In summary, the article examines how a magnet falling through a solenoid and a pipe along its axis can be modeled using the point dipole model. There is a similarity and a difference between the two models, with the difference being in the conceptual connection of the constituent rings. The magnet makes a lot of noise when descending and the current in the pipe is helical.
  • #1
kuruman
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
2023 Award
14,151
7,666
Introduction
In an earlier article, we examined a magnet falling through a solenoid. We argued that the point dipole model can account for the basic features of the induced emf across the solenoid ends. Here, we extend the model to a magnet falling through a conducting pipe along its axis.
With the falling dipole moment oriented along the vertical ##z##-axis, the electric field ##E(\rho,z)## is tangent to circles centered on the axis.  The induced emf around a closed loop of radius ##\rho## is ##\text{emf}(z)=2\pi \rho~E(\rho,z)##. There is a similarity and a difference between a solenoid and a conducting pipe placed in that space.  The similarity is in their modeling as a stack of conducting rings. The difference is in the conceptual connection of the constituent rings.  In the solenoid, the rings are in series and the overall emf across them is of interest.  In the pipe...

Continue reading...
 
  • Like
  • Love
Likes bob012345, berkeman, Delta2 and 2 others
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
As the magnet is continuously moving down the tube, the current would seem to follow a helical, rather than circular, path.
 
  • #3
tech99 said:
As the magnet is continuously moving down the tube, the current would seem to follow a helical, rather than circular, path.
Can you elaborate? The assumption is that the point dipole is perfectly aligned along the z-axis and is moving along it. Therefore the emf is perfectly azimuthal. I can see a helical current in a solenoid if its ends are connected to something but not a pipe.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71
  • #4
I guess it's a very complicated problem, if you consider the case that the magnet in addition to falling down in the specified orientation is in addition rotating. Then of course the current in the pipe becomes much more complicated too.
 
  • #5
If you cut a slit in the pipe in the axial direction the effect is still present.
 
  • #6
Mister T said:
If you cut a slit in the pipe in the axial direction the effect is still present.
Sure, and if you flatten out the cut pipe into a rectangle, there will still be an induced current opposing the motion of the dipole. Free charges will always be pushed around if present and Lenz's law is here to stay.
 
  • #7
vanhees71 said:
I guess it's a very complicated problem, if you consider the case that the magnet in addition to falling down in the specified orientation is in addition rotating. Then of course the current in the pipe becomes much more complicated too.
The magnet makes a lot of noise when descending. When it drops out of the bottom it does not seem to be spinning (due to a helical current), but I can't be sure. Maybe the vertical axis of the magnet rotates (like precession) as it goes down?
 
  • #8
Sure, I guess in practice if you release a bar magnet with its polarization pointing parallel to ##\vec{g}## it will stay in this orientation with sufficient accuracy. Also the experimental results in the papers quoted in this thread and in the Insights article are pretty well in agreement with the predictions (at least when the model of a homogeneously magnetized cylinder is used).

I'm pretty sure that a treatment including a possible spinning of the magnet is very complicated and, if satisfactorily treatable at all, only numerically possible.
 
  • #9
Simple experiment - put a paint mark on the top of the magnet, drop it down the tube and watch down the tube as the magnet falls. Your observation will indicate whether the magnet rotates or not.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71
  • #10
AndyG said:
Simple experiment - put a paint mark on the top of the magnet, drop it down the tube and watch down the tube as the magnet falls. Your observation will indicate whether the magnet rotates or not.
That's a simple enough observation. It also seems to me that there is no reason for the magnet to rotate as it falls. We know that Lenz's law dictates that eddy currents will always form in conductors to generate forces and torques that oppose the motion of magnets relative to such conductors. So if the magnet is dropped without initial spin, why should it start spinning?

I used to do this convincing demonstration of Lenz's law. Roll a wheel-shaped neodymium magnet down an aluminum incline. We all expect it to lose the race against a geometrically identical non-magnetized cylinder. But not always. If the non-magnetized wheel is angled towards one of the edges of the incline, it will roll off. When the magnetized wheel reaches an edge, it will twist away, cross over to the opposite edge as it rolls down, twist again and thus zig-zag down the length of the incline. How does it "know" to do that? Simple: you can't beat Lenz's law.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71
  • #11
kuruman said:
So if the magnet is dropped without initial spin, why should it start spinning?
Wouldn't it be very difficult to drop it bare-handed with negligible spin?
 

1. How does a magnet fall through a conducting pipe?

When a magnet is dropped through a conducting pipe, it experiences a change in magnetic flux. This change in flux induces an electric current in the pipe, which in turn creates a magnetic field that opposes the motion of the falling magnet. This opposing magnetic field slows down the magnet's fall until it reaches a terminal velocity.

2. What factors affect the speed of the falling magnet?

The speed at which a magnet falls through a conducting pipe is affected by the strength of the magnet, the length and diameter of the pipe, and the conductivity of the pipe material. A stronger magnet will fall faster, while a longer or wider pipe or a more conductive material will slow down the magnet's fall.

3. Can a magnet fall through a non-conducting pipe?

Yes, a magnet can fall through a non-conducting pipe, but it will not experience the same slowing effect as it would in a conducting pipe. This is because a non-conducting pipe does not allow for the induction of an electric current, so there is no opposing magnetic field to slow down the magnet's fall.

4. How can I model a magnet falling through a conducting pipe?

To model a magnet falling through a conducting pipe, you will need to use equations from electromagnetism, such as Faraday's law and Lenz's law. These equations will allow you to calculate the induced electric current and magnetic field, and ultimately the speed of the falling magnet. You will also need to know the properties of the magnet and pipe material, as well as the dimensions of the pipe.

5. What applications does this model have?

This model has applications in fields such as physics, engineering, and materials science. It can be used to study the effects of magnetic fields on moving objects, as well as the behavior of conducting materials. It can also be applied to the design and optimization of devices that use magnets and conductors, such as electromagnetic brakes and generators.

Similar threads

  • Classical Physics
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
5
Views
766
  • Electromagnetism
2
Replies
59
Views
4K
Replies
9
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
19
Views
953
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
20
Views
3K
Back
Top