'm stuck now because I don't know what to do with a1 and a2. Can you guide me please.
 
  • #42
Emily_20 said:
Actually I'm stuck now because I don't know what to do with a1 and a2. Can you guide me please.
Do you know calculus?
I have labelled the three parts of the string (let it's length be ##l##).
1418ljc (1).jpg


From the figure

##x+2z+y=l##

If you differentiate this equation with respect to time (two times) you will get the relation between ##a_{1}## and ##a_{2}##.
 
  • #43
Sorry I don't know calculus and my physics course is based on Algebra could you help me with this one?
 
  • #44
I need to find n terms of m1,m2, and g. find the acceleration of the hanging block in the two-block/ two-pulley setup shown in the diagram
 
  • #45
Emily_20 said:
Sorry I don't know calculus and my physics course is based on Algebra could you help me with this one?

You don't need to know very much about the calculus.
Do you know that ##\frac{dx}{dt}=v## and ##\frac{dv}{dt}=a##

Any way, can you tell me if you pull ##m_{2}## by ##x## then how much distance will ##m_{1}## covers?
 
  • #46
I think x/2?
 
  • #47
Emily_20 said:
I need to find n terms of m1,m2, and g. find the acceleration of the hanging block in the two-block/ two-pulley setup shown in the diagram

By this method you will find the accelerations in terms if m1,m2 and g.
If you differentiate the equation two times wrt time you will see that all those variable would vanish and you will get a relation between ##a_{1}## and ##a_{2}##.

You can do it without calculus too. :rolleyes:
Just try to find the answer of the question in #post45.
 
  • #48
I really do not know how to get from 2(m1a1)-m2g=-m2a2 . I am sorry, its difficult for me Could you give me more hints
 
  • #49
Emily_20 said:
I think x/2?

Yes.:)
So if the acceleration of ##m_{2}## is ##a_{2}## then acceleration of ##m_{1}## is ##\frac{a_{2}}{2}##

Now can you find relation between a1 and a2?
 
  • #50
2(m1a2/2)-m2g=m2a2
 
  • #51
2m12a2/2-m2g=m2a2
 
  • #52
I got a2=m2g/(2m1-m2)
 
  • #53
No.
I think I lead you on a wrong path. Sorry for that.:s
If m2 is pulled by 'x' distance then m1 is pulled by '2x' distance.

So ##a_{1}=2a_{2}##.
Just use this value and find the answer.
 
  • #54
2(m12a2)-m2g=-m2a2
 
  • #55
Emily_20 said:
2(m12a2)-m2g=-m2a2

Correct. Go ahead.
 
  • #56
4m1a2-m2g=-m2a2

a2=m2g/(4m1+m2)
 
  • #57
Emily_20 said:
4m1a2-m2g=-m2a2

a2=m2g/(4m1+m2)

That looks good to me.:)
 
  • #58
Thank you so much! you're my genius hero lol. Thank you everyone else who helped me too I appreciate it very much you saved me!
 
  • #59
I understand everything so far but I am confused about this part:" If m2 is pulled by 'x' distance then m1 is pulled by '2x' distance.

So a1=2a2." how did you know that the distance is 2x?
 
  • #60
a2=m2g/(4m1+m2) is the final answer correct?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 34 ·
2
Replies
34
Views
4K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
8K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K