German Electric Train Starts Singing: Is It True?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaveC426913
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Electric Train
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the claim that a German electric train can produce musical sounds while powering up. Participants express curiosity about the authenticity of this phenomenon, noting that some electric devices, like model aircraft speed controllers, can emit tones through vibrations. While some believe the train's sound is charming and potentially real, skepticism remains regarding whether the sounds are natural or artificially enhanced. Comparisons are made to other transit systems, like the Montreal subway, which used to play musical notes, suggesting a precedent for such features. Overall, the idea of adding musical elements to electric trains is seen as a delightful enhancement, regardless of the current reality.
DaveC426913
Gold Member
Messages
23,911
Reaction score
7,949
Engineering news on Phys.org
Possibly.

Some electric model aircraft speed controllers play tones/ beeps by vibrating the armature to indicate the state of programmable features.
 
:smile: Yes indeed charming. And with electronic controls, very believable.

Changing the frequency of firing rates as a function of speed is like shifting gears in a transmission.

I imagine that an alien from a world with only electric drives would be charmed by the sounds of a Harley accelerating. :wink:
 
DaveC426913 said:
Is it true?

Montreal subways play a pleasant four note sequence on starting. Well, in mid 80's they did. Sigh, seems like only yesterday.
Of course they're way smaller machines.

So yes i believe it's real...
 
I'm still not convinced. I've watched several other videos of the train, and although the notes do change, they are all monotonic. Either someone has "layered" the sound track in a clever way, or someone has added an acoustic system to augment the trains natural tones. In either case, I think it is a pleasant effect, and if not real, it should be added to all electric commuter trains.

Our local e-commuter train used to routinely run over people when it first went into service.
It's name quickly evolved from MAX(Metro Area eXpress) to Mad Max.

Actually, listening to the following, I just realized that if two trains were leaving at once, it might create the same effect. But I think the timing would have to be perfect to get them to make harmonious music, as in Dave's video.


Eisenbahn Musik - Taurus Tonleiter - Musical Train Engines
Published on Jun 18, 2013
Taurus Tonleiter - Lokomotive macht Musik
E-Lok Baureihe 182 der DB
ÖBB BR 1016 1116
Siemens ES64U2 - Elektrolokomotive Abfahrt
Musical Train Engines - Electric Locomotive
Sound noises
Zuggeräusche Eisenbahn Taurus

ps. If anyone is really bored, you can watch the following.
14 ½ minutes of listening to LOTS of these trains leave the station.



I could only make it through the first 3 minutes.
 
  • Like
Likes jim hardy
I thought i'd seen it all...
Singing Tesla Coils ?

 
  • Like
Likes DaveC426913 and Merlin3189
While I was rolling out a shielded cable, a though came to my mind - what happens to the current flow in the cable if there came a short between the wire and the shield in both ends of the cable? For simplicity, lets assume a 1-wire copper wire wrapped in an aluminum shield. The wire and the shield has the same cross section area. There are insulating material between them, and in both ends there is a short between them. My first thought, the total resistance of the cable would be reduced...
Hey guys. I have a question related to electricity and alternating current. Say an alien fictional society developed electricity, and settled on a standard like 73V AC current at 46 Hz. How would appliances be designed, and what impact would the lower frequency and voltage have on transformers, wiring, TVs, computers, LEDs, motors, and heating, assuming the laws of physics and technology are the same as on Earth?
I used to be an HVAC technician. One time I had a service call in which there was no power to the thermostat. The thermostat did not have power because the fuse in the air handler was blown. The fuse in the air handler was blown because there was a low voltage short. The rubber coating on one of the thermostat wires was chewed off by a rodent. The exposed metal in the thermostat wire was touching the metal cabinet of the air handler. This was a low voltage short. This low voltage...
Back
Top